inexpensive fat bikes
#26
Fatbiker
Buy Used
I see lots of cheap fat bikes on Amazon and Bikesdirect. Are any of these decent? It looks like a lot of them have hi-tensile steel frames and weigh a ton.
Can you get a decent fat bike under $1000?
I'm 5'1". It seems likely only the better fat bikes, the ones made by actual bike manufacturers, would come in different frame sizes.
Can you get a decent fat bike under $1000?
I'm 5'1". It seems likely only the better fat bikes, the ones made by actual bike manufacturers, would come in different frame sizes.
#27
Newbie
A buddy of mine has been riding a Reid Hercules for a couple of years and is happy as heck with it. Said it cost less than a grand, new. Might be something to check out.
#28
Newbie
My wife is 5'2" with short legs. She was on a specialized Fatboy 24, until I saw this one advertised on FB.
It's a Specialized Hellga Comp we picked up for $1000. 26" wheels with 4.4" Ground controls. 2x10 drivetrain. Notice the standover height:676 mm!
Oh, the Comp has a carbon fork as well. I can't recommend this bike enough for someone of your height, the wife loves it!
It's a Specialized Hellga Comp we picked up for $1000. 26" wheels with 4.4" Ground controls. 2x10 drivetrain. Notice the standover height:676 mm!
Oh, the Comp has a carbon fork as well. I can't recommend this bike enough for someone of your height, the wife loves it!
Likes For flieger:
#29
Senior Member
Thread Starter
So I ended up ordering the Motobecane Boris LTD from BikesDirect. They just got them in stock (it's shipped but I don't have it yet.) $899, seems like a decent bike and comes in XS frame size.
I spent a few months combing through craigslist, FB marketplace, pinkbike, etc but with the combination of needing a less common size, low popularity of fatbikes in my area, and the bike shortage making everyone massively overprice their used bikes, it wasn't looking promising for finding one used.
I spent a few months combing through craigslist, FB marketplace, pinkbike, etc but with the combination of needing a less common size, low popularity of fatbikes in my area, and the bike shortage making everyone massively overprice their used bikes, it wasn't looking promising for finding one used.
#30
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2015
Location: North Central Wisconsin
Posts: 4,709
Mentioned: 14 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 3067 Post(s)
Liked 1,227 Times
in
794 Posts
Good luck. Friends of the mine that have purchased Motobecane fat bikes from Bikes Direct...The frame broke on every one of them.
#31
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Hey if it lasts long enough so that I get an idea of how/where/how much I want to ride it, and whether it's worth getting a better bike once bikes are actually available again, I'm OK with that.
Just not a lot of options right now with the bike shortages ... it's kind of crazy. I checked with bike shops in 3 states. Even the shop I mentioned earlier in this thread, that told me they had the Surly Wednesday in stock … it turns out they never actually had it. They said they were getting some in "any day" and then the manufacturer sold out before they got them.
Just not a lot of options right now with the bike shortages ... it's kind of crazy. I checked with bike shops in 3 states. Even the shop I mentioned earlier in this thread, that told me they had the Surly Wednesday in stock … it turns out they never actually had it. They said they were getting some in "any day" and then the manufacturer sold out before they got them.
#32
Fatbiker
Hey if it lasts long enough so that I get an idea of how/where/how much I want to ride it, and whether it's worth getting a better bike once bikes are actually available again, I'm OK with that.
Just not a lot of options right now with the bike shortages ... it's kind of crazy. I checked with bike shops in 3 states. Even the shop I mentioned earlier in this thread, that told me they had the Surly Wednesday in stock … it turns out they never actually had it. They said they were getting some in "any day" and then the manufacturer sold out before they got them.
Just not a lot of options right now with the bike shortages ... it's kind of crazy. I checked with bike shops in 3 states. Even the shop I mentioned earlier in this thread, that told me they had the Surly Wednesday in stock … it turns out they never actually had it. They said they were getting some in "any day" and then the manufacturer sold out before they got them.
#33
Junior Member
Join Date: Jun 2021
Posts: 16
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 4 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 12 Times
in
5 Posts
Thanks for the Surly Wednesday suggestion. That looks like a decent price for a new one from a reputable manufacturer.
Any other Fat Bikes in that price range or perhaps lower to consider out there?
Any other Fat Bikes in that price range or perhaps lower to consider out there?
#35
Fatbiker
#37
Fatbiker
#39
Fatbiker
I'm happy with my Pug. It's the only fatbike I'll ever need. Looking for something steel frame w/ smaller tires for when the snow is not flying here in SD. I like touring bikes, like the Jones LWB, Surly Troll, etc. Something like that. What I really really really want (in the worst way) is the Jones LWB Complete--but good luck finding one. Tempted to spring for the new Jones HD bike, but have hesitated because of the price and it's probably way more than what I need. Meantime--still shopping!
#40
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2019
Posts: 1,606
Mentioned: 8 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 581 Post(s)
Liked 921 Times
in
518 Posts
I searched all Spring for a fat bike in my size (XL) before something reasonably priced popped up. No new ones in sight, people were asking MSRP or more for used ones. The only other option was a whole shed load of Northrock (Costco) 'One Size Fits All' fat bikes, which likely wouldn't work for me or OP.
Through patience and a willingness to drive 2+hrs away at moments notice I did find a good quality one (2017 Norco) for less than a new one would cost, but it took a while.
Through patience and a willingness to drive 2+hrs away at moments notice I did find a good quality one (2017 Norco) for less than a new one would cost, but it took a while.
#41
Fatbiker
I searched all Spring for a fat bike in my size (XL) before something reasonably priced popped up. No new ones in sight, people were asking MSRP or more for used ones. The only other option was a whole shed load of Northrock (Costco) 'One Size Fits All' fat bikes, which likely wouldn't work for me or OP.
Through patience and a willingness to drive 2+hrs away at moments notice I did find a good quality one (2017 Norco) for less than a new one would cost, but it took a while.
Through patience and a willingness to drive 2+hrs away at moments notice I did find a good quality one (2017 Norco) for less than a new one would cost, but it took a while.
I keep on the lookout daily.
Sad times for bicycle drivers.
#42
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2015
Location: North Central Wisconsin
Posts: 4,709
Mentioned: 14 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 3067 Post(s)
Liked 1,227 Times
in
794 Posts
I'm happy with my Pug. It's the only fatbike I'll ever need. Looking for something steel frame w/ smaller tires for when the snow is not flying here in SD. I like touring bikes, like the Jones LWB, Surly Troll, etc. Something like that. What I really really really want (in the worst way) is the Jones LWB Complete--but good luck finding one. Tempted to spring for the new Jones HD bike, but have hesitated because of the price and it's probably way more than what I need. Meantime--still shopping!
#43
Fatbiker
#44
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2015
Location: North Central Wisconsin
Posts: 4,709
Mentioned: 14 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 3067 Post(s)
Liked 1,227 Times
in
794 Posts
When they say "steel is real" they always forget the last part of that phrase. "Steel is real heavy" is what it should be. That's a nice 31 lb bike that would be much heavier if it was steel and nothing wrong at all with hydraulic disc brakes. Really no benefit at all to a steel frame and cable actuated disc brakes IMO.
https://www.trekbikes.com/us/en_US/b...rCode=bluedark
https://www.trekbikes.com/us/en_US/b...rCode=bluedark
#45
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2020
Posts: 1,060
Mentioned: 3 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 529 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 255 Times
in
185 Posts
I prefer steel. There is a possibility that at some time in the future I might break a frame. I am heavy, and ride on a lot of rough tracks. I am confident that steel can be welded together again. Being cheaper to buy is a bonus.
Likes For alo:
#46
Fatbiker
When they say "steel is real" they always forget the last part of that phrase. "Steel is real heavy" is what it should be. That's a nice 31 lb bike that would be much heavier if it was steel and nothing wrong at all with hydraulic disc brakes. Really no benefit at all to a steel frame and cable actuated disc brakes IMO.
https://www.trekbikes.com/us/en_US/b...rCode=bluedark
https://www.trekbikes.com/us/en_US/b...rCode=bluedark
I don't buy anything but steel. I've had aluminum and it's light and all that, but it does break. I've never broken a steel frame. Yes, it's heavier. But lighter isn't everything. Everyone obsessed with lightness. I certainly understand not adding unnecessary weight to the bike, and most of my components are aluminum, but the weight-weenie thing gets ridiculous. I'm not racing, competing or anything like that, so weight is not an issue for me at all.
#47
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2015
Location: Left Coast, Canada
Posts: 5,126
Mentioned: 24 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2236 Post(s)
Liked 1,315 Times
in
707 Posts
It seems the 1120 still comes with 28h wheels. We talked about that quite a bit a couple of years ago in the touring sub forum. There were a number of complaints about spokes breaking back then. Not sure why the low spoke count choice for a bike designed for rugged off road use. More "looks" than practicality IMO.
Funny that in the general forum they are currently arguing endlessly that weight makes no difference and in the fatbike forum there is an argument that it matters.. considering the penalty already paid for 4+ wheelsets. 40-50T cassette cogs makes that a bit of a mute point. I can crank my stock fatboy.up the same climbing trails being done on CF 29r mtbs. It's the motor, not the frame that counts.
Funny that in the general forum they are currently arguing endlessly that weight makes no difference and in the fatbike forum there is an argument that it matters.. considering the penalty already paid for 4+ wheelsets. 40-50T cassette cogs makes that a bit of a mute point. I can crank my stock fatboy.up the same climbing trails being done on CF 29r mtbs. It's the motor, not the frame that counts.
Last edited by Happy Feet; 07-08-21 at 01:01 AM.
#48
Fatbiker
Aye, and for sure. I'm a big, burly kettlebell & mace swinging bastard. I drive my Pug hurling through time and space like a madman. Bike and driver weigh nearly three hundred pounds altogether. Eight speed Shimano hub, heavy duty spokes, fattest tires I can fit on the bike... I never break down. I roll on and on to my heart's content. Bodyweight and bike weight = momentum. On asphalt and pavement my knobby tires sound like a swarm of angry wasps coming up on the walkers and joggers. They jump out of the way as though they're getting stung.
It always surprises me to see how many lightweights just can't keep up with me. They put all this time and effort into this lightweight bike and clothing and the whole bit, but they aren't built strong enough physically and they just peter out after a little while. I think what has a lot to do with people obsessed with lightweight everything is they don't want to put the work in and get stronger and more capable, so they rely on a light bike; they want what everyone else has, afraid to be different; gotta have the latest gear; they like to LOOK pro; mass marketing gets their hooks in them, etc. I do what I want to do and don't care what others think.
It always surprises me to see how many lightweights just can't keep up with me. They put all this time and effort into this lightweight bike and clothing and the whole bit, but they aren't built strong enough physically and they just peter out after a little while. I think what has a lot to do with people obsessed with lightweight everything is they don't want to put the work in and get stronger and more capable, so they rely on a light bike; they want what everyone else has, afraid to be different; gotta have the latest gear; they like to LOOK pro; mass marketing gets their hooks in them, etc. I do what I want to do and don't care what others think.
#49
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2015
Location: Left Coast, Canada
Posts: 5,126
Mentioned: 24 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2236 Post(s)
Liked 1,315 Times
in
707 Posts
I definitely think there is a place for the "best" technology when it comes to bikes and that is when one is riding competitively. If you have already optimized the motor then any advantage one gets from optimizing the bike makes sense.
But... if one talks obsessively about the competitive advantages of one bike over another yet only rides recreationally, as most of us do here, and hasn't optimized the motor, it comes across that the "competition" is just how fancy a bike one can buy. Using a credit card is not a skill. I suspect, except for a few outliers, most people participating on this forum could not out ride the capabilities of even a mid grade fat bike. I know I just took my rigid Fatboy to Alpine Ski Resort in Fernie and the only thing limiting my progression through the runs was skill, not bike.
All that does not mean one can't choose whatever bike they want. That's fair play. But blah blah blah about how one is so much better than the other is boring to anyone who actually gets out and gives it on a regular basis. On the trails I meet few people who give a sh_t as long as you are riding.
But... if one talks obsessively about the competitive advantages of one bike over another yet only rides recreationally, as most of us do here, and hasn't optimized the motor, it comes across that the "competition" is just how fancy a bike one can buy. Using a credit card is not a skill. I suspect, except for a few outliers, most people participating on this forum could not out ride the capabilities of even a mid grade fat bike. I know I just took my rigid Fatboy to Alpine Ski Resort in Fernie and the only thing limiting my progression through the runs was skill, not bike.
All that does not mean one can't choose whatever bike they want. That's fair play. But blah blah blah about how one is so much better than the other is boring to anyone who actually gets out and gives it on a regular basis. On the trails I meet few people who give a sh_t as long as you are riding.
Likes For Happy Feet:
#50
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2015
Location: North Central Wisconsin
Posts: 4,709
Mentioned: 14 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 3067 Post(s)
Liked 1,227 Times
in
794 Posts
It seems the 1120 still comes with 28h wheels. We talked about that quite a bit a couple of years ago in the touring sub forum. There were a number of complaints about spokes breaking back then. Not sure why the low spoke count choice for a bike designed for rugged off road use. More "looks" than practicality IMO.