Thanks for the suggestions. Interesting that y’all have had better luck with the Giro gloves. Only one of mine has an issue so perhaps it’s defective. I’ll check with Giro about a warranty replacement.
Someone suggested the Specialized Grail glove. I tried it, really liked it, but the padding in the palm bunched up after one ride. Reading online, it seems they used to stitch the padding in place but have since moved to a cheaper adhesive method which doesn’t seem to work too well. I contacted Specialized about my issue and what my research showed, they basically told me, “sucks, feel free to return them.”
I like the Pearl Izumi. I’ll check those out if I don’t have any luck with Giro.