Originally Posted by
inspclouseau
Why fork mount for roof tops? Seems like extra work needlessly?
I had both, and can say that the fork mount seems far more secure. The bike seemed to move around a bit with the frame mounted rack.
I currently have 2 Thule fork mounted Echelon bike trays on a roof rack of my sedan. It removes easily with the help of a second person and I store it away during winter or when I am going on a long drive and don't want the wind noise and loss of mpgs. Otherwise, I prefer the roof rack because my bike does not fit easily in my car (need to put seats down and really wiggle it in there) and I still have use of the interior of my car. I drive a Saab and there are no reasonably priced trailer hitches available for it (awd model 9-3)
I would like to find a rack to use with my old hatchback Camaro. I see someone on the internet used a Saris Bones, but he had to get creative with the attachment points. I am thinking about the Saris Gran Fondo, though. Because it is higher up, it would be easier to hook onto my car. Not sure about how secure it is, though.