If it were me, I’d get the Caledonia. Not that I love SRAM, but it’s got deeper and wider wheels and you can probably find some places to shed weight. I also like that geometry- it’s pretty close to the R3 and Aspero
I have a hard time buying that bike weighs over 19 pounds. My Aspero w/ GRX 800 2x weighs 18.5 pounds with Reserve 32mm wheels and 40mm tires that weigh 450g each and the base frame is heavier. It’s gotta be a misprint- I’m guessing it’s 18# or less