Originally Posted by
noisebeam
For me Brooks was most comfortable out of the box. As mine aged and 'bucketed' it stopped providing support at my sit bones and instead increased pressure on my crotch area. I eventually got a plastic saddle which doesn't sag as it wears so the comfort does not change.
I 100% agree. New B-17 is really comfy, it gets less comfortable as it ages. I've given up on them, they don't last more than a year or two before they start getting way too soft.