I found a pair of the Specialized Torch 2.0 in my size at Jenson. I'd have sworn I'd looked at all the usual online shops when I first brought this up a few weeks ago, but they had them today. I saw a pair at CompetitiveCyclist but by the time I acted they were gone. As I said somewhere, finding sizes of anything in particular is hard as it is expensive to stock them all.
I'll try them and return them if they aren't right for me. I just put a new pair of Keo cleats on my existing shoes, so I'll just move those over if I keep the Torch. I also found a single Keo cleat in my box-o-junk. I don't remember what happened there that I only replaced one, I guess I just cracked one when still new. I would always just replace both even though the right is always more worn than the left.