Originally Posted by
SethL
If I want to replace a 10 speed cassette, is it worth spending more $ to get a better quality one? I do have an extra tiagra 11-28 with low mileage but I am thinking its not the best option. Does it matter if I replace with a sram or shimano cassette? What about the other brands?
I assume it's how you define a "better" cassette. The more expensive ones (Shimano Dura Ace, SRAM Red) are the lightest cassettes, if weight is important. Otherwise the lower priced cassettes should work fine. Personally, I would stay with Shimano or SRAM. There are other brands available too, but I have no experience with those. A quick search at Amazon shows brands like Bibike and Bolany.
I've used both SRAM and Shimano cassettes with Shimano, KMC and SRAM chains, and all work well together.