juntjoo

It's the one on the right. From an older Fuji Royale road bike. Can I adapt the black ones on somehow? Maybe replace the spindles? The crank arms just have threaded holes for them. This is the first time I've worked on pedals. Most I've learned is to loosen backwards on both pedals due to the opposite threads

csport

The one on the right is the normal one.

I think the one on the left is missing the small axle which threads into the pedal with one end and into the crank arm with the other end. The purpose of this design is to be able to replace this small axle making the pedal compatible with both 9/16 and 1/2 threads.

Leisesturm

You only loosen (and tighten) 'backwards' on the left hand (non-drive side)pedal. The pedal on the drive (chain) side has 'normal' threading and behaves like you would expect. The pedals pictured on the right are not (IMO) antiquated just yet, it is more the case that the black ones are unique, in my experience. WTF. Can you position the camera for a view into the end of the pedal? I've seen newish pedals use 8mm Allen keys for installation/removal; with or without 'flats' for crescent wrenches, but the threading still has to be external to go into the crankarm.

cxwrench

You don't say?

Ross200

+1. Blackburn universal pedal set at WallyWorld for $8.36 resembles the black one. One size DOES fit all-except DynaDrive. Leisestrum will see MANY more of these as Specialized and Trek corporate stores take over the world! They have the Walton family running scared-

These are what you get at midnight Saturday at Walmart when you realize you drove eight hours to the campsite and brought your road shoes instead of your off road shoes, the ride starts at 6 am and the nearest bike shop opens on Tuesday two hours away. They DID kinda much the graphics on my friend's Lynskey with the carbon cranks-very stylish!

SurferRosa

Maybe you haven't heard, but this is a convention for people to remember how to loosen a pedal regardless of side (left or right). Both loosen by turning a wrench held at 12:00 "backwards" toward the rear wheel.

juntjoo

Well that may be why they were on sale at Walmart. Missing pieces.

juntjoo

Sorry . I figured the one on the left was the "normal" and didn't focus on it. Seems the consensus is I got it backwards

juntjoo

Most won't like this but I ride barefoot. And the metal is a little tough. Would like the plastic as I have on my other bikes

Crankycrank

Check your local bike shop for some cheap plastic pedals as some keep a box of orphan pedals from new bikes that were changed out. I think these types of pedals would be more comfortable with bare feet, but you can always sand/grind/cut the teeth off of plastic pedals fairly easily. Just an example Giant Urbano Bike Commuting and Crusing Pedals – Bicycle Warehouse

mitchmellow62

I agree. My one experience with this type of pedal wasn't good. My grandson (12 at the time) was able to destroy them in short order. I can't recommend them.

cxwrench

Except for kid's bikes that have 1/2" pedal axles.

Ross200

The Blackburn pedals come with both 1/2 and 9/16 stubs. Sorry no French threads-my bad.

ClydeClydeson

There are much better pedals for riding barefoot. Anything with a 'cage' is less than optimal.

For example:

https://www.walmart.ca/en/ip/9-16-In...m/5GNZ9JP6MOBK

Other types are available, this was just the first ones I found with an image and a working link.

Here's some fancy ones:

https://www.amazon.ca/Look-Geo-City-...8KGQRYLH&psc=1

Camilo

I think we've all learned that flat pedals are flat pedals as long as the let you to be able to ride!

Camilo

Before you posted this, I was going to say, the plastic flat pedals I've seen all have some sort of design meant to grip the shoe - the little protruding teeth on the OP's example and the molded in pins in others. I was going to suggest that for barefoot riding, I'd personally file down to make them smooth flat. Both of your examples would be preferable to me for sure, were I to ride barefoot like i did for miles and miles and miles around the neighborhood when I was a kid. But the pedals we had were like the Walmart example you posted with the rubber surfaces on both sides of the pedal spindle.

I'm sure I'm not the only one that gets a little impatient with newbies posting the same question over and over. But I believe this is the first time I've seen a thread on the best pedal for barefoot riding, and it's very refreshing!

I am waiting for some know-it-all to criticize the OP for riding barefoot. I say, go for it, and enjoy the feeling of bare feet in a warm breeze!

juntjoo

Thanks for all the tips. But I ain't paying more than $10 for pedals if even. Got those black ones for $5. I'm hoping to snag a free bike being donated as they are from time to time. I can wait. Or get a whole bike from a thrift store for cheap and part it out.

One of you suggested grinding down my stock pedals but they're original so I want to keep em, or even use em if I decide to use shoes say like in winter.

csport

Yes, if for some reason the bare foot slips off the pedal and hits the ground there will be dire consequences.

What Crankycrank said. Or something like this:
https://www.randombikeparts.com/coll...muter-bike-new

But these resin pedals are for sissies. Chuck Norris rides road clipless, his feet have integrated cleats for that.

juntjoo

Thanks. Those look worth considering