converting 10sp to 11sp
#1
Full Member
Thread Starter
converting 10sp to 11sp
I recently bought a Trek 520 Grando 10sp to use bikepacking and bike touring. It was a budget bike and the tiagra shifting is lousy. I've gotten very used to electronic shifting over the last 5+ years. I just took my 11sp sram etap off my gravel bike so have this spare groupset ready to use ... somewhere. My main questions are:
Is there an 11sp freehub body available for the Shimano M475 ( currently 10sp) hub?
Will an 11sp chain work on 10sp chainrings? guessing not.
Will the etap front derailleur work with 42/28 chainrings?
Is there an 11sp freehub body available for the Shimano M475 ( currently 10sp) hub?
Will an 11sp chain work on 10sp chainrings? guessing not.
Will the etap front derailleur work with 42/28 chainrings?
#2
I'm good to go!
Join Date: Jul 2017
Location: Mississippi
Posts: 14,984
Bikes: Tarmac Disc Comp Di2 - 2020
Mentioned: 51 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 6191 Post(s)
Liked 4,807 Times
in
3,316 Posts
Is there an 11sp freehub body available for the Shimano M475 ( currently 10sp) hub?
Never mind, I found this......
FH-M475
SHIMANO - Rear FREEHUB - 6-Bolt Disc Brake - Quick Release - 8/9/10-speedFor use with 6-bolt disc brake rotors and quick release dropouts, the SHIMANO FH-M475 rear hub is available in silver and black and compatible with 8, 9, and 10-speed cassettes.
Will an 11sp chain work on 10sp chainrings? guessing not.
Will the etap front derailleur work with 42/28 chainrings?
Last edited by Iride01; 05-20-22 at 09:18 AM.
#3
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Mountain Brook. AL
Posts: 4,002
Mentioned: 14 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 303 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 136 Times
in
104 Posts
FWIW the Shimano 11 spd 11-34 cassette in the 700-800 series were specifically designed to be used on 8-10spd free hubs
as well as 11 spd hubs with a spacer. It is my understanding that a number of the ATB oriented shimano 11 spd cassettes
were also usable on 10spd hubs and cover larger ranges than the 11-34. Problem might be chain wrap with larger than
11-34 even with smaller chain rings and clearing the larger cassette cogs with your SRAM etap RD, though hanger extender
would probably fix that.
as well as 11 spd hubs with a spacer. It is my understanding that a number of the ATB oriented shimano 11 spd cassettes
were also usable on 10spd hubs and cover larger ranges than the 11-34. Problem might be chain wrap with larger than
11-34 even with smaller chain rings and clearing the larger cassette cogs with your SRAM etap RD, though hanger extender
would probably fix that.
#4
Full Member
Thread Starter
--First, I also find Sram tech docs difficult to find - if the one you're looking for exists at all. I'm pretty sure they would not support using the FD on 42/28 chainrings. My next idea is to go 1x; keep the 28 that's on there for low gearing. I can happily? coast downhill.
--Interesting about the Shimano 11 spd cassettes designed to work on 10sp hubs. I was hoping to use my 11-36 sram cassette (which exceeded the chain capacity and was less than ideal on my gravel bike, for sure) rather than buy a new one. I used a roadlink to get to the 36 but the chain was too long and I had to be careful to stay out of small/small. I don't mind this setup on this particular bike.
--I realize the spec on the current hub - I was hoping someone might know if I can replace the current freehub body with an 11spd freehub body.
--I am definitely not looking for race performance. I'm doing a tour with this heavy bike plus panniers.
--Interesting about the Shimano 11 spd cassettes designed to work on 10sp hubs. I was hoping to use my 11-36 sram cassette (which exceeded the chain capacity and was less than ideal on my gravel bike, for sure) rather than buy a new one. I used a roadlink to get to the 36 but the chain was too long and I had to be careful to stay out of small/small. I don't mind this setup on this particular bike.
--I realize the spec on the current hub - I was hoping someone might know if I can replace the current freehub body with an 11spd freehub body.
--I am definitely not looking for race performance. I'm doing a tour with this heavy bike plus panniers.
#5
Senior Member
My understanding is that 11sp road spacing is 131, not 130. They kind of snuck that extra 1mm in there since it would barely be noticeable when inserting the wheel into the frame. What that means is that the hub may be a mm too narrow to take an 11sp as cassette tolerances are really tight and the dropout may be up against the freehub. You could probably make it work though with a spacer, but that may also require a re-dish. I also vaguely recall one of Shimano's groupsets not being compatible with the others, and it may have been Tiagra. Is it worth doing vs. just buying an 11sp wheel? I know, you are trying to keep the cost down and reuse what you have. I do it myself and then end up spending more to make it work than just buying what I needed in the first place. You know you are going to need a specially splined wrench to take it off, one that only fits Tiagra, and another that only fits 11sp! (or something like that. If you ever had Campy you know what I mean.)
Shimano has a compatibility chart that shows everything but can be difficult to understand too.
Shimano has a compatibility chart that shows everything but can be difficult to understand too.
#6
Full Member
Thread Starter
I'm debating all this too - new wheel and all. It's probably not worth the cost and hassle. I worked on the tiagra shifting today ... the shop had it set up with low limit screw incorrectly set, cables have stretched, test ride tomorrow. If it shifts better then I'll probably keep what I have. I switched out the freehub body on my white industry hub to go from the 11sp to 12sp and found it was easy to do. I also found a diagram online showing this 131mm vs 130mm, so I can see the potential for problems.
thanks for your input.
thanks for your input.
My understanding is that 11sp road spacing is 131, not 130. They kind of snuck that extra 1mm in there since it would barely be noticeable when inserting the wheel into the frame. What that means is that the hub may be a mm too narrow to take an 11sp as cassette tolerances are really tight and the dropout may be up against the freehub. You could probably make it work though with a spacer, but that may also require a re-dish. I also vaguely recall one of Shimano's groupsets not being compatible with the others, and it may have been Tiagra. Is it worth doing vs. just buying an 11sp wheel? I know, you are trying to keep the cost down and reuse what you have. I do it myself and then end up spending more to make it work than just buying what I needed in the first place. You know you are going to need a specially splined wrench to take it off, one that only fits Tiagra, and another that only fits 11sp! (or something like that. If you ever had Campy you know what I mean.)
Shimano has a compatibility chart that shows everything but can be difficult to understand too.
Shimano has a compatibility chart that shows everything but can be difficult to understand too.
#7
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 2,391
Mentioned: 14 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1560 Post(s)
Liked 1,733 Times
in
973 Posts
The 11 speed hub is wider than the 10 speed hub. BUT the 11 speed cassettes with the largest cog > 34t, are dished in in the back. So it fits over the 10 speed hub.
Likes For icemilkcoffee: