gearbasher

It seems merziac and I are in the minority when it comes to bottom bracket fixed cups ( see https://www.bikeforums.net/classic-v...ight-pull.html ). So, here's a poll to see if we have any allies.

leftthread

Include a fifth category: fixed cup removal only to install a cartridge bb.

gearbasher

Good idea, only I can't figure out how to add it or it won't let me. Anyhow, that might fall into the only if damaged option.

non-fixie 

My approach:

• if just for maintenance, I'll check for damage and if none is apparent, I'll check if it is still tight and most often just clean and grease it in situ
• if it is to be replaced with a shorter/longer/whatever different type, I'll remove it. If that turns out to be a risk and it is in good shape, I will reconsider the replacement and look for other options
• if it needs to come out because it is damaged or I really want that particular Gipiemme triple, it comes out, no matter what

I voted "Only if damaged".

merziac

You forgot the "Always" option too.

Pompiere

Before I got the proper tools, I would leave the fixed cup in place and clean it the best I could from the opposite side. Now, I don't think twice about removing the fixed cup to do a proper overhaul.

gearbasher

I think that one falls into the on a regular basis option.

merziac

This is the only correct answer.

merziac

Maybe, and that's how I voted but it leaves wiggle room where there is none for me.

Hobbiano 

Now and then.

Andy_K 

This would be my vote, though I fear it may not be a sustainable solution for long with Italian bottom brackets. Maybe Velo Orange will step up, but it seems that Shimano has stopped making square taper Italian threaded bottom brackets (or at least I couldn't find a new one when I needed it recently). Since cartridge BBs aren't serviceable, there may come a day when I find myself looking for vintage cup and cone bottom brackets to replace them as they fail.

Of course, this leaves the original question. Suppose you have a cartridge bottom bracket that last for an improbably long time. For instance, maybe you invested in a Phil Wood and after 20,000 miles it's still spinning smoothly. Would you ever remove it just to regrease the threads? Me personally? No.

So I voted, only when damaged.

gearbasher

Yes, I would remove it just to regrease the threads. This would assure it can be easily removed when it needs to be replaced. 15 minutes of preventive maintenance can save hours of frustration.

scarlson 

I like to maintain fixed cups in situ if possible. However, there are lots of reasons to remove one.
I will remove a fixed cup based on a couple criteria considered at the same time.

I consider, in the following order:

1. Is it damaged? If it is, sure, take out by whatever means necessary, unless I believe the bike is not really going to be ridden much at all.
2. Can I get it out? If I can easily, sure, take it out.
3. Is it RH or LH threaded? I am more likely to leave in an RH threaded fixed cup because it might be stuck (and that's a good thing in this case) and it might be hard to find another one!
4. What's the future use going to look like? If it's going to be commuted on in salt and weather, or ridden in muddy sandy areas, I will remove it and change it for a sealed BB regardless of the condition, to save the future strife.
5. What's the BB? If it's worth saving/preserving/reselling, and not on this bike, then I'll take it out and replace it with something appropriate for the quality level of the bike and its expected duty. I might even consider polishing the pitting out of an old damaged cup from a respectable marque, depending on the extent of the damage. There is absolutely no sense in leaving a nice Campy or Stronglight or TA BB on a bike which is going to be used for all weather touring or commuting!

Basically, be sensible. There are always exceptions.

merziac

madpogue 

I'm between choices 3 and 4, leaning toward 4, esp. since reading the recent admonitions of some of the "do it every time" purists. So far I haven't had one thwart me yet, but I suppose if I encounter one that really puts up a fight, and it's for a low-buck build / rehab, I may opt to leave it in.

sd5782 

Moved to “Politics and Religion”.

jdawginsc 

Weld or glue in place; purchase grease gun extender tube. Procure and use a high suction vacuum. Scoff at the crunchy sound after you put it all back together.

I just sell the frame.

All joking aside, I take it out every several overhauls, not each one.

Steel Charlie

Every time. Just part of doing the job the way it should be done.

merziac

Amen brother.

merziac

Shop mechanic: "The DS BB cup is stuck, can I just leave it?"

Shop manager: "Sure, I'll have somebody that can do it get it out, don't bother coming back tomorrow."

merziac

Looks like we are not truly in the minority even if you add all the others together right now, but the non believers seem to be much quicker to defend their position as I would expect.

madpogue 

FiFY.

merziac

But the cup is still stuck.

John E

Does your definition of "proper tools" include the Sheldon Brown nut-washers-and-bolt system?

When I took the 1959 Capo to CyclArt for a repaint, I needed help removing the fixed cup. Jim Cunningham had a bench vise mounted atop a long pole in the middle of a large room, and that was the only way we could garner enough leverage to break it loose.

For an ISO, British, or Swiss-threaded BB, I can justify removing the fixed cup, but how about Italian or French? I find I need to use Loctite to keep those fixed cups "fixed." Is it really advantageous to take these in and out and grease the threads when they inherently have trouble staying tight because of a major (self-loosening) design blunder?

SwimmerMike 

I fully strip all bikes when they come in (including removing the fixed cup). Otherwise when I'm doing routine maintenance I will remove the fixed cup every other time.