Adding disc brake idiots guide wanted
#26
Mad bike riding scientist
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 27,700
Bikes: Some silver ones, a red one, a black and orange one, and a few titanium ones
Liked 4,538 Times
in
2,522 Posts
I’ll agree that a drum brake is the way to go. That said, there doesn’t seem to be a reaction arm anchor on the left chainstay (see red arrow below). That is somewhat problematic. Coaster brakes use a simple, thin metal strap for the reaction arm but that might not be up to snuf for this kind of brake. You will need something stronger than the 1/16” thick steel strap that coaster brakes typically use.
__________________
Stuart Black
Plan Epsilon Around Lake Michigan in the era of Covid
Old School…When It Wasn’t Ancient bikepacking
Gold Fever Three days of dirt in Colorado
Pokin' around the Poconos A cold ride around Lake Erie
Dinosaurs in Colorado A mountain bike guide to the Purgatory Canyon dinosaur trackway
Solo Without Pie. The search for pie in the Midwest.
Picking the Scablands. Washington and Oregon, 2005. Pie and spiders on the Columbia River!
Stuart Black
Plan Epsilon Around Lake Michigan in the era of Covid
Old School…When It Wasn’t Ancient bikepacking
Gold Fever Three days of dirt in Colorado
Pokin' around the Poconos A cold ride around Lake Erie
Dinosaurs in Colorado A mountain bike guide to the Purgatory Canyon dinosaur trackway
Solo Without Pie. The search for pie in the Midwest.
Picking the Scablands. Washington and Oregon, 2005. Pie and spiders on the Columbia River!
#27
Senior Member
I have the no longer made Magura HS66 and a non modified Araya drum brake on my 1990 Burly Bongo Tandem. The Magura brakes are much better stoppers than my Paul Klampers on my touring bike. Both the Tandem and Touring bike have 26" wheels. I would like to see some pictures of your brakes.
#28
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2024
Location: San Diego
Posts: 1,221
Bikes: Columbine, Paramount Track Bike, Colnago Super, Santana Tandems (1995 & 2007), Gary Fisher Piranha, Trek Wahoo, Bianchi Track Bike, a couple of Honda mountain bikes
Liked 440 Times
in
271 Posts
I put a Magura HS33 on the front of our tandem, replacing the cantilever brake that looked and sounded like it was made when Truman was president. I’m amazed at how well the bike stops. Arguably as well as my road bike, and definitely well enough to get “counseled” by my stoker…..
__________________
Cheers, Mike
-Stupid hurts....ride safe
Cheers, Mike
-Stupid hurts....ride safe
#29
Regarding braking on long descents, so a drag brake... the problem with bike discs is partly the small amount of heat sink of the disc because they are so thin, though I still like that better than heating up aluminum rims to the point of popping spokes and worse. Bike drum brakes, beside having more mass to the drum, if it is similar to car drum brakes, I'm betting it has long front and rear shoes (pads) so it has 20X (wild-@ss guess) the pad surface as disc pads, thus much longer life.
When cars went to discs, the discs were thick and vented (USA iron), but it was still a challenge at first to be as powerful as drums, because the wheel diameters were small and thus with the caliper and clearance needed, the disc was not as large as desired. Audi for their V8 model made a "hat" disc where the caliper was on the inside and the disc nearly as large as the wheel diameter, huge increase in swept area, but expensive, and shops weren't set up to reface them, so those didn't last. Now, with huge wheels on factory cars, and cars being lighter, sufficient size discs are easy. On really high performance cars, they use carbon pads against carbon discs ("carbon-carbon") which has tremendous coefficient of friction and great stopping power. Expensive.
But getting back to bikes... My folding bike is near perfect after all my mods, but I want discs, long decents will pop spokes on the 20" rims. Rear disc mounts would involve framebuilding, if they were willing, expensive. I looked for disc fork, didn't see one. Plus I would need new wheels. I decided it was cheaper to put the money toward a disc folder in the future.
When cars went to discs, the discs were thick and vented (USA iron), but it was still a challenge at first to be as powerful as drums, because the wheel diameters were small and thus with the caliper and clearance needed, the disc was not as large as desired. Audi for their V8 model made a "hat" disc where the caliper was on the inside and the disc nearly as large as the wheel diameter, huge increase in swept area, but expensive, and shops weren't set up to reface them, so those didn't last. Now, with huge wheels on factory cars, and cars being lighter, sufficient size discs are easy. On really high performance cars, they use carbon pads against carbon discs ("carbon-carbon") which has tremendous coefficient of friction and great stopping power. Expensive.
But getting back to bikes... My folding bike is near perfect after all my mods, but I want discs, long decents will pop spokes on the 20" rims. Rear disc mounts would involve framebuilding, if they were willing, expensive. I looked for disc fork, didn't see one. Plus I would need new wheels. I decided it was cheaper to put the money toward a disc folder in the future.
Last edited by Duragrouch; 04-27-24 at 12:26 AM.
#30
Mad bike riding scientist
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 27,700
Bikes: Some silver ones, a red one, a black and orange one, and a few titanium ones
Liked 4,538 Times
in
2,522 Posts
Regarding braking on long descents, so a drag brake... the problem with bike discs is partly the small amount of heat sink of the disc because they are so thin, though I still like that better than heating up aluminum rims to the point of popping spokes and worse. Bike drum brakes, beside having more mass to the drum, if it is similar to car drum brakes, I'm betting it has long front and rear shoes (pads) so it has 20X (wild-@ss guess) the pad surface as disc pads, thus much longer life.
You are correct that bicycle disc rotors are small in terms of being a heat sink but they aren’t too small for the job.
But getting back to bikes... My folding bike is near perfect after all my mods, but I want discs, long decents will pop spokes on the 20" rims. Rear disc mounts would involve framebuilding, if they were willing, expensive. I looked for disc fork, didn't see one. Plus I would need new wheels. I decided it was cheaper to put the money toward a disc folder in the future.
I would also suggest that you try a different approach to braking. Brakes…in a bike or car…shouldn’t be applied at the top of a hill and never released until the bottom. That’s a poor use of brakes. In a car, you should downshift and let the engine do most of the work. I do a lot…a lot…of mountain driving and I can go down 7% grades for miles without touching my brakes. If I do apply brakes I do so in short burst and then get off the brake to let the engine do the work.
On a bike, I similarly use my brakes sparingly, although I don’t have the engine compression to use. Sitting up and catching wind helps but my main strategy is to apply the brakes hard for only a few seconds, then get off them and repeat as needed. There is significant cooling of any brake surface in between braking events and no heat build up because there is no friction on the rim. I’ve ridden 10s of thousands of miles in mountain situations, both on and off road, and never had a brake surface even get hot, much less overheated.
Avoiding brake heating isn’t about the type of brake but how the brake is used.
__________________
Stuart Black
Plan Epsilon Around Lake Michigan in the era of Covid
Old School…When It Wasn’t Ancient bikepacking
Gold Fever Three days of dirt in Colorado
Pokin' around the Poconos A cold ride around Lake Erie
Dinosaurs in Colorado A mountain bike guide to the Purgatory Canyon dinosaur trackway
Solo Without Pie. The search for pie in the Midwest.
Picking the Scablands. Washington and Oregon, 2005. Pie and spiders on the Columbia River!
Stuart Black
Plan Epsilon Around Lake Michigan in the era of Covid
Old School…When It Wasn’t Ancient bikepacking
Gold Fever Three days of dirt in Colorado
Pokin' around the Poconos A cold ride around Lake Erie
Dinosaurs in Colorado A mountain bike guide to the Purgatory Canyon dinosaur trackway
Solo Without Pie. The search for pie in the Midwest.
Picking the Scablands. Washington and Oregon, 2005. Pie and spiders on the Columbia River!
#31
I have never heard of anyone popping spokes because of rim heat nor have I even heard someone suggest that is possible. The tire would fail long before any heat build up could cause structural damage to the rim and/or spoke. Even tire failure due to heat is something that is rare. Additionally, rubber brake pads would melt before even that occurs. Further, the mass…and area…of a rim brake is so large and under flow of air that building up the kind of heat you are talking about would be almost impossible.
You are correct that bicycle disc rotors are small in terms of being a heat sink but they aren’t too small for the job.
If you are popping spokes on descents, I would look for some other cause. Heat from braking isn’t the culprit.
I would also suggest that you try a different approach to braking. Brakes…in a bike or car…shouldn’t be applied at the top of a hill and never released until the bottom. That’s a poor use of brakes. In a car, you should downshift and let the engine do most of the work. I do a lot…a lot…of mountain driving and I can go down 7% grades for miles without touching my brakes. If I do apply brakes I do so in short burst and then get off the brake to let the engine do the work.
On a bike, I similarly use my brakes sparingly, although I don’t have the engine compression to use. Sitting up and catching wind helps but my main strategy is to apply the brakes hard for only a few seconds, then get off them and repeat as needed. There is significant cooling of any brake surface in between braking events and no heat build up because there is no friction on the rim. I’ve ridden 10s of thousands of miles in mountain situations, both on and off road, and never had a brake surface even get hot, much less overheated.
Avoiding brake heating isn’t about the type of brake but how the brake is used.
You are correct that bicycle disc rotors are small in terms of being a heat sink but they aren’t too small for the job.
If you are popping spokes on descents, I would look for some other cause. Heat from braking isn’t the culprit.
I would also suggest that you try a different approach to braking. Brakes…in a bike or car…shouldn’t be applied at the top of a hill and never released until the bottom. That’s a poor use of brakes. In a car, you should downshift and let the engine do most of the work. I do a lot…a lot…of mountain driving and I can go down 7% grades for miles without touching my brakes. If I do apply brakes I do so in short burst and then get off the brake to let the engine do the work.
On a bike, I similarly use my brakes sparingly, although I don’t have the engine compression to use. Sitting up and catching wind helps but my main strategy is to apply the brakes hard for only a few seconds, then get off them and repeat as needed. There is significant cooling of any brake surface in between braking events and no heat build up because there is no friction on the rim. I’ve ridden 10s of thousands of miles in mountain situations, both on and off road, and never had a brake surface even get hot, much less overheated.
Avoiding brake heating isn’t about the type of brake but how the brake is used.
- Aluminum has a high coefficient of thermal expansion. A bike shop decades ago told me that a prime advantage of discs was rims not expanding due to heat, which stresses both the rims at the spoke holes and the spokes, they said disc rims last longer due to that alone.
- Aluminum has a high specific heat, so will absorb more heat and cool more slowly.
- My 20" rims have less circumference and thus less heat sink than larger wheels, so get hotter for the same heat energy.
- My 20" wheel spokes are short and constant section, so have less elasticity than spokes on larger wheels, and especially if double-butted.
- 20" rims have greater "hoop/arch stiffness" than larger diameter rims for the same rim section, so have less radial elasticity.
- The 20" rear uses a standard 130mm cassette hub, so for the same wheel dish, the non-drive-side spokes are at a higher lateral angle, requiring a greater difference in tension between the NDS and DS spokes, the drive side spokes are higher tension, and more than on a larger wheel.
- On the day I snapped the spoke, I was using all rear brake, as the front rim was getting more concave sidewalls from years of wear and I was trying to baby it. So all heat going into rear rim, plus drive side spokes higher tension, and all the above factors, *pop*. The rim wasn't hot enough to burst the tube, but hot enough for significant growth. Maybe that spoke was fatigued and ready to pop, but nevertheless, the rim growth pushed it over the edge. When it popped, I was at the bottom of the hill going slow so even less air cooling, and had just let off the brake, no bump or other event. And it was a summer day.
Like I said, a confluence of bad. Most problems are a combination of factors, not just one.
Back when engine head gaskets were not as good as now, well-designed piston engines (like aircraft engines), instead of having short head bolts, had very long head bolts from the head to the lower skirt of the block, greater than the cylinder length, this gave much greater elasticity and kept the head gasket tight over a wider temperature range, and to compensate for gasket compression over time. Longer spokes do the same on bike wheels, greater elasticity.
Last edited by Duragrouch; 04-27-24 at 04:59 PM.
#32
Mad bike riding scientist
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 27,700
Bikes: Some silver ones, a red one, a black and orange one, and a few titanium ones
Liked 4,538 Times
in
2,522 Posts
I do all of the things you mentioned, standing up for drag, not braking continuously. This was on a 220 foot descent over not a long distance and with turns, so a good amount of braking energy. My wheels are trued extremely meticulously, dead-on and even tension. But as I have explained before, a confluence of bad, there is not getting around:
- Aluminum has a high coefficient of thermal expansion. A bike shop decades ago told me that a prime advantage of discs was rims not expanding due to heat, which stresses both the rims at the spoke holes and the spokes, they said disc rims last longer due to that alone.
- Aluminum has a high specific heat, so will absorb more heat and cool more slowly.
- My 20" rims have less circumference and thus less heat sink than larger wheels, so get hotter for the same heat energy.
- My 20" wheel spokes are short and constant section, so have less elasticity than spokes on larger wheels, and especially if double-butted.
- 20" rims have greater "hoop/arch stiffness" than larger diameter rims for the same rim section, so have less radial elasticity.
- 20" rims have greater "hoop/arch stiffness" than larger diameter rims for the same rim section, so have less radial elasticity.
- The 20" rear uses a standard 130mm cassette hub, so for the same wheel dish, the non-drive-side spokes are at a higher lateral angle, requiring a greater difference in tension between the NDS and DS spokes, the drive side spokes are higher tension, and more than on a larger wheel.
- On the day I snapped the spoke, I was using all rear brake, as the front rim was getting more concave sidewalls from years of wear and I was trying to baby it. So all heat going into rear rim, plus drive side spokes higher tension, and all the above factors, *pop*. The rim wasn't hot enough to burst the tube, but hot enough for significant growth. Maybe that spoke was fatigued and ready to pop, but nevertheless, the rim growth pushed it over the edge. When it popped, I was at the bottom of the hill going slow so even less air cooling, and had just let off the brake, no bump or other event. And it was a summer day.
Back when engine head gaskets were not as good as now, well-designed piston engines (like aircraft engines), instead of having short head bolts, had very long head bolts from the head to the lower skirt of the block, greater than the cylinder length, this gave much greater elasticity and kept the head gasket tight over a wider temperature range, and to compensate for gasket compression over time. Longer spokes do the same on bike wheels, greater elasticity.
__________________
Stuart Black
Plan Epsilon Around Lake Michigan in the era of Covid
Old School…When It Wasn’t Ancient bikepacking
Gold Fever Three days of dirt in Colorado
Pokin' around the Poconos A cold ride around Lake Erie
Dinosaurs in Colorado A mountain bike guide to the Purgatory Canyon dinosaur trackway
Solo Without Pie. The search for pie in the Midwest.
Picking the Scablands. Washington and Oregon, 2005. Pie and spiders on the Columbia River!
Stuart Black
Plan Epsilon Around Lake Michigan in the era of Covid
Old School…When It Wasn’t Ancient bikepacking
Gold Fever Three days of dirt in Colorado
Pokin' around the Poconos A cold ride around Lake Erie
Dinosaurs in Colorado A mountain bike guide to the Purgatory Canyon dinosaur trackway
Solo Without Pie. The search for pie in the Midwest.
Picking the Scablands. Washington and Oregon, 2005. Pie and spiders on the Columbia River!
#33
(above) The part about conductivity is true, but again, for the same rim section and material, a larger rim has more heat sink so will not heat up as much as a smaller rim with less heat sink..
I don't seem to have any credibility with you, so I'm gonna wait for one of the folks here who have had a lot of pro wrenching time on bikes and can reply to both my points and your points. Or someone who's done mountain descents and can attest to rims overheating and popped spokes, but again, larger rims have several things going for them that my 20" rims don't.
I don't seem to have any credibility with you, so I'm gonna wait for one of the folks here who have had a lot of pro wrenching time on bikes and can reply to both my points and your points. Or someone who's done mountain descents and can attest to rims overheating and popped spokes, but again, larger rims have several things going for them that my 20" rims don't.
#34
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Rochester, NY
Posts: 18,344
Bikes: Stewart S&S coupled sport tourer, Stewart Sunday light, Stewart Commuting, Stewart Touring, Co Motion Tandem, Stewart 3-Spd, Stewart Track, Fuji Finest, Mongoose Tomac ATB, GT Bravado ATB, JCP Folder, Stewart 650B ATB
Liked 4,189 Times
in
2,472 Posts
I've got to support Stuart's understanding of the various aspects we'll talking about just now. I'll add that disk brake equipped bikes do break spokes on front wheels. We've replace more front wheel spokes then years ago and I can't remember the last time a rim brake ft wheel spoke broke that wasn't from an incident.
Do rims heat up during long downhills, sure and there are many stories about blowing off tires from increasing pressures, pads glazing and/or melting the contact surface (rubber is a poor heat conductor). But I can't ever remember a claim of spoke breakage from downhill braking with rim brakes. I have felt my own rims many times with my fingers, usually when I was curious about how hot they actually felt. This includes tandeming on the Blue Ridge and many tours with over 100lbs of bike and gear on my single (and with that kind of load you don't really go too fast but still have a huge momentum that loads the brakes). I have never had rims so hot that I couldn't touch them. Sometimes they were uncomfortable but not painful at all.
Now I have seen the results of disk rotor being way too hot. beautiful colors... Andy
Do rims heat up during long downhills, sure and there are many stories about blowing off tires from increasing pressures, pads glazing and/or melting the contact surface (rubber is a poor heat conductor). But I can't ever remember a claim of spoke breakage from downhill braking with rim brakes. I have felt my own rims many times with my fingers, usually when I was curious about how hot they actually felt. This includes tandeming on the Blue Ridge and many tours with over 100lbs of bike and gear on my single (and with that kind of load you don't really go too fast but still have a huge momentum that loads the brakes). I have never had rims so hot that I couldn't touch them. Sometimes they were uncomfortable but not painful at all.
Now I have seen the results of disk rotor being way too hot. beautiful colors... Andy
__________________
AndrewRStewart
AndrewRStewart
Likes For Andrew R Stewart:
#35
I've got to support Stuart's understanding of the various aspects we'll talking about just now. I'll add that disk brake equipped bikes do break spokes on front wheels. We've replace more front wheel spokes then years ago and I can't remember the last time a rim brake ft wheel spoke broke that wasn't from an incident.
Do rims heat up during long downhills, sure and there are many stories about blowing off tires from increasing pressures, pads glazing and/or melting the contact surface (rubber is a poor heat conductor). But I can't ever remember a claim of spoke breakage from downhill braking with rim brakes. I have felt my own rims many times with my fingers, usually when I was curious about how hot they actually felt. This includes tandeming on the Blue Ridge and many tours with over 100lbs of bike and gear on my single (and with that kind of load you don't really go too fast but still have a huge momentum that loads the brakes). I have never had rims so hot that I couldn't touch them. Sometimes they were uncomfortable but not painful at all.
Now I have seen the results of disk rotor being way too hot. beautiful colors... Andy
Do rims heat up during long downhills, sure and there are many stories about blowing off tires from increasing pressures, pads glazing and/or melting the contact surface (rubber is a poor heat conductor). But I can't ever remember a claim of spoke breakage from downhill braking with rim brakes. I have felt my own rims many times with my fingers, usually when I was curious about how hot they actually felt. This includes tandeming on the Blue Ridge and many tours with over 100lbs of bike and gear on my single (and with that kind of load you don't really go too fast but still have a huge momentum that loads the brakes). I have never had rims so hot that I couldn't touch them. Sometimes they were uncomfortable but not painful at all.
Now I have seen the results of disk rotor being way too hot. beautiful colors... Andy
Last edited by Duragrouch; 04-28-24 at 08:37 PM.