I just read through the Crosscheck lovefest thread, and it seems most of you are commuting on Brooks saddles...
I'm a Brooks fan through and through. I have a Professional on my four road bikes and have had several other models in the past.
When I started all weather commuting last year I did a few rides in the rain on one of my Pro's and the color faded and the saddle was saturated. I then read some horror stories online about riding them wet causing them to prematurely sag and eventually tear. Since then I've been trying to find a saddle that is as comfortable as the Brooks (but not tensioned leather) for my commuter and I have come up empty handed...
How do your Brooks saddles hold up for the long haul after getting ridden wet?
(here is an old photo that shows my Brooks street cred)