What system was used by the two fitters? I also went to two fittings. One took my body measurements, punched them into some computer program, and it spat out the "ideal" setup for me. The second one was done with a Shimano fit system (
Shimano unveils new bike fitting system | Bicycle Retailer and Industry News ) where my body measurements were used as a starting point, and then dialed in - very accurately - as I pedaled on the fitting jig bike. Those measurements were transferred, by lasers, to my bike, and after small adjustments on the saddle and a minor change in stem, the bike is super comfortable to ride.
p.s.: the second fitting took almost 3 hours, was a lot more money, and was worth every penny.