Air pad technology?
#1
Full Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Posts: 400
Bikes: Schwinn, Nishiki, Santana, Trek, Rodriguez
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 189 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 106 Times
in
69 Posts
Air pad technology?
Does anyone have knowledge of the materials/construction used in lightweight air sleeping pad construction to hold the air in?
Over the years our air pads have failed in different ways. Two of our new air pads have failed because an inner membrane layer separated from the outer fabric shell. Such a failure cannot be patched, at least not using the supplied patch kits. I suspect (a guess) that some air pads use fabric impregnated with some type of urethane (think of Ortliebs) versus some pads that use a laminated membrane. The former can be fixed with patches, the latter cannot if the leak is due to delamination.
Possibly new pad technology uses a membrane to lower weight, if so, I want to identify such pads and stay away. I want to be able to patch a pad in the middle of nowhere. Are there different material/construction to hold air in pads? Difficult to know since this is proprietary information.
Over the years our air pads have failed in different ways. Two of our new air pads have failed because an inner membrane layer separated from the outer fabric shell. Such a failure cannot be patched, at least not using the supplied patch kits. I suspect (a guess) that some air pads use fabric impregnated with some type of urethane (think of Ortliebs) versus some pads that use a laminated membrane. The former can be fixed with patches, the latter cannot if the leak is due to delamination.
Possibly new pad technology uses a membrane to lower weight, if so, I want to identify such pads and stay away. I want to be able to patch a pad in the middle of nowhere. Are there different material/construction to hold air in pads? Difficult to know since this is proprietary information.
#3
Senior Member
I can't help with this question, but I strongly suspect that the main cause for delamination issues are from over inflation and leaving the mat in a very hot tent, or in the sun, causing the mat to balloon up from the increased pressure from heat.
I've observed this numerous times over the years.
touch wood, my neoair has been good for the years that I've had it, but I'm particularly careful about a hot tent or sun.
I've observed this numerous times over the years.
touch wood, my neoair has been good for the years that I've had it, but I'm particularly careful about a hot tent or sun.
#4
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2015
Location: QC Canada
Posts: 1,968
Bikes: Custom built LHT & Troll
Mentioned: 12 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 842 Post(s)
Liked 149 Times
in
106 Posts
My pad suffered from delamination. I could not think of a reason for this, other than wear and tear. And even though the lifetime warranty is impressive, it doesn't solve the very real problem of sleeping on the ground until you can find a replacement. I've opted for closed cell. Not clear what I'd do in colder weather -- I'd probably use my xTherm. Delamination being progressive, I'd assume that it could survive the trip or I'd find a replacement before it'd become useless.
#5
Senior Member
Not obvious. ThermaRest writes that delamination is generally attributed to a manufacturing defect and that they'll usually replace the pad under their limited lifetime warranty.
My pad suffered from delamination. I could not think of a reason for this, other than wear and tear. And even though the lifetime warranty is impressive, it doesn't solve the very real problem of sleeping on the ground until you can find a replacement. I've opted for closed cell. Not clear what I'd do in colder weather -- I'd probably use my xTherm. Delamination being progressive, I'd assume that it could survive the trip or I'd find a replacement before it'd become useless.
My pad suffered from delamination. I could not think of a reason for this, other than wear and tear. And even though the lifetime warranty is impressive, it doesn't solve the very real problem of sleeping on the ground until you can find a replacement. I've opted for closed cell. Not clear what I'd do in colder weather -- I'd probably use my xTherm. Delamination being progressive, I'd assume that it could survive the trip or I'd find a replacement before it'd become useless.
As you say, and they do, there are multiple reasons.
My comment comes from seeing camp mats becoming like marshmallows, all puffed up and bloated, from excessive heat--it can't be good for the parts glued together inside.
Your idea of using a closed cell mat underneath sounds like a really good idea. When I got my neoair, the increased comfort over many decades of traditional self inflating thermorests was really really noticeable. This is why I am so careful with mine.
I also see people putting them outside against trees, on the ground, and generally but being careful, with them.
My personal experience with delamination with an older style thermorest , was that it was a slow process, so yes it appears to be gradual. Holes due to uncareful tent placement over sharp plants or whatever, is a different risk. Being careful inside the tent with sharp objects etc too is just common sense, so I find it very hard to discuss risk assessment for air mats simply because different people treat things in such different ways.
And some people are just tough on equipment and don't use common sense.
No matter the cause though, especially with a cold weather trip like you are considering, you sure as heck want to be sure of your sleep system, just like your choices of clothing, as you have been asking about lately.
I'm a skinny guy who gets colder probably more than others, so completely get that.
Thanks again for that great article.
#6
Full Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Posts: 400
Bikes: Schwinn, Nishiki, Santana, Trek, Rodriguez
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 189 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 106 Times
in
69 Posts
Not obvious. ThermaRest writes that delamination is generally attributed to a manufacturing defect and
djb mentions that excessive heat might be a problem. Perhaps, and I imagine that heat could also damage the membrane bonding over time, but we always inflate our pads after coming into camp.
While a PITA, I am ok with patching a pad...a soap solution and sponge from the cook set work well in finding it. But, when a inner membrane de-bonds and tears, it is impossible to repair.
#8
Senior Member
I'm certainly in that crowd now of not really having much of an urge to go back to a foam pad, really appreciate an air pad for sleeping partially on my side. Lots of quite good, light options. Just not cheap, but avoid a hotel night or two and you've paid for a good air pad.
#9
Full Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Posts: 400
Bikes: Schwinn, Nishiki, Santana, Trek, Rodriguez
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 189 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 106 Times
in
69 Posts
Very true. Good sleep is so important. I would pay much more for "a good air pad". I'm not sure a good air pad exists, and the comments from people going back to foam supports this notion. Weight is secondary, pads with higher thread count (if that means less punctures), and most importantly, can always be repaired in the field. The lifetime warranty thing doesn't help much in the middle of nowhere. I wish manufacturers would respond to this need, stop with the "ultra" thing, and focus/market durability. But then, this is the sort of rant that touring on a bicycle can bring on
#10
Senior Member
For the record, my very early model neoair is comfortable, and has been fine for about ten years, so I have no complaints.
#11
Senior Member
Very true. Good sleep is so important. I would pay much more for "a good air pad". I'm not sure a good air pad exists, and the comments from people going back to foam supports this notion. Weight is secondary, pads with higher thread count (if that means less punctures), and most importantly, can always be repaired in the field. The lifetime warranty thing doesn't help much in the middle of nowhere. I wish manufacturers would respond to this need, stop with the "ultra" thing, and focus/market durability. But then, this is the sort of rant that touring on a bicycle can bring on
- The newer neoair style pads had a few internal baffle failure. These were relatively rare and never were a complete failure in that they lft the user unable to sleep on them until they could get a replacement. Worst case, on a long trip they might need to sleep on it a few nights and buy a new pad if it is a long trip. I slept on the lump for a week or so and it wasn't bad. The lump starts small and builds so you really aren't likely to have to go without a pad. Some have repaired pinholes, but they are surprisingly infrequent.
- The other type of fatal failue I recall was with the older selfinflating pads. They were sometimes impossible to effectively patch if the failed at the seam. I have not used this style pad in decades other than a huge basecamp one that I sometimes use in the back of a vehicle.
BTW, windex is great for finding leaks in inflated or pressurized items of all sorts including bike related stuff.
#12
Full Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Posts: 400
Bikes: Schwinn, Nishiki, Santana, Trek, Rodriguez
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 189 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 106 Times
in
69 Posts
Windex? Never thought of that. I find camp suds to be sufficient.
#13
Senior Member
Thanks, your experience with neoair is helpful. Our older expeds also suffered from baffle failure many (4) times. And your assertion that baffle failure is not devastating (word?) is correct. We gave up on exped owing to the multiple failures, but now I wonder... We switched to Klymit and then experienced membrane separation problems in two pads which caused an intimate awareness of the ground for a long time on tour. I love Mother Earth, but she can be hard. We have new klymit pads from warranty, maybe will work, but I understand why some people have given up on air pads. If the klymits fail again, we will switch to either exped (perhaps their new line has fixed the baffle problem) or neoair. I can deal with baffle problems.
Windex? Never thought of that. I find camp suds to be sufficient.
Windex? Never thought of that. I find camp suds to be sufficient.
as for staes thing for Windex, he's actually that Greek dad from My Big Fat Greek Wedding, so it's no surprise that he says that ;-)