Small-Wheeled Bike Saddle Recommendations
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2016
Location: Hong Kong
Posts: 40
Bikes: Brompton S6R-X, Tern Verge X20, Moulton SST, BMC RoadMachine, Bianchi Infinito CV, Giant TCR Advanced Pro Disc
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Small-Wheeled Bike Saddle Recommendations
I've just upgraded my Brompton with a Brooks Cambium saddle. I get on well with Brooks B17, but had swapped for a while to the standard Brompton saddle to get something more resistant to the elements since I sometimes ride in the rain. The basic Brompton saddle is pretty awful, so decided to try the Cambium which promised more comfort, zero break-in period, and fewer upkeep / rain protection issues.
The Cambium has been a revelation. It kills a lot of the road buzz that was registering on my rear end - my bike has the firm suspension block.
Anyway what I'm getting at is there ought to be a list of suggested saddles which play well with small-wheeled bikes and provide good support whilst eating up the the kind of road buzz we have to live with due to our love of smaller wheel sizes and lower tyre volumes.
What else is good?
Also, does a Brompton titanium seat post make much of a difference to ride quality?
The Cambium has been a revelation. It kills a lot of the road buzz that was registering on my rear end - my bike has the firm suspension block.
Anyway what I'm getting at is there ought to be a list of suggested saddles which play well with small-wheeled bikes and provide good support whilst eating up the the kind of road buzz we have to live with due to our love of smaller wheel sizes and lower tyre volumes.
What else is good?
Also, does a Brompton titanium seat post make much of a difference to ride quality?
#3
Junior Member
Only differ in that most small wheelers have the rider more upright and at a slower speed. I usually have B17, C17 or Flyer saddles on 650B and 700C bikes with drop bars, but found that the wider C19 Carved is very comfortable on the Dahon and BF I’ve been riding lately, both with flat bars and both forcing me to be more upright in posture.
#4
Only differ in that most small wheelers have the rider more upright and at a slower speed. I usually have B17, C17 or Flyer saddles on 650B and 700C bikes with drop bars, but found that the wider C19 Carved is very comfortable on the Dahon and BF I’ve been riding lately, both with flat bars and both forcing me to be more upright in posture.
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: SF Bay Area
Posts: 3,478
Bikes: Now: HPV Gecko FX 20 w/ assist.. Old: Trident Spike 2 recumbent trike w/ e-assist
Liked 389 Times
in
298 Posts
Can't speak to Brompton titanium saddle post but it made a big difference on my Bike Friday pakiT. Absorbs bigger bumps even better than little ones. Enough difference that I went and installed the titanium stem mast as well. There's a bit more flex on the seat mast but I'm pretty light and it doesn't bother me at all. Ymmv with the differences on the Brommie design, but I prefer the feel. Maybe you can find one to try out. As to saddle, get one that fits your butt, same as with any other bike. If you don't go titanium, can you not add a thudbuster to a Brompton? Or does it mess with the fold too much?
Likes For linberl:
#6
Schwinnasaur
Thudbuster on bike with rear suspension is redundant.
Likes For linberl:
#9
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2016
Location: Hong Kong
Posts: 40
Bikes: Brompton S6R-X, Tern Verge X20, Moulton SST, BMC RoadMachine, Bianchi Infinito CV, Giant TCR Advanced Pro Disc
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Interesting comments!
Yes, suspension blocks (I use the firm one) obviously smooth out the ride somewhat.
However I've noticed that I'm more irritated by high frequency road buzz (e.g. chip seal) than by bigger lower frequency jolts. Suspension blocks work more like high pass filters and seem to mainly attenuate the lower bigger amplitude lower frequency 'noise'.
I feel as if the rubbery Cambium saddle does a better job with the high frequency stuff than the previous B17 and Brompton stock saddles. I asked about the Titanium seat post option because Titanium bikes have such a good reputation for smooth ride quality. Might try one of these too... don't care too much about the weight bonus of Ti... but if it makes the ride more pleasant sure.
These are kind of asymptotic gains, but I'm hedonistic enough to chase them whilst being masochistic enough to pedal up hills in tropical heat. Rationality ain't in it!
Yes, suspension blocks (I use the firm one) obviously smooth out the ride somewhat.
However I've noticed that I'm more irritated by high frequency road buzz (e.g. chip seal) than by bigger lower frequency jolts. Suspension blocks work more like high pass filters and seem to mainly attenuate the lower bigger amplitude lower frequency 'noise'.
I feel as if the rubbery Cambium saddle does a better job with the high frequency stuff than the previous B17 and Brompton stock saddles. I asked about the Titanium seat post option because Titanium bikes have such a good reputation for smooth ride quality. Might try one of these too... don't care too much about the weight bonus of Ti... but if it makes the ride more pleasant sure.
These are kind of asymptotic gains, but I'm hedonistic enough to chase them whilst being masochistic enough to pedal up hills in tropical heat. Rationality ain't in it!
Likes For Depaso:
#11
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: SF Bay Area
Posts: 3,478
Bikes: Now: HPV Gecko FX 20 w/ assist.. Old: Trident Spike 2 recumbent trike w/ e-assist
Liked 389 Times
in
298 Posts
Interesting comments!
Yes, suspension blocks (I use the firm one) obviously smooth out the ride somewhat.
However I've noticed that I'm more irritated by high frequency road buzz (e.g. chip seal) than by bigger lower frequency jolts. Suspension blocks work more like high pass filters and seem to mainly attenuate the lower bigger amplitude lower frequency 'noise'.
I feel as if the rubbery Cambium saddle does a better job with the high frequency stuff than the previous B17 and Brompton stock saddles. I asked about the Titanium seat post option because Titanium bikes have such a good reputation for smooth ride quality. Might try one of these too... don't care too much about the weight bonus of Ti... but if it makes the ride more pleasant sure.
These are kind of asymptotic gains, but I'm hedonistic enough to chase them whilst being masochistic enough to pedal up hills in tropical heat. Rationality ain't in it!
Yes, suspension blocks (I use the firm one) obviously smooth out the ride somewhat.
However I've noticed that I'm more irritated by high frequency road buzz (e.g. chip seal) than by bigger lower frequency jolts. Suspension blocks work more like high pass filters and seem to mainly attenuate the lower bigger amplitude lower frequency 'noise'.
I feel as if the rubbery Cambium saddle does a better job with the high frequency stuff than the previous B17 and Brompton stock saddles. I asked about the Titanium seat post option because Titanium bikes have such a good reputation for smooth ride quality. Might try one of these too... don't care too much about the weight bonus of Ti... but if it makes the ride more pleasant sure.
These are kind of asymptotic gains, but I'm hedonistic enough to chase them whilst being masochistic enough to pedal up hills in tropical heat. Rationality ain't in it!
Likes For linberl: