Why is ultralight touring so unpopular?
#51
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2014
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 13,061
Bikes: (2) ti TiCycles, 2007 w/ triple and 2011 fixed, 1979 Peter Mooney, ~1983 Trek 420 now fixed and ~1973 Raleigh Carlton Competition gravel grinder
Liked 4,093 Times
in
2,644 Posts
I have a really simple test for how well I planned my clothing and shelter. Was I warm enough and comfortable on the coldest and/or wettest time of my trip? Did I have clothes along I wasn't wearing? If I can say yes to the first and no to the second, I figured I planned pretty well. (I do allow that I might not be wearing a second set of underclothes that are now filthy.)
There is another factor to consider if you have gotten older. It may require more padding/pillows/comfort to get a good night's sleep, especially if you hit the hay with no alcohol in your system. Sleep is one of those things life is much better with. So there are those of us who choose more weight for that reason.
Ben
There is another factor to consider if you have gotten older. It may require more padding/pillows/comfort to get a good night's sleep, especially if you hit the hay with no alcohol in your system. Sleep is one of those things life is much better with. So there are those of us who choose more weight for that reason.
Ben
#52
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Madison, WI
Posts: 11,344
Bikes: 1961 Ideor, 1966 Perfekt 3 Speed AB Hub, 1994 Bridgestone MB-6, 2006 Airnimal Joey, 2009 Thorn Sherpa, 2013 Thorn Nomad MkII, 2015 VO Pass Hunter, 2017 Lynskey Backroad, 2017 Raleigh Gran Prix, 1980s Bianchi Mixte on a trainer. Others are now gone.
Liked 1,505 Times
in
1,175 Posts
If I have a choice between eating Clif bars for a month and eating some good food, I will take the good food.
***
In August I met three different parties of bike packers, I was mountain biking while car camping. One of the groups had to do a 6 mile detour for water earlier during the day because they were so concerned about weight that they ran out of water. The other two groups were seriously dehydrated from running out of water before they made it to the campsite. One of them, I gave him half of one of my water bottles because I was afraid he would not make the last two miles to get to the campsite.
I am not saying I enjoy carrying too much weight, but if I finish the day with one extra full bottle of water, it does not bother me at all that I carried an extra pound and a half of water for that day.
#53
Banned.
I don't really accept the premise of the OP. Ultralght touring isn't unpopular. I've toured in a variety of styles, from an expedition tourer with 40lbs of gear, including two-person tent and all the trimmings, to a roadbike with a saddlebag weighing less than 10lbs. My question is, what do I need to stay comfortable? If I'm camping and self-catering, my enjoyment is increased more by having a decent sleeping bag/pad and roomy tent than it is compromised by hauling a few pounds extra. If I'm credit card touring and staying in B&Bs or hostels, I'll take only a couple of changes of clothing and enjoy the sportier ride. But I see no particular virtue in being spartan for the sake of it, and I'm not sufficiently interested in saving a pound or two to go out of my way to purchase the lightest possible equipment.
#54
Senior Member
I think ultralight is getting more popular simply because it's easier to buy bags and gear that are suited to it. Also lighter bikes are available that are suited to touring. When I've toured a lot of other tourists are interested in my set up and amazed that I have a tent, sleeping bag and stove in my saddlebag. They are most envious when climbing hills. I keep my gear weight to around 20lbs and use a saddlebag because that's what I did back in the 1970s, I never seriously considered panniers. I like the lightweight approach as it allows me to enjoy the cycling more, makes travel on buses, taxis and planes easier and also makes camping more efficient.
#56
I don't bother with cooking supplies, I have no interest in it. I'd rather just snack on clif bars etc. like you, and grab a meal from a local restaurant once a day or so. I'd rather try new foods and ****, stuff I can't get made the same way at home, than boil some ramen noodles or something.
#57
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2012
Posts: 1,923
Bikes: Nature Boy 853 Disc, Pugsley SS
Likes: 0
Liked 8 Times
in
6 Posts
I'm not sure what you carry in your "14.5 lbs of gear" but I know what I carry and how I've used every bit of what I carry and could have used more. For example, I started a tour in Toledo this spring (last week of April to be precise) with some "ultralight" gear choices that made for some very uncomfortable nights for the next month. I usually carry a 0°F down bag but opted to try a much lighter bag based on previous tours where the 0°F bag was just too warm. I obtained a nice 1.5 lb 45°F bag that was totally inadequate for the first night on the banks of Lake Erie when the temperature hit 22°F. Even wearing my rain jacket, arm warmers, leg warmers, zip off pants, light jacket and extra socks, it was an incredibly uncomfortable night. Any less clothing and I'm sure it would have been unhealthy.
I had several more nights like that and even went so far as to purchase bulky (and heavy) sweat pants and sweat shirt to sleep in. I was glad for the extra room and for the extra warmth. Even as late as the last week of May, I had a night that hovered around 25°F in western Maryland. Without the extra space and extra clothes, I'm sure my trip would have been cut short long before that point.
I had several more nights like that and even went so far as to purchase bulky (and heavy) sweat pants and sweat shirt to sleep in. I was glad for the extra room and for the extra warmth. Even as late as the last week of May, I had a night that hovered around 25°F in western Maryland. Without the extra space and extra clothes, I'm sure my trip would have been cut short long before that point.
How much money you are willing to spend on gear has a HUGE impact on weight. An ultralight down sleeping bag that is of a "certain" quality and weight-to-warmth ratio can easily top $500 or more, depending on the temperature rating. My ideal 3-season bag is at least $350, though the one I use is actually a $300 synthetic (and thus, is slightly heavier).
I don't like your example with the sleeping bag. it's like complaining a tire doesn't work when you bought the wrong sized tire for your bike. My "ultralight" sleeping bag weighs less than 3lbs, but it is rated to 15º, so it's REALLY warm. It's ultralight, and it's warm. Bringing a 45º bag on a trip that is colder is user error, not ultralight failings.
An ultralight shelter, like say, the Contrail can be perfectly comfortable and resilient. Bike Grease and Coffee used one for all of South America without failure. Yet, it weighs less than a couple of pounds and stuffs away to the size of a large orange. Everyone's comfort level is different so I hesitate to mention this, but as I suffer from claustrophilia, I adore my bivy bag, and it weighs far less than a tent and packs to the size of a grapefruit, and is BURLY as bivy bags go. Totally waterproof and durable.
Cook kit: my titanium pot, pot lid, spork, pot scraper, canister stove, fuel canister, cleaning sponge, and stuff sack weigh very little altogether and pack in a little kit that is smaller than some Starbucks collectible mugs (they get bigger every year...).
I'm not refusing comfort, refusing warmth, refusing to cook, or refusing to carry multiple day's worth of food or a large quantity of water. I am spending a lot of money to optimize those processes. My touring weight went up since my first tour, in tandem with independence and self-reliance.
Last edited by mdilthey; 11-06-15 at 01:09 PM.
#58
Senior Member
I was going to say that I really do not want to eat freeze dried out of the pouch or use a spork with a single cup for all my utinsels, but then you made it pretty clear how you go that light. You do not even bring the freeze dried pouch or the spork.
If I have a choice between eating Clif bars for a month and eating some good food, I will take the good food.
***
In August I met three different parties of bike packers, I was mountain biking while car camping. One of the groups had to do a 6 mile detour for water earlier during the day because they were so concerned about weight that they ran out of water. The other two groups were seriously dehydrated from running out of water before they made it to the campsite. One of them, I gave him half of one of my water bottles because I was afraid he would not make the last two miles to get to the campsite.
I am not saying I enjoy carrying too much weight, but if I finish the day with one extra full bottle of water, it does not bother me at all that I carried an extra pound and a half of water for that day.
If I have a choice between eating Clif bars for a month and eating some good food, I will take the good food.
***
In August I met three different parties of bike packers, I was mountain biking while car camping. One of the groups had to do a 6 mile detour for water earlier during the day because they were so concerned about weight that they ran out of water. The other two groups were seriously dehydrated from running out of water before they made it to the campsite. One of them, I gave him half of one of my water bottles because I was afraid he would not make the last two miles to get to the campsite.
I am not saying I enjoy carrying too much weight, but if I finish the day with one extra full bottle of water, it does not bother me at all that I carried an extra pound and a half of water for that day.
A Swiss Army knife and bandana makes a fine lightweight kitchen.
#59
Senior Member
Nah. I guess people who can't make them work are just using the wrong kind of system. If you get it right, you'll sleep like a baby.
And the hammock needs to be pretty level. If it droops too much it means you only have one position to sleep in (on your back) and that's not going to work. I sleep on my side and even though it's a hammock it works fine.
And the hammock needs to be pretty level. If it droops too much it means you only have one position to sleep in (on your back) and that's not going to work. I sleep on my side and even though it's a hammock it works fine.
#60
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2012
Posts: 1,923
Bikes: Nature Boy 853 Disc, Pugsley SS
Likes: 0
Liked 8 Times
in
6 Posts
Nah. I guess people who can't make them work are just using the wrong kind of system. If you get it right, you'll sleep like a baby.
And the hammock needs to be pretty level. If it droops too much it means you only have one position to sleep in (on your back) and that's not going to work. I sleep on my side and even though it's a hammock it works fine.
And the hammock needs to be pretty level. If it droops too much it means you only have one position to sleep in (on your back) and that's not going to work. I sleep on my side and even though it's a hammock it works fine.
#62
Senior Member
This is not to say that I'm an ultralight tourer. But there are enough folks on this forum cheering for the ultra-light side, that I would not consider it unpopular.
Why isn't it popular with me?
- Money
- Comfort
- Experience
Money, of course, because the lighter the gear, the more it costs. Sure, I could also ditch weight by jettisoning gear, but if I've resolved to take my [insert item that 90% of bike tourists consider unnecessary here], then the only way to lighten my load is to get the lightest version of my gear. Sometimes it's a question of buying better gear or going on the trip. My penny jar isn't full enough for both (and it's heavy).
Comfort because I don't bike just to bike. I bike to go places and see places/people, and if I can't be comfortable off the bike, then I probably won't go. I consider every bike trip to really be an excuse to sleep in my hammock. I know there are lighter systems, but I've never found one more comfortable. A sweaty, cotton shirt doesn't feel good to bike in, but a dry, cotton shirt feels good to sleep in. I misplaced my pillow, but when I find, it goes back on the road with me, too.
By experience, I mean that I know what kind of experience I want to have. I could save a lot of weight by staying in hotels, but in addition to sacrificing money and comfort, I would sacrifice the experience of camping, which is one of my motivations. I could eat in restaurants or eat food that didn't require cooking, and so leave a whole other pile of gear behind, but I enjoy preparing a hot meal in camp. Getting out of my hammock and fixing up a cup of coffee in the morning is a joy. It's also more weight than what I need to carry.
So I don't think ultralight touring is unpopular in general, and definitely not on this forum, and I don't think it's bad way to go. But sometimes I want a pillow, a camping chair, a cold drink, and a little music. For me the challenge isn't in seeing what I can go without, it's about doing all the things I love, and also travelling by bike. Unfortunately "all the things I love" sometimes weigh more than twenty pounds.
#63
Senior Member
I have found ultralight backpacking to be pretty unpopular as well.
#64
Senior Member
Not sure what your point is, but sometimes so do I even when going ultralight. It never really occurred to me before but I guess that sometimes I have had more weight in water for a long dry section than I was carrying in gear. For me that is usually limited to a day here or there where there will be no opportunity for resupply for a 24 hours or more.
#65
Senior Member
I really think that "ultralight touring" is a bit of a misnomer......it's just touring without a bunch of useless heavy stuff. When I got back into touring I just didn't see the need to carry a bunch of stuff and started out with a saddlebag and some stuff sacks. Over the years I've adjusted things and by putting the Contrail tent fly and my 30F sleeping bag in compression sacks everything now fits nicely into a Carradice Camper saddlebag an an Ortlieb handlebar bag. I've never been cold at night or during the day because I have selected my gear carefully. I prefer to travel with just a couple of bags, but others prefer to carry more, there are no rules here, just preferences.
#66
Senior Member
I always carry 2 liters....so around 4.4 lbs, I can easily carry another 2 liters in my saddlebag making a total of 8.8lbs.
Going over Rainey and Washington passes this year in really hot weather I was ok with 2 liters in bottle cages and a coupe of soda bottles in my back pockets.
Going over Rainey and Washington passes this year in really hot weather I was ok with 2 liters in bottle cages and a coupe of soda bottles in my back pockets.
#67
Senior Member
I really think that "ultralight touring" is a bit of a misnomer......it's just touring without a bunch of useless heavy stuff. When I got back into touring I just didn't see the need to carry a bunch of stuff and started out with a saddlebag and some stuff sacks. Over the years I've adjusted things and by putting the Contrail tent fly and my 30F sleeping bag in compression sacks everything now fits nicely into a Carradice Camper saddlebag an an Ortlieb handlebar bag. I've never been cold at night or during the day because I have selected my gear carefully. I prefer to travel with just a couple of bags, but others prefer to carry more, there are no rules here, just preferences.
I certainly know that with me, a certain amount of laziness comes into play. A for instance is footwear, instead of actually going out and finding and buying some light "post ride" shoes, I've taken shoes I already have, same goes for my tent, its over 4lbs but am sure I would sleep well in a smaller much lighter one, but just havent spent the money on a one person super light tent that I would only use a few times (whereas our 2 and 3 people tents in the family do get used a number of times in the summer).
this summer I ended up not doing a camping bike trip on my own, so just never got around to this stuff and other stuff, but as I have said before on this forum, seeing how folks have gone with less stuff has inspired me to get the amount down, but then again, I'm fine too with my usual 30-40lbs of stuff that Ive toured with going back 25 years.
Its all good, and any time spent on a trip out on a bike on nice quiet roads is always good, no matter the details.
#68
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Raleigh, NC
Posts: 8,896
Bikes: Waterford RST-22, Bob Jackson World Tour, Ritchey Breakaway Cross, Soma Saga, De Bernardi SL, Specialized Sequoia
Likes: 0
Liked 6 Times
in
4 Posts
How many lbs is considered ulltralight? I rode the GAP-C&O Canal trails the past two summers with about 20-25 lbs of gear, but don't know if that's considered ultralight -- although it certainly is when compared to those with 50-100 lbs of gear.
This forum tends to focus on cyclists who do fully loaded touring. However, many cyclists ride supported or credit card tours with very light loads. Most of my supported tours have been ridden with little more than a seat bag, and credit card tours with loads ranging from a seat bag to one set of panniers.
This forum tends to focus on cyclists who do fully loaded touring. However, many cyclists ride supported or credit card tours with very light loads. Most of my supported tours have been ridden with little more than a seat bag, and credit card tours with loads ranging from a seat bag to one set of panniers.
#69
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2014
Location: mars
Posts: 759
Bikes: 2015 synapse
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
I had a full on tent with me on my last tour, and the one before that it was a hammock / tarp / bug net. Never camped out on tour in the rain or exposed to bugs, no idea why people think ultralight means mosquito city.
#70
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2014
Location: mars
Posts: 759
Bikes: 2015 synapse
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
I don't know where you tour but I've toured in plenty of "civilized" parts of the US where I couldn't find food at all. Even restaurants can be difficult to find. I usually carry three days worth just in case and have used all three days before I could restock.
Your system works for you but don't assume that the rest of us have to follow your "system". I'm sure you could save some weight by removing the saddle and seatpost as well as by riding naked but how many sacrifices are you willing to make?
Your system works for you but don't assume that the rest of us have to follow your "system". I'm sure you could save some weight by removing the saddle and seatpost as well as by riding naked but how many sacrifices are you willing to make?
Can you show me a post I've ever made here implying other people nee d to follow my system? I don't recall doing so?
#71
Senior Member
That guy isn't a real ultralite tourist, he has too much gear. Some of the fabrics are heavy. All you need is the same pack they use for the hiking strapped to the rear rack. Some people have the core load down to 6 pounds, 9 pounds can be done cheaply at the same durability levels as normal gear. The result is one looks just like half the people riding bikes out there. But I always overstate for emphasis (which is a bad habit). What I am really saying is that how do you know a guy is ultralite or not, without knowing more than you can see just passing.
I'd call this guy ultralite since he was cycling half way around the world, and he had the gear to climb everest. But maybe he had a 22" TV in there somewhere:
I'd call this guy ultralite since he was cycling half way around the world, and he had the gear to climb everest. But maybe he had a 22" TV in there somewhere:
#72
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2014
Location: mars
Posts: 759
Bikes: 2015 synapse
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
If you believe those are the only two choices than you don't know anything about camp cooking. I usually eat local foods for breakfast and/or lunch and cook a quality dinner. I have never eaten ramen noodles or anything like it while touring. For certain logistical reasons, I skipped the cooking equipment during my tour of the Black Hills in June. Finding quality meals that my body runs well on was a challenge. Nothing like going to a salad bar and finding many of the items slathered in mayo or ranch dressing. I would much rather carry a full cooking kit and make pasta with something like sautéed spinach, onion, fresh garlic olive oil and some sort of protein, like sausage or chicken.
#73
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2014
Location: mars
Posts: 759
Bikes: 2015 synapse
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
I was going to say that I really do not want to eat freeze dried out of the pouch or use a spork with a single cup for all my utinsels, but then you made it pretty clear how you go that light. You do not even bring the freeze dried pouch or the spork.
If I have a choice between eating Clif bars for a month and eating some good food, I will take the good food.
If I have a choice between eating Clif bars for a month and eating some good food, I will take the good food.
I stop by those roadside fruit stands and get fresh fruit. I buy bananas and apples at grocery stores for breakfast. I stop by delis and buy a few rolls, some meat and cheese for lunch. I grab subs and bolthouse farm smoothies for dinner. I snack on all kinds of delicious nuts throughout the day. Dried fruits, jerky, chocolate covered granola bars, etc. Plus at least one meal at a restaurant a day. Last tour I had sushi, lo mein, shrimp poboys, smoothies, craft beers, seafood gumbo, crab buffet, some amazing bbq sandwiches etc. I ate good as hell and never had more than a pound of food on me at a time.
Regarding water, I just carry my two regular water bottles, and try to never use the second one. When I'm in the middle of a big city or something I keep the second one empty, when I'm in more rural areas I always keep it full. I think out of the two weeks of my last tour I only needed the second water bottle once. I'm ok with carrying some extra water too, that's one thing I would never, ever want to run out of.
#74
Senior Member
That's the problem, they are cheap, they are light, they strangle trees, what isn't to like about them. Except you have to be a fanatic about them to get them to work for you. I have a Hennessey, can't sleep in it. I wish I could because they about double the number of places you can stealth. But I just can't afford another cult.
#75
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2014
Location: mars
Posts: 759
Bikes: 2015 synapse
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
That's the problem, they are cheap, they are light, they strangle trees, what isn't to like about them. Except you have to be a fanatic about them to get them to work for you. I have a Hennessey, can't sleep in it. I wish I could because they about double the number of places you can stealth. But I just can't afford another cult.