advice to make wheel build stronger, more durable
#1
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2021
Posts: 12
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 7 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 5 Times
in
4 Posts
advice to make wheel build stronger, more durable
looking to build a set of wheels for my gravel bike. I keep cracking rims at spoke holes especially drive side rear. I have checked spoke tension and it is within spec for wheel and even across all spokes. these wheels were built by my lbs and, I thought, a good wheel builder. I ride about 5k miles a year and about half of that on my gravel bike.
this is my plan- 35mm deep carbon asymmetric rim(disc brake), 24mm inside diameter(hookless) to run 700x35c tubeless(maybe 38c), dt aero comp spokes(32H), I will reuse my dt swiss 240s hubs. I have tension meter, dish gauge, wheel stand and lots of patience to get spoke tension even and as close to spec as possible.
I have been taking apart and rebuilding some rims in my shop with good results. I think I have the understanding and patience needed for a good build.
I would love any feedback so thanks in advance for constructive comments
this is my plan- 35mm deep carbon asymmetric rim(disc brake), 24mm inside diameter(hookless) to run 700x35c tubeless(maybe 38c), dt aero comp spokes(32H), I will reuse my dt swiss 240s hubs. I have tension meter, dish gauge, wheel stand and lots of patience to get spoke tension even and as close to spec as possible.
I have been taking apart and rebuilding some rims in my shop with good results. I think I have the understanding and patience needed for a good build.
I would love any feedback so thanks in advance for constructive comments
#3
Senior Member
What make/material rims are you cracking and what kind of riding are you doing on the bike? Also you say north of 200lb, how far north?
The build seems sound, however, if you have a destructive history I'd be making some changes. First, I'd go for the triple butted Alpine 3 spokes. They'll be more forgiving with the extra flex capability. I'd also consider being very picky about the rim you use. No doubt you've done some research, but Light Bicycle used to do a heavy rider spec carbon rim when I built my track wheels. Only a little more weight, but more material around the spoke area. Not sure If they still do the same, but I'd be looking for a rim that is beefier in that section compared to others, especially with your history. If you continue to crack at the spoke holes then you'd need to give some serious consideration to going to an eyeletted rim or reducing your spoke tension a little and dealing with the little bit of extra flex.
On top of that, also pay consideration to where you're riding and how you're riding. Maybe your style needs some changes to be more sympathetic to your equipment
** I also build my own wheels and while it's not a necessity, the Park Tools spoke tension app is a very hand little tool when it comes to the fine tuning towards the end of the build and in truing a wheel
The build seems sound, however, if you have a destructive history I'd be making some changes. First, I'd go for the triple butted Alpine 3 spokes. They'll be more forgiving with the extra flex capability. I'd also consider being very picky about the rim you use. No doubt you've done some research, but Light Bicycle used to do a heavy rider spec carbon rim when I built my track wheels. Only a little more weight, but more material around the spoke area. Not sure If they still do the same, but I'd be looking for a rim that is beefier in that section compared to others, especially with your history. If you continue to crack at the spoke holes then you'd need to give some serious consideration to going to an eyeletted rim or reducing your spoke tension a little and dealing with the little bit of extra flex.
On top of that, also pay consideration to where you're riding and how you're riding. Maybe your style needs some changes to be more sympathetic to your equipment
** I also build my own wheels and while it's not a necessity, the Park Tools spoke tension app is a very hand little tool when it comes to the fine tuning towards the end of the build and in truing a wheel
Last edited by brawlo; 03-08-21 at 05:09 PM.
#4
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2021
Posts: 12
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 7 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 5 Times
in
4 Posts
What make/material rims are you cracking and what kind of riding are you doing on the bike? Also you say north of 200lb, how far north?
The build seems sound, however, if you have a destructive history I'd be making some changes. First, I'd go for the triple butted Alpine 3 spokes. They'll be more forgiving with the extra flex capability. I'd also consider being very picky about the rim you use. No doubt you've done some research, but Light Bicycle used to do a heavy rider spec carbon rim when I built my track wheels. Only a little more weight, but more material around the spoke area. Not sure If they still do the same, but I'd be looking for a rim that is beefier in that section compared to others, especially with your history. If you continue to crack at the spoke holes then you'd need to give some serious consideration to going to an eyeletted rim or reducing your spoke tension a little and dealing with the little bit of extra flex.
On top of that, also pay consideration to where you're riding and how you're riding. Maybe your style needs some changes to be more sympathetic to your equipment
** I also build my own wheels and while it's not a necessity, the Park Tools spoke tension app is a very hand little tool when it comes to the fine tuning towards the end of the build and in truing a wheel
The build seems sound, however, if you have a destructive history I'd be making some changes. First, I'd go for the triple butted Alpine 3 spokes. They'll be more forgiving with the extra flex capability. I'd also consider being very picky about the rim you use. No doubt you've done some research, but Light Bicycle used to do a heavy rider spec carbon rim when I built my track wheels. Only a little more weight, but more material around the spoke area. Not sure If they still do the same, but I'd be looking for a rim that is beefier in that section compared to others, especially with your history. If you continue to crack at the spoke holes then you'd need to give some serious consideration to going to an eyeletted rim or reducing your spoke tension a little and dealing with the little bit of extra flex.
On top of that, also pay consideration to where you're riding and how you're riding. Maybe your style needs some changes to be more sympathetic to your equipment
** I also build my own wheels and while it's not a necessity, the Park Tools spoke tension app is a very hand little tool when it comes to the fine tuning towards the end of the build and in truing a wheel
thanks no snark intended, but I don't think I have a "destructive history" I do ride with a lot of torque but I am cautious about impacts and approach bumps and root pops off the saddle with a bended leg. I think the velocity blunt 35 rim was the wrong choice of hoops, for this is the second set to crack. I have a road bike with dt swiss 411 rims which i ride more and probably with more watts and it is holding up wonderfully, also a city bike with a $100 set of weinmann wheels, and my fixie all without issues. the rim i selected has a stated weight of 205kg so I'm looking forward to inspecting it when it arrives, at that point I'll decide on spokes. the other issue which i discovered upon research, after trusting bike shop for choice of rims, is that the blunt 35's are way to wide for the tires i run, which i can't see causing spoke hole cracking. it has a 30.2 inside diameter so it is meant for tires 50c+ and I run 35-38c. the rim i ordered has an ID of 25mm.
Likes For mbpletcher:
#6
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2013
Location: Yolo County, West Sacramento CA
Posts: 517
Bikes: Modified 26 inch frame Schwinn Varsity with 700c wheels and 10 speed cassette hub. Ryan Vanguard recumbent. 67cm 27"x1 1/4" Schwinn Sports Tourer from the 1980's. 1980's 68cm Nishiki Sebring with 700c aero wheels, 30 speeds, flat bar bicycle.
Mentioned: 12 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 131 Post(s)
Liked 141 Times
in
102 Posts
thanks no snark intended, but I don't think I have a "destructive history" I do ride with a lot of torque but I am cautious about impacts and approach bumps and root pops off the saddle with a bended leg. I think the velocity blunt 35 rim was the wrong choice of hoops, for this is the second set to crack. I have a road bike with dt swiss 411 rims which i ride more and probably with more watts and it is holding up wonderfully, also a city bike with a $100 set of weinmann wheels, and my fixie all without issues. the rim i selected has a stated weight of 205kg so I'm looking forward to inspecting it when it arrives, at that point I'll decide on spokes. the other issue which i discovered upon research, after trusting bike shop for choice of rims, is that the blunt 35's are way to wide for the tires i run, which i can't see causing spoke hole cracking. it has a 30.2 inside diameter so it is meant for tires 50c+ and I run 35-38c. the rim i ordered has an ID of 25mm.
#7
Senior Member
thanks no snark intended, but I don't think I have a "destructive history" I do ride with a lot of torque but I am cautious about impacts and approach bumps and root pops off the saddle with a bended leg. I think the velocity blunt 35 rim was the wrong choice of hoops, for this is the second set to crack. I have a road bike with dt swiss 411 rims which i ride more and probably with more watts and it is holding up wonderfully, also a city bike with a $100 set of weinmann wheels, and my fixie all without issues. the rim i selected has a stated weight of 205kg so I'm looking forward to inspecting it when it arrives, at that point I'll decide on spokes. the other issue which i discovered upon research, after trusting bike shop for choice of rims, is that the blunt 35's are way to wide for the tires i run, which i can't see causing spoke hole cracking. it has a 30.2 inside diameter so it is meant for tires 50c+ and I run 35-38c. the rim i ordered has an ID of 25mm.
I really can't believe that the builder specced those rims for your build!!?? I'd be steering anyone I came across from using that person!
#8
Full Member
Join Date: Oct 2017
Location: South Carolina
Posts: 218
Bikes: Felt ZR3, Specialized Sectur
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 100 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 52 Times
in
37 Posts
looking to build a set of wheels for my gravel bike. I keep cracking rims at spoke holes especially drive side rear. I have checked spoke tension and it is within spec for wheel and even across all spokes. these wheels were built by my lbs and, I thought, a good wheel builder. I ride about 5k miles a year and about half of that on my gravel bike.
this is my plan- 35mm deep carbon asymmetric rim(disc brake), 24mm inside diameter(hookless) to run 700x35c tubeless(maybe 38c), dt aero comp spokes(32H), I will reuse my dt swiss 240s hubs. I have tension meter, dish gauge, wheel stand and lots of patience to get spoke tension even and as close to spec as possible.
I have been taking apart and rebuilding some rims in my shop with good results. I think I have the understanding and patience needed for a good build.
I would love any feedback so thanks in advance for constructive comments
this is my plan- 35mm deep carbon asymmetric rim(disc brake), 24mm inside diameter(hookless) to run 700x35c tubeless(maybe 38c), dt aero comp spokes(32H), I will reuse my dt swiss 240s hubs. I have tension meter, dish gauge, wheel stand and lots of patience to get spoke tension even and as close to spec as possible.
I have been taking apart and rebuilding some rims in my shop with good results. I think I have the understanding and patience needed for a good build.
I would love any feedback so thanks in advance for constructive comments
Just my opinion. If you are under 185, I would "consider" carbon but anything over 185, no way. To much weight in my opinion and then you have off road conditions that literally abuse the rims. Again, just my opinion but carbon is not going to make you any faster unless you average over 24mph. They look cool and everything but the downside is cost. My wheel build with the rim and labor was 250 and has been bullet proof. So at my weight, things get more complicated especially wheel sets. Not sure if it would help, but the site is No gas wheels. Just google no gas wheels. Maybe you could call him and get some advice. He does very good work. I don't personally know him either I just went to the shop he gets work out of and they took it from there.
Good luck.
john
#9
Drip, Drip.
Join Date: Oct 2020
Location: Southern Ontario
Posts: 1,575
Bikes: Trek Verve E bike, Felt Doctrine 4 XC, Opus Horizon Apex 1
Mentioned: 8 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1034 Post(s)
Liked 193 Times
in
163 Posts
- Youre not heavy enough to be destroying any rims unless wheel is not tensioned properly, likely too much tension on drive side which can easily cause cracks in carbon rim
- even a cheap wheelset that is properly tensioned should not lose its true let alone break at your weight.
- the way you fit onto the bike could affect how smoothly you ride over rough obstacles. A poor frame fit is much more likely to cause bent wheels
-more spokes =/= stronger wheel
- even a cheap wheelset that is properly tensioned should not lose its true let alone break at your weight.
- the way you fit onto the bike could affect how smoothly you ride over rough obstacles. A poor frame fit is much more likely to cause bent wheels
-more spokes =/= stronger wheel
#10
Drip, Drip.
Join Date: Oct 2020
Location: Southern Ontario
Posts: 1,575
Bikes: Trek Verve E bike, Felt Doctrine 4 XC, Opus Horizon Apex 1
Mentioned: 8 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1034 Post(s)
Liked 193 Times
in
163 Posts
I recommend sticking to a more basic wheelset,.or at the very least avoid carbon. Get a spoke key and ensure that you regularly maintain ideal spoke tension in the rear wheel. This is what you really need,
#11
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2021
Posts: 12
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 7 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 5 Times
in
4 Posts
spoke tension was always even and at high end of spec., but below too tight, without ever having to adjust. a properly built wheel should not need regular maintenance of spoke tension. I have a spoke key, and some spoke wrenches, tension meter, wheel stand, dish gauge, and have been enjoying taking apart a cheap set of wheels and rebuilding them better.
after speaking with velocity about the blunt 35 rims they have stated that the weight of me, my bike, and gear is not compatible with the blunts, though this is not stated anywhere. they offered my 50% off of another rim of my choice, but they don't have anything that I'm interested in.
I will be building wheels on 35mm deep asymmetric carbon rims with 32 double butted spokes and I am confident they will be strong and durable and work great for me and my bike.
opinions are like elbows, everyone usually has a couple
after speaking with velocity about the blunt 35 rims they have stated that the weight of me, my bike, and gear is not compatible with the blunts, though this is not stated anywhere. they offered my 50% off of another rim of my choice, but they don't have anything that I'm interested in.
I will be building wheels on 35mm deep asymmetric carbon rims with 32 double butted spokes and I am confident they will be strong and durable and work great for me and my bike.
opinions are like elbows, everyone usually has a couple
#12
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2017
Location: Northern Virginia
Posts: 727
Bikes: Current: 2016 Bianchi Volpe; 1973 Peugeot UO-8. Past: 1974 Fuji S-10-S with custom black Imron paint by Stinsman Racing of PA.
Mentioned: 2 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 215 Post(s)
Liked 204 Times
in
142 Posts
spoke tension was always even and at high end of spec., but below too tight, without ever having to adjust. a properly built wheel should not need regular maintenance of spoke tension. I have a spoke key, and some spoke wrenches, tension meter, wheel stand, dish gauge, and have been enjoying taking apart a cheap set of wheels and rebuilding them better.
after speaking with velocity about the blunt 35 rims they have stated that the weight of me, my bike, and gear is not compatible with the blunts, though this is not stated anywhere. they offered my 50% off of another rim of my choice, but they don't have anything that I'm interested in.
I will be building wheels on 35mm deep asymmetric carbon rims with 32 double butted spokes and I am confident they will be strong and durable and work great for me and my bike.
opinions are like elbows, everyone usually has a couple
after speaking with velocity about the blunt 35 rims they have stated that the weight of me, my bike, and gear is not compatible with the blunts, though this is not stated anywhere. they offered my 50% off of another rim of my choice, but they don't have anything that I'm interested in.
I will be building wheels on 35mm deep asymmetric carbon rims with 32 double butted spokes and I am confident they will be strong and durable and work great for me and my bike.
opinions are like elbows, everyone usually has a couple
Maybe I am reading this wrong, but you were looking for opinions and got them. If you were already convinced you were on the right track, why ask for opinions?