Originally Posted by
smasha
No.
If someone wants to explain *why* an idea is wrong, and/or *why* other ideas are better, that's productive disagreement.
Instead, much of the discussion resembles bickering children, each insisting that their idea is best, and no one explaining why.
Also, I'm not convinced that my idea is the best, or even good. I'm not here looking for accolades, I'm here looking for discussion about what works and why. Maybe I'm in the wrong place...?
This is what you actually asked of the forum:
Originally Posted by
smasha
What does everyone else think?
Seems like you got just what you asked for.