Originally Posted by
force10
Late to the party but couldnt pass up on the opportunity to say how horrible the Silca Asymmetrico is. Single worst cycling product I have purchased. No amount of fussing or tightening will keep it in place. It fell off four different bikes with six different saddles before I finally ditched it.
I have the Asymmetrico but haven't experienced that problem. I like that the Boa can be tightened up so nothing rattles around inside. I don't like things on my bike rattling.
My installation method: tighten Boa, jiggle the roll a few times, tighten Boa again. Repeat until jiggling doesn't loosen the roll.