Giant Fastroad SL1, any1 got 1, thoughts vs trek FX 3 /FX2
#1
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Giant Fastroad SL1, any1 got 1, thoughts vs trek FX 3 /FX2
HiSo I have trek FX 2 disc with nearly a year very good bike imo (having said that I haven't too much to reference it off)
I had trek FX 7.2 previous which apart from disc brakes was pretty much as good.
I got the itch to upgrade and balancing price etc ended up with giant fastroad sl 1
Ive had few rides on it and I can't really say I'm blown away.
It does come in light for the money 9.8kg , does have carbon fork and 105 drivetrain , comparing to sl3 it would appear 380 euro pays for the 105 over Claris ( weather those upgrades matter to a leisurely cyclists like me , probably not)
The bike does feel a bit sportier , but feels faster than it is , if GPS is correct , and probably that little bit smoother.
But looking at stats from trek FX 2 , the trek seems to be the faster bike some how.
Just wondering, does anyone else have the giant fastroad sl 1, if so what you think ,
Personally if FX 2 is anything thing to judge by, my thinking would be if you put 105 on trek FX 3 be better bike than the giant .
Just interested in other , more experienced riders views, thanks
I had trek FX 7.2 previous which apart from disc brakes was pretty much as good.
I got the itch to upgrade and balancing price etc ended up with giant fastroad sl 1
Ive had few rides on it and I can't really say I'm blown away.
It does come in light for the money 9.8kg , does have carbon fork and 105 drivetrain , comparing to sl3 it would appear 380 euro pays for the 105 over Claris ( weather those upgrades matter to a leisurely cyclists like me , probably not)
The bike does feel a bit sportier , but feels faster than it is , if GPS is correct , and probably that little bit smoother.
But looking at stats from trek FX 2 , the trek seems to be the faster bike some how.
Just wondering, does anyone else have the giant fastroad sl 1, if so what you think ,
Personally if FX 2 is anything thing to judge by, my thinking would be if you put 105 on trek FX 3 be better bike than the giant .
Just interested in other , more experienced riders views, thanks
#2
Full Member
Join Date: Aug 2021
Posts: 263
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 102 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 55 Times
in
48 Posts
When you say "faster", do you mean easier acceleration? Cos if I'm not wrong the FX3 is a 40T and the '21 FX2 is 3x 48/38/28 crank, and the Giant is 50/34? On the top end, there is no way either will have faster top speed. The FRSL1 is lighter, better geared for speed, so it shouldn't be slower in any way. Maybe you are just not accustomed to the gearing choice? Going from 3x9 to 2x10 can sometimes leave you in the wrong gear a lot. Or it could be a grippy tire thing. I know when I switched to the GP5000U and Marathon Supreme OneStars, most other tires feel slow and not grippy.
#3
Junior Member
Thread Starter
When you say "faster", do you mean easier acceleration? Cos if I'm not wrong the FX3 is a 40T and the '21 FX2 is 3x 48/38/28 crank, and the Giant is 50/34? On the top end, there is no way either will have faster top speed. The FRSL1 is lighter, better geared for speed, so it shouldn't be slower in any way. Maybe you are just not accustomed to the gearing choice? Going from 3x9 to 2x10 can sometimes leave you in the wrong gear a lot. Or it could be a grippy tire thing. I know when I switched to the GP5000U and Marathon Supreme OneStars, most other tires feel slow and not grippy.
And you must be right , it must be me with the gearing ,
I could never reach top speed on either bike , but the cycles I have done on fsl1 on routes I've done numerous times the data would suggest I hit higher speeds more consistently on trek , I agree it doesn't make sense , I just expected if anything for it to be other way around, it maybe is my gearing
Likes For Masonchat:
#4
Full Member
Join Date: Aug 2021
Posts: 263
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 102 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 55 Times
in
48 Posts
Well I have to say when I change my gearing to a smaller larger rear cog on my Pinions, I occasionally go by number of clicks vs actually feel of the pedal when I'm watching out for traffic etc, out of habit, so I end up pedaling in a lower gear for longer. And it isn't just higher speeds but average speeds. Once I went to a Pinion, my average speed went up 1+ mph, even though my max speed was around the same, cos I calculated the gearing that way. However, the fastest upgrade I did was going to very fast tires. That shaved minutes off my commute.
#5
Junior Member
Is the fit the same on both bikes?
__________________
2011 Trek Madone 5.2 WSD
2009 Trek 2.1 WSD
2011 Trek Madone 5.2 WSD
2009 Trek 2.1 WSD
Likes For pinsonp2:
#6
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Likes For Masonchat:
#7
Junior Member
Thread Starter
well this bike is starting to really boil my pi## , had another cycle , beautiful day here in Ireland , was really enjoying the cycle and thought I'd be posting a positive post.
There is something about the bike I love, it's definitely more aggressive geometry , I find myself constantly wanting to push myself when I ride it and end up cycling further than I intendedAll was well until a spoke broke , at least I was close to home but not what you expect from a new bike really is it.
First spoke I've ever had break in 5 years of cycling , the spokes fell very flimsy when compared to the trek which I did when I got home .
I'm paranoid now , are the wheels that bad?
There is something about the bike I love, it's definitely more aggressive geometry , I find myself constantly wanting to push myself when I ride it and end up cycling further than I intendedAll was well until a spoke broke , at least I was close to home but not what you expect from a new bike really is it.
First spoke I've ever had break in 5 years of cycling , the spokes fell very flimsy when compared to the trek which I did when I got home .
I'm paranoid now , are the wheels that bad?
#8
Full Member
Join Date: Aug 2021
Posts: 263
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 102 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 55 Times
in
48 Posts
Haha, stuff like that happens. I've done my share of stupid things like bend a CX-Ray with a pannier bag bottom hook! Most of the OE spokes are just generic 14g stainless steel, unless you get to the higher models. I suggest moving to Sapim or Pillar Wing spokes. Or better yet, even upgrade to some Hunt Alloy Aeros.
If your telemetry still shows you being a little slower, check your cadence in certain corners where the FX2 is faster. Should show which gear you're in and indicate under or over gearing.
If your telemetry still shows you being a little slower, check your cadence in certain corners where the FX2 is faster. Should show which gear you're in and indicate under or over gearing.
Last edited by Sardines; 01-04-22 at 03:31 PM.
#9
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Haha, stuff like that happens. I've done my share of stupid things like bend a CX-Ray with a pannier bag bottom hook! Most of the OE spokes are just generic 14g stainless steel, unless you get to the higher models. I suggest moving to Sapim or Pillar Wing spokes. Or better yet, even upgrade to some Hunt Alloy Aeros.
If your telemetry still shows you being a little slower, check your cadence in certain corners where the FX2 is faster. Should show which gear you're in and indicate under or over gearing.
If your telemetry still shows you being a little slower, check your cadence in certain corners where the FX2 is faster. Should show which gear you're in and indicate under or over gearing.
Thanks sardines, I will look up those wheels , the trek is 14g stainless steel and they are very solid in comparison , the giant gx wheel set doesnt say ,
I'm not a cyclist as this data will prove but this is data from today's ride if any good for analysis , first time have cadence sensor
I'm not a cyclist as this data will prove but this is data from today's ride if any good for analysis , first time have cadence sensor
#10
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Sardines, I looked at the hunt aero , are they for rim brakes only , bit pricey at moment anyway after dropping 1300 euro on bike , continental gp5000 tyres coming and GPS comp 🙄, I'll be selling a kidney 😆
#11
Junior Member
Thread Starter
If I do upgrade wheels can any one please tell me what specs I'm looking out for , hub size , disc 6 bolt ?? Etc that will work with fsl1 as this data not given by giant and I'm as green as Lettuce with the tech stuff , in case ye couldn't tell already 😄
#12
Full Member
Join Date: Aug 2021
Posts: 263
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 102 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 55 Times
in
48 Posts
The Hunt Aeros come in disc as well, just go thru their site and look for the Aero 34 or Aero Light alloys. They are UK produced so you should be able to call them to ask about the right wheels for you. They will come with all axle adapters. A savings of 500g will give your bike a new kick in the pants, not to mention the aero benefits. You can also buy the rotors from them as well.
Last edited by Sardines; 01-04-22 at 07:28 PM.
#13
Junior Member
Thread Starter
The Hunt Aeros come in disc as well, just go thru their site and look for the Aero 34 or Aero Light alloys. They are UK produced so you should be able to call them to ask about the right wheels for you. They will come with all axle adapters. A savings of 500g will give your bike a new kick in the pants, not to mention the aero benefits. You can also buy the rotors from them as well.
#14
Full Member
Join Date: Aug 2021
Posts: 263
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 102 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 55 Times
in
48 Posts
Or you could do what my kid did for her FX6 and find a set of lightly used light Bontrager Paradigm Comp wheels for under $200 as an upgrade. Used wheels are an option, but obviously depending on the quality etc.
Sapim has quite a few grades and I'm pretty sure Giant is too big to break margins and give good quality like the CX bladed range.
Sapim has quite a few grades and I'm pretty sure Giant is too big to break margins and give good quality like the CX bladed range.
#15
Junior Member
Thread Starter
The Hunt Aeros come in disc as well, just go thru their site and look for the Aero 34 or Aero Light alloys. They are UK produced so you should be able to call them to ask about the right wheels for you. They will come with all axle adapters. A savings of 500g will give your bike a new kick in the pants, not to mention the aero benefits. You can also buy the rotors from them as well.
Would the stock wheelset have any sell on value
#16
Full Member
Join Date: Aug 2021
Posts: 263
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 102 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 55 Times
in
48 Posts
Well congratulations! Personally I'd repair the wheel and keep it as a spare, if you have the space. But it really depends on where you are and what the market is for used bike parts for value.
I would just buy new rotors and pads and break them in. Centerlocks are better and the adapter adds weight, so I'd make the switch. Make sure they are trued as well. Enjoy!
I would just buy new rotors and pads and break them in. Centerlocks are better and the adapter adds weight, so I'd make the switch. Make sure they are trued as well. Enjoy!
Likes For Sardines:
#17
Junior Member
Thread Starter
The Hunt Aeros come in disc as well, just go thru their site and look for the Aero 34 or Aero Light alloys. They are UK produced so you should be able to call them to ask about the right wheels for you. They will come with all axle adapters. A savings of 500g will give your bike a new kick in the pants, not to mention the aero benefits. You can also buy the rotors from them as well.
Well congratulations! Personally I'd repair the wheel and keep it as a spare, if you have the space. But it really depends on where you are and what the market is for used bike parts for value.
I would just buy new rotors and pads and break them in. Centerlocks are better and the adapter adds weight, so I'd make the switch. Make sure they are trued as well. Enjoy!
I would just buy new rotors and pads and break them in. Centerlocks are better and the adapter adds weight, so I'd make the switch. Make sure they are trued as well. Enjoy!
Noob in trouble again so , ok so my current rotors I think front is 160mm 6 bolt and rear is 140mm 6 bolt
If I'm making switch to centre lock what rotors would I be ordering , do the wheels not come trued and would my current pads not do as hardly used yet ? Sorry for all the questions
#19
Full Member
Join Date: Aug 2021
Posts: 263
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 102 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 55 Times
in
48 Posts
I'd just order the rims with the rotors installed by Hunt. Just the cheapest Shimanos Icetech will work fine. I would go with 160mm all round, and don't forget to get a bracket for your rear caliper to raise it up to fit the 160mm. I would get better pads as well while you're at it. You should be able to get this from your LBS, when they install the stuff. I assume you won't be doing this yourself?
I would even go as far as to go tubeless with your new wheels.
I would even go as far as to go tubeless with your new wheels.
Thanks , and help ha .
Noob in trouble again so , ok so my current rotors I think front is 160mm 6 bolt and rear is 140mm 6 bolt
If I'm making switch to centre lock what rotors would I be ordering , do the wheels not come trued and would my current pads not do as hardly used yet ? Sorry for all the questions
Noob in trouble again so , ok so my current rotors I think front is 160mm 6 bolt and rear is 140mm 6 bolt
If I'm making switch to centre lock what rotors would I be ordering , do the wheels not come trued and would my current pads not do as hardly used yet ? Sorry for all the questions
#20
Junior Member
Thread Starter
I'd just order the rims with the rotors installed by Hunt. Just the cheapest Shimanos Icetech will work fine. I would go with 160mm all round, and don't forget to get a bracket for your rear caliper to raise it up to fit the 160mm. I would get better pads as well while you're at it. You should be able to get this from your LBS, when they install the stuff. I assume you won't be doing this yourself?
I would even go as far as to go tubeless with your new wheels.
I would even go as far as to go tubeless with your new wheels.
Now hunt say no problem they can send out adaptors for the quick release and wheels be fine
But is that ok /acceptable ? Would wheels ride the same or should I return them at Futher cost and delay ??
Likes For Sardines:
#22
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Likes For Masonchat:
Likes For Sardines:
#24
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Well I haven't riden it since spoke went , so I haven't but I've decided it's not a big thing , I really enjoy riding the bike which is the main thing I suppose.
I tend to go further than planned when riding it and do feel it is more energy efficient
Could well be gearing issue as you said , few more rides might tell a lot .
Really looking forward to getting out on it with new wheels and tyres
I tend to go further than planned when riding it and do feel it is more energy efficient
Could well be gearing issue as you said , few more rides might tell a lot .
Really looking forward to getting out on it with new wheels and tyres
Likes For Masonchat:
#25
Full Member
Join Date: Aug 2021
Posts: 263
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 102 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 55 Times
in
48 Posts
I would fix that spoke. It's simple to do and cheap to true the wheels. Always nice to have spare wheel to keep riding when things like spokes or tires go.
Well I haven't riden it since spoke went , so I haven't but I've decided it's not a big thing , I really enjoy riding the bike which is the main thing I suppose.
I tend to go further than planned when riding it and do feel it is more energy efficient
Could well be gearing issue as you said , few more rides might tell a lot .
Really looking forward to getting out on it with new wheels and tyres
I tend to go further than planned when riding it and do feel it is more energy efficient
Could well be gearing issue as you said , few more rides might tell a lot .
Really looking forward to getting out on it with new wheels and tyres