Originally Posted by
Robbo_Rider
Really? Isn't carbon fiber stronger than aluminum,
It is, it has a nearly infinite fatigue life, but unlike aluminum, carbon is susceptible to cracks and damage from direct impact to the frame. For example, if you crash and lay the frame down sideways and part of the frame smashes against a rock...it may end up cracking. An aluminum frame is better in this regard.
I own 2 carbon bikes and one aluminum bike. I do prefer the ride feel of the carbon plus it's lighter weight.