Selecting a budget 2-wheel cargo carrier
#26
Reminds me of a thread in the forum that was recently locked. Something about being an impassioned maverick.
Last edited by indyfabz; 05-22-24 at 07:33 PM.
Likes For indyfabz:
#27
Full Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: So. California
Posts: 311
Bikes: Gary Fisher Advance (1993, heavily modded); Fuji Absolute 2.0 (2010; modded); 1989 Miyata 512 (58cm; $50, thrift buy); KHS Classic (63cm, 12-spd); Schwinn World Sport (58cm); Schwinn Voyageur (58cm); 1987 Centurion Ironman (60cm); etc.
Liked 48 Times
in
32 Posts
It mostly in the nuances and tacits.
#28
Dirty Heathen
Join Date: Oct 2015
Location: MC-778, 6250 fsw
Posts: 2,277
Bikes: 1997 Cannondale, 1976 Bridgestone, 1998 SoftRide, 1989 Klein, 1989 Black Lightning #0033
Liked 985 Times
in
574 Posts
Look, man; I’m an iconoclast, I get it; I appreciate unique solutions, especially if it’s done with some panache. Headshok Cannondales, SoftRide beam frames; Iused to own a Buell, for crying out loud.
I never claimed that they’re some secret sauce, and everyone else is too close-minded to accept my vision.
Hope you own a good raincoat; I hear those hair shirts get really itchy when they get wet
Last edited by Ironfish653; 05-25-24 at 12:33 AM.
#29
Whole thread is TL: DR. Just a few quick things from experience.
I used a B.O.B. trailer on a tour. It is unique in having the pivot point completely behind the rear wheel, like a car travel trailer, and half the load on that pivot. On a (very) Long Wheelbase Recumbent, it was stable, unless descending at a good speed (even mild grades), I had to LOCK the steering, tight grip, and make slow steering movements, or the trailer would get into sway "amplification". Now this was with a touring load, but not huge, tent, sleeping bag, cookset, water, etc. When I later tried pulling behind my roadrace bike (a VERY rigid Cannondale frame), it was uncontrollable at low speed, felt like a wet noodle when climbing out of the saddle and rocking the bike (which I never would do on the recumbent, impossible).
Most trailers are two wheel and attach to the left chainstay or left rear axle; Either is fine if it has a flex joint, to only allow pulling and stopping with no bending force on bike, and not high trailer weight for high loads fore and aft. All have trailer weight centered on trailer axle, so very low hitch weight at bike, so low polar moment of inertia. Also, because hitch is near rear bike axle, it behaves dynamically like a 5th wheel trailer which is much more stable than a rear trailer hitch like noted above for the B.O.B./travel trailer.
The trailers that look like a hand truck: Look reasonably stable fore/aft, but if hitched high up at the bike seatpost, that means more lateral movement when climbing and rocking the bike; Check for stability during that, and also fast descents.
Years after I toured with my B.O.B. and LWB 'bent, I took a 40 hour course in vehicle dynamics of heavy truck and trailer systems, and came to understand the hows and whys of all of the above.
Lastly, if I toured now, it would be panniers, because moving a bike with trailer up or down even the smallest stairs, or through a doorway, or traveling with it, can be near impossible. LWB 'bent and trailer... comfy? Oh gosh yes, no hand pressure, no bent neck, could see the sights, etc, luxurious space, I didn't overpack, but never had to squeeze down my sleeping bag, just toss into cavernous rubbermaid container on B.O.B., and totally rainproof and had vent holes on underside of handles. But a lot of weight up hills, even worse on a 'bent, and a bear to transport unless by pickup truck or van.
I second the notion of looking for a used kid trailer, they are often dirt cheap at goodwill or on craigslist or garage sale.
I used a B.O.B. trailer on a tour. It is unique in having the pivot point completely behind the rear wheel, like a car travel trailer, and half the load on that pivot. On a (very) Long Wheelbase Recumbent, it was stable, unless descending at a good speed (even mild grades), I had to LOCK the steering, tight grip, and make slow steering movements, or the trailer would get into sway "amplification". Now this was with a touring load, but not huge, tent, sleeping bag, cookset, water, etc. When I later tried pulling behind my roadrace bike (a VERY rigid Cannondale frame), it was uncontrollable at low speed, felt like a wet noodle when climbing out of the saddle and rocking the bike (which I never would do on the recumbent, impossible).
Most trailers are two wheel and attach to the left chainstay or left rear axle; Either is fine if it has a flex joint, to only allow pulling and stopping with no bending force on bike, and not high trailer weight for high loads fore and aft. All have trailer weight centered on trailer axle, so very low hitch weight at bike, so low polar moment of inertia. Also, because hitch is near rear bike axle, it behaves dynamically like a 5th wheel trailer which is much more stable than a rear trailer hitch like noted above for the B.O.B./travel trailer.
The trailers that look like a hand truck: Look reasonably stable fore/aft, but if hitched high up at the bike seatpost, that means more lateral movement when climbing and rocking the bike; Check for stability during that, and also fast descents.
Years after I toured with my B.O.B. and LWB 'bent, I took a 40 hour course in vehicle dynamics of heavy truck and trailer systems, and came to understand the hows and whys of all of the above.
Lastly, if I toured now, it would be panniers, because moving a bike with trailer up or down even the smallest stairs, or through a doorway, or traveling with it, can be near impossible. LWB 'bent and trailer... comfy? Oh gosh yes, no hand pressure, no bent neck, could see the sights, etc, luxurious space, I didn't overpack, but never had to squeeze down my sleeping bag, just toss into cavernous rubbermaid container on B.O.B., and totally rainproof and had vent holes on underside of handles. But a lot of weight up hills, even worse on a 'bent, and a bear to transport unless by pickup truck or van.
I second the notion of looking for a used kid trailer, they are often dirt cheap at goodwill or on craigslist or garage sale.
Last edited by Duragrouch; 05-22-24 at 10:10 PM.
#30
#31
Full Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: So. California
Posts: 311
Bikes: Gary Fisher Advance (1993, heavily modded); Fuji Absolute 2.0 (2010; modded); 1989 Miyata 512 (58cm; $50, thrift buy); KHS Classic (63cm, 12-spd); Schwinn World Sport (58cm); Schwinn Voyageur (58cm); 1987 Centurion Ironman (60cm); etc.
Liked 48 Times
in
32 Posts
For my GF, I have used several HQ kickstands -- one Japan-made Specialized glass-fiber; the other German-made aircraft metal -- that clamped on chainstay AND seatstay. Robust and confident design, but all routinely came loose and ultimately broke. Nevertheless, these dual-clamp kickstands seemed to have been very gentle on the bike frame.
All things held equal, this type of load distribution is what may lead to central- , seatpost-mounts being gentler on bike frame. Nice fat/chunky seatpost, meant to support typical obese American males. The seatpost being geometrized by four (4) frame tubes.
Last edited by elcyc; 05-23-24 at 07:42 AM.
#32
Which trailer has a chainstay attachment?
For my GF, I have used several HQ kickstands -- one Japan-made Specialized glass-fiber; the other German-made aircraft metal -- that clamped on chainstay AND seatstay. Robust and confident design, but all routinely came loose and ultimately broke. Nevertheless, these dual-clamp kickstands seemed to have been very gently on the bike frame.
For my GF, I have used several HQ kickstands -- one Japan-made Specialized glass-fiber; the other German-made aircraft metal -- that clamped on chainstay AND seatstay. Robust and confident design, but all routinely came loose and ultimately broke. Nevertheless, these dual-clamp kickstands seemed to have been very gently on the bike frame.
#33
Banned
Now that it's been established this thread is a show-n-tell rather than OP seeking help, maybe it would be a better fit in "Utility Cycling." Will make OP's motivation clear if he keeps posting this stuff in "General."
#34
I think the two-kid trailer I have in storage, has a rubber-lined clamp that clamps around the left chainstay, and a u-joint between it and the trailer tongue. Early trailers aimed for a simple hookup without special parts, like the special B.O.B. skewer or Nutz required to hook one of those up.
#35
Full Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: So. California
Posts: 311
Bikes: Gary Fisher Advance (1993, heavily modded); Fuji Absolute 2.0 (2010; modded); 1989 Miyata 512 (58cm; $50, thrift buy); KHS Classic (63cm, 12-spd); Schwinn World Sport (58cm); Schwinn Voyageur (58cm); 1987 Centurion Ironman (60cm); etc.
Liked 48 Times
in
32 Posts
100-mile update on the $135 Aosom Bike Cargo Trailer
100-mile update on the $135 trailer.
Amazon description: "Aosom Bike Cargo Trailer, Bicycle Trailer, Heavy-Duty Bike Wagon Cart, Foldable Compact Storage, with Universal Hitch, 16" Wheels, 88 lbs. Capacity, Black"
I don't have Amazon Prime but still received the Aosom, a day after order, at $135.
Assembly was fairly straightfwd, but diagrams very small and hard to read/see.
CONS:
(in order of seriousness and caution!)
(1) The trailer can tip over on to left or right (but not fully) in a ridiculous "uni-cycle" position ... IF... one side ( left or right wheel) encounters pylon, large rock, medium-sized pothole, or (especially) curb of street or sidewalk. EVEN AT LOW SPEEDS. EVEN WITH MEDIUM LOAD, WELL SECURED WITH BUNGEE . Maybe it's the large 16" wheels? But the center of grav. still pretty low compared to child/pet carrier. Dunno folks! Not sure if other trailers -- such as better-rated Burley or axle mount or child /pet carriers (!!!) -- succumb to this dangerous maneuver. But this is major flaw. Not for off roading or rough city streets or (especially ) inattentive towing.
(2) Not light. And mass more spread out throughout trailer (not tight and centered). Maybe Burley or Topeak or DIY trailers are better, lighter design.
(3) Not foldable; despite ad/description. If you get one, you'll find out why!
PROS:
-Large wheels make up-down stairs and steps easy. Frame never scrapes. In and out of my 2nd story condo units (multiple flights of steps) in seconds.
-Despite large size, using its "handle bars" to maneuver just bikeless trailer, such as move inside garage or home, with tight corners, is very easy.
-Quick disconnect works well. (not sure how long it'll last).
-For commuting; grocery-getting: Better than panniers on smooth roads/paths. Because: I can use light road bike to locomotive. Which responds better and more agile than my decked-out Gary Fisher hybrid mod (4 panniers; heavier; less maneuverable ). Overall: light steel road bike + trailer = less rolling resistance, better aerodynamics and maneuverability than my GF hybrid . Again, on smooth roads/paths, with proactive foreknowledge/planning/AWARENESS and attentiveness that one is towing a trailer that might tip. Maybe a learning curve thing ????
OTHER:
The spring hitch mech that allows trailer to turn does not inspire long-term confidence. Then again, this is my first experience with any bike trailer.
Bungee or secure all content. This will help stability FEEL and confidence of bike+trailer.
At standstill, don't move the hand-move trailer - -as when you may be locking up both units -- with it attached to the (bike); you will easily topple a light road bike (even on a roubust kickstand).
The quick -lock keys rattle. You'll need to bungee them to quiet the beast down.
It may become second nature once the CONS are planned for.
Amazon description: "Aosom Bike Cargo Trailer, Bicycle Trailer, Heavy-Duty Bike Wagon Cart, Foldable Compact Storage, with Universal Hitch, 16" Wheels, 88 lbs. Capacity, Black"
I don't have Amazon Prime but still received the Aosom, a day after order, at $135.
Assembly was fairly straightfwd, but diagrams very small and hard to read/see.
CONS:
(in order of seriousness and caution!)
(1) The trailer can tip over on to left or right (but not fully) in a ridiculous "uni-cycle" position ... IF... one side ( left or right wheel) encounters pylon, large rock, medium-sized pothole, or (especially) curb of street or sidewalk. EVEN AT LOW SPEEDS. EVEN WITH MEDIUM LOAD, WELL SECURED WITH BUNGEE . Maybe it's the large 16" wheels? But the center of grav. still pretty low compared to child/pet carrier. Dunno folks! Not sure if other trailers -- such as better-rated Burley or axle mount or child /pet carriers (!!!) -- succumb to this dangerous maneuver. But this is major flaw. Not for off roading or rough city streets or (especially ) inattentive towing.
(2) Not light. And mass more spread out throughout trailer (not tight and centered). Maybe Burley or Topeak or DIY trailers are better, lighter design.
(3) Not foldable; despite ad/description. If you get one, you'll find out why!
PROS:
-Large wheels make up-down stairs and steps easy. Frame never scrapes. In and out of my 2nd story condo units (multiple flights of steps) in seconds.
-Despite large size, using its "handle bars" to maneuver just bikeless trailer, such as move inside garage or home, with tight corners, is very easy.
-Quick disconnect works well. (not sure how long it'll last).
-For commuting; grocery-getting: Better than panniers on smooth roads/paths. Because: I can use light road bike to locomotive. Which responds better and more agile than my decked-out Gary Fisher hybrid mod (4 panniers; heavier; less maneuverable ). Overall: light steel road bike + trailer = less rolling resistance, better aerodynamics and maneuverability than my GF hybrid . Again, on smooth roads/paths, with proactive foreknowledge/planning/AWARENESS and attentiveness that one is towing a trailer that might tip. Maybe a learning curve thing ????
OTHER:
The spring hitch mech that allows trailer to turn does not inspire long-term confidence. Then again, this is my first experience with any bike trailer.
Bungee or secure all content. This will help stability FEEL and confidence of bike+trailer.
At standstill, don't move the hand-move trailer - -as when you may be locking up both units -- with it attached to the (bike); you will easily topple a light road bike (even on a roubust kickstand).
The quick -lock keys rattle. You'll need to bungee them to quiet the beast down.
It may become second nature once the CONS are planned for.
#36
(1) The trailer can tip over on to left or right (but not fully) in a ridiculous "uni-cycle" position ... IF... one side ( left or right wheel) encounters pylon, large rock, medium-sized pothole, or (especially) curb of street or sidewalk. EVEN AT LOW SPEEDS. EVEN WITH MEDIUM LOAD, WELL SECURED WITH BUNGEE . Maybe it's the large 16" wheels? But the center of grav. still pretty low compared to child/pet carrier. Dunno folks! Not sure if other trailers -- such as better-rated Burley or axle mount or child /pet carriers (!!!) -- succumb to this dangerous maneuver. But this is major flaw. Not for off roading or rough city streets or (especially ) inattentive towing
To address both issues, the trailers I've designed (not for bikes) have the wheels on trailing arms and torsion springs or spring/damper units for better energy absorption and dissipation, with the wheels more alongside the frame for lower chassis center of gravity. Somebody made an ultralight trailer like that for boats and kayaks and such, can't recall if for car or bike. Ah, here's one, can't recall if that is the one I saw years back or different, you can just barely see the spring/damper units. I personally would have designed it for the load to sit lower between the wheels:
However, with a long enough trailer, you may then scrape front or rear, up and down incline transitions.
With a tracked vehicle (like a tank), I can get the CG real low, and not scrape at either end, but the tracks wear so bad on pavement and take a lot of power to execute vehicle turns.
Last edited by Duragrouch; 05-30-24 at 01:19 AM.
#37
Full Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: So. California
Posts: 311
Bikes: Gary Fisher Advance (1993, heavily modded); Fuji Absolute 2.0 (2010; modded); 1989 Miyata 512 (58cm; $50, thrift buy); KHS Classic (63cm, 12-spd); Schwinn World Sport (58cm); Schwinn Voyageur (58cm); 1987 Centurion Ironman (60cm); etc.
Liked 48 Times
in
32 Posts
skinnier tires to lower rolling friction
It's not the wheel size per se, but that the load is all above wheel center at that height. Smaller wheels would lower the CG with respect to track (width between tire centers). My guess is they use a solid rod as axle across both wheels and run the rod under the frame? If not, if the wheels secured to brackets at each side, I would have mounted the wheels higher on the frame. The other issue is the wheel hitting an obstruction and it's relatively light without much ability to absorb energy (no suspension except the tires) so bounces high, tipping the trailer.
No chassis-wide connecting axle rod, as on Burley. But I like the Aosom wheel-to-chassis design better than Burley -- see photos.
Taller wheels do help when not connected to bike; maneuvering the Aosom up down stairs and around inside furniture. See prev. post.
Since the Aosom does not do off-road and rough roads all that well with stock tires, why not optimize trailer for smooth paths and roads? Ergo: Looking for skinnier tires to lower rolling friction on the 16" trailer wheels. Anyone know of a source?
BOTTOM LINE:
How many reading this post have experienced trailer tipping ? What trailer are/were you using?
#38
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: San Jose (Willow Glen) Ca
Posts: 10,390
Bikes: Kirk Custom JK Special, '84 Team Miyata,(dura ace old school) 80?? SR Semi-Pro 600 Arabesque
Liked 3,492 Times
in
1,825 Posts
Maybe having high mount vs the recommend lower mounting position has a difference in the tippyness ?
__________________
Life is too short not to ride the best bike you have, as much as you can.
Life is too short not to ride the best bike you have, as much as you can.
Likes For squirtdad:
#39
You may have something there. I first considered that and then dismissed it. But thinking now... A low hitch at same height as wheel center, one wheel goes up, would rotate laterally about that hitch point; A much higher hitch will rotate laterally about that higher hitch point, which may cause the trailer to move laterally in the direction of the raised wheel, increasing the propensity to tip over onto the unraised wheel. Just a theory.
#40
Dirty Heathen
Join Date: Oct 2015
Location: MC-778, 6250 fsw
Posts: 2,277
Bikes: 1997 Cannondale, 1976 Bridgestone, 1998 SoftRide, 1989 Klein, 1989 Black Lightning #0033
Liked 985 Times
in
574 Posts
You may have something there. I first considered that and then dismissed it. But thinking now... A low hitch at same height as wheel center, one wheel goes up, would rotate laterally about that hitch point; A much higher hitch will rotate laterally about that higher hitch point, which may cause the trailer to move laterally in the direction of the raised wheel, increasing the propensity to tip over onto the unraised wheel. Just a theory.
Also, small wheels are more likely to hang up on obstacles than larger ones. A 20" like many better models use, will climb a curb, for example, with much less abrupt of a bounce than the OPs 16s.
I had a Chariot Cougar 2-seat model for many years , which uses 20" wheels, and has them mounted on a 1/4-leaf suspension, mounted at the back edge of the chassis, above the frame rail; made for a very smooth, stable ride.
I had a couple incidents where I hooked a wheel on something (curb, bollards, trees) hard enough to take my bike out from under me, but never was the trailer anywhere close to rolling over.