mojopt

Here is my problem- I need a very small 17" frame. The problem is a) the frame is too small to accommodate a second holder and b) I don't care to use a seat post mounted twin cage.

Being a newby, I am seeking comments on the method I have chosen (see pics). Obviously, I could now carry two bottles, one on each fork leg.

I'm trying to determine why I haven't seen this before. Reaching the bottle for a drink on the run is not an issue with me. I stop to drink. The only other issue I can tihnk of is the possiblity of the bottle(s) falling out and under my rear wheel. That is why I plan to add a strap to the cage.

What I'm I missing here?

Best regards,

Mike

dgasmd

Where to begin.......... First off, if you are looking for a good way to hurt yourself, keep that bottle there. BEtter yet, add another to the other side!! For a number of reasons, this IS NOT a good idea in my mind. I would suggest you either get a seat mounted cage system or simply put them in the rear pockets of your cycling jersey. They are commonly kept there conveniently. If you don't use cycling jerseys, and simply judging from the looks here I am going to take a stab at strongly assuming you don't, get some.

clausen

Use smaller bottles. My wifes frame won't fit large bottles but the 500 ml size fits. Use a rear pocket or there are cages for handle bars. That setup is a accident just waiting to happen.

ericm979

If you slip while putting the bottle in or taking it out, and the bottle or your hand goes into the wheel, you will be taking a short air flight with a very rough landing.

Put a cage on the downtube. Then find a side-entry cage for the seat tube. Use short bottles if you have to.

mojopt

dgasmd,

Thanks for your relpy. Would you care to explain the possible hazards? I appreciate your opinion and would like to be more informed of the risks.

Thanks again,

Mike

AndrewP

I was looking at waterbottles in Sports Expert recently and they came with a cage and bracket for mounting on the handlebars. I had a bike with 2 bottles in front of the bars back in the 50s - very convenient. You should drink while riding, but your arrangement is good for carrying extra water for refilling the smaller bottles. When out all day, I often find that there isnt a place to get more water when I need it.

tntyz

I'm guessing that people feel you'll be tempted to reach for the bottle while riding, even though you DID say you stop when drinking.

laduckslayer

If you don't get the useful commentary from Dgasmd, then, well you just don't get it. Ride it like you stole it and watch your fingers when you need a drink.

dgasmd

The main obvious one is the reaching to grab the bottle while rolling. Your hand can and WILL get caught by the spokes causing an accident in more than one way injuring more than just your hand. Another is the clear possibility of dropping the bottle right in front of the rear wheel and crashing. Another is the real possibility of getting your arm caught with the handlebars and twisting/turning the bars by mistake while reaching down = crash again. Lastly, I see the fact that the weight of the bottle with liquids will add a huge instability factor to your front end making it dangerous when turning, taking a hand or two off the bars, etc. Just too many risks.

Many have already given excellent suggestions. Look into those first and get rid of this system before you hurt yourself.

Bontrager

:facepalm:

thompsonpost

Interference with the bottle and the downtube while turning.

DwayneS

Nestor

How about something like this?

https://www.shopwiki.com/MINOURA+CLAM...LE+CAGE+HOLDER

HarryStoddard

https://www.rei.com/product/721789

Something like this.

prathmann

The fork mounting should be fine as long as you really never reach for it or put it back while riding. I'd put one bottle on the downtube as usual to use while riding and keep the fork mount only for carrying a spare that'll be exchanged while stopped. That position is about the same as low-rider panniers and normally doesn't cause any instability. I used to use a single pannier in the front for my commuting stuff (weighed much more than a full bottle) and never had any handling issues.

Jakedatc

Or.. a couple Bontrager Sideswipes and not have ejecto-bottles. i use one for my seat tube cage since i can't even get a 20oz in with a normal cage.. bonty cage i fit a 24oz no problem.

https://store.trekbikes.com/jump.jsp?...th=1%2C2%2C261

valygrl

Are you sure you can't use regular cages? I have 2 on my 17" trek 520. And um... did you try it without the frame pump?