Can we at least all agree that indexed front shifting, especially on doubles, is stupid?
Even when it works well, which it often does, it's pointless. GripShift and older Campy Ergopower show this clearly.
As to the larger question:
Indexed shifting is fine. Friction shifting is fine. I have, and have had, bikes with each. I have, and have had, no desire to spend any money to change any bike from one to the other.
Also, get off my lawn!
--Shannon