An underrated aspect of cycling as a sport is ...
#126
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Mississauga/Toronto, Ontario canada
Posts: 8,719
Bikes: I have 3 singlespeed/fixed gear bikes
Liked 2,496 Times
in
1,287 Posts
I don't need a coach to tech me how to commute , how to ride my mountain bike on singletrack or how to go on a recreational ride. Experience is the best teacher and I learned a lot in the past 12 years just by going out and riding...I don't do any "roadie group rides" because I've witnessed some horrible riding practises done by club riders and I don't want to associate myself with those groups of people.
#127
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Mississauga/Toronto, Ontario canada
Posts: 8,719
Bikes: I have 3 singlespeed/fixed gear bikes
Liked 2,496 Times
in
1,287 Posts
Likes For wolfchild:
#128
Senior Member
The OP was not talking about pro level cycling or even amateur racing. I believe he is simply sharing his views regarding the kind of cycling most of us do, that is, recreational cycling. His thoughts appear to me to be innocuous and fairly accurate. I don't think anyone will deny that riding as a pro or as a serious amateur racer requires skill and considerable fitness. And I think that recreational riders have the necessary skills to pursue their interest in cycling in a safe and competent manner, skills that they probably acquired simply by riding. So, I retract any language that I might have used in previous posts that might be considered dismissive of other people's views. Cycling is fun, and most of us can do it as proficiently as we need to.
#129
Senior Member
And I disagree. I’ve seen too many examples where a very bad outcome was averted not by one rider’s skill, but rather the expertise of those around him. In most cases, the person never realized the damage they could have done. So that person rides happily along thinking they’re doing just fine in the group oblivious to the danger they are to themself and others.
Likes For asgelle:
#130
[MENTION=54365]asgelle[/MENTION] - in case you missed my earlier post:
So in your scenario where he's riding with faster riders and closing gaps before getting dropped...is he not participating with faster, more experienced riders despite his lack of skill? The very supposition this thread is about?
Is there a minimum threshold before one gets to claim attendance? Perhaps a faster rider circles around after he gets dropped and tells him "you can't claim this ride"?
Originally Posted by Spoonrobot
Except no (and we're talking faster, not more experienced*). Every time he opens a gap and then has to close it uses energy. It means he'll be dropped that much sooner than if he were able to follow wheels without opening gaps.
I could play tennis with Rapha Nadal if he lowered his game to my level.
I could play tennis with Rapha Nadal if he lowered his game to my level.
Is there a minimum threshold before one gets to claim attendance? Perhaps a faster rider circles around after he gets dropped and tells him "you can't claim this ride"?
#131
Senior Member
#132
Although I've been working at it, I also tend to not respond to an argument I'm losing or lost. So I understand, good luck out there.
#133
Senior Member
I know I said it before but to re iterate in the midst of all this group ride skills talk: you can be an avid cyclist and not ride in groups. I live in an area with two very popular road circuits and see many serious cyclists going solo or in pairs. It's far more prevalent than larger pace lines. In fact, a few weeks ago, guy in his 70's kept time with me for a while (or was it I with him) as we chatted - turned out he was quite active in the regional randoneering club and had done PBP - no small feat. All that was needed to ride with him for as long as I wanted (or was able) was endurance.
#134
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: Ontario, Canada
Posts: 4,626
Bikes: iele Latina, Miele Suprema, Miele Uno LS, Miele Miele Beta, MMTB, Bianchi Model Unknown, Fiori Venezia, Fiori Napoli, VeloSport Adamas AX
Liked 934 Times
in
646 Posts
And I disagree. I’ve seen too many examples where a very bad outcome was averted not by one rider’s skill, but rather the expertise of those around him. In most cases, the person never realized the damage they could have done. So that person rides happily along thinking they’re doing just fine in the group oblivious to the danger they are to themself and others.
Cheers
#135
Skills such as:
- Being able to wheelie/manual/loft your front wheel up/over ledges and or rocks, choreographed so that as soon as you reach the apex of the loft you shift your weight forward while applying the right amount of pedal torque to maintain traction and not spin out.
- Being able to stall, track stand, and readjust your line when climbing/descending steep tech
- Being able to ride over surfaces with extremely variable friction characteristics, at both slow and high speeds
- Being able to rip, row, and pump terrain to maintain your speed and line
- Being able to ride down drops that are difficult to walk down
- Being able to ride up very steep slopes and maintain balance so that you don't wheelie nor spin out the rear tire (fore/aft balance)
- Being able to threshold brake over surfaces with extremely variable friction characteristics, at both low and high speeds
I'm sure I missed a few but that should give you some concepts to chew on.
Spinay70
#136
Advanced Slacker
Join Date: Feb 2017
Posts: 6,252
Bikes: Soma Fog Cutter, Surly Wednesday, Canfielld Tilt
Liked 2,571 Times
in
1,451 Posts
Guess it depends on what you mean by “good at it”, but if you mean proficient enough to not keep screwing up and actually enjoy the sport with others, I tend to agree with the OP.
I know many people who do “B” road rides and even some “A” riders who don’t have very good handling skills. But they seem to pick ip what they need to know to ride in a group pretty easily. And as had been said, you can be an avid cyclist and not ride in groups.
Now, if we are talking about competitive riding... that is a different story. As is mountain biking.
Another difference is that cycling does not need to be competitive. Unless you are in a race, there are no losers. You can be the slowest rider in your group all the time, and never really feel like you suck at it
I know many people who do “B” road rides and even some “A” riders who don’t have very good handling skills. But they seem to pick ip what they need to know to ride in a group pretty easily. And as had been said, you can be an avid cyclist and not ride in groups.
Now, if we are talking about competitive riding... that is a different story. As is mountain biking.
Another difference is that cycling does not need to be competitive. Unless you are in a race, there are no losers. You can be the slowest rider in your group all the time, and never really feel like you suck at it
Last edited by Kapusta; 09-14-19 at 03:15 PM.
Likes For Kapusta:
#137
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Mississauga/Toronto, Ontario canada
Posts: 8,719
Bikes: I have 3 singlespeed/fixed gear bikes
Liked 2,496 Times
in
1,287 Posts
The mountain bike groups that I rode with before had no problem with allowing newbies to come along and ride with them over some "extremely technical and challenging trails". If somebody didn't feel confident they just got of the bike and walked over some sections. We were never in the rush to get anywhere. we were out there to have fun and didn't care about any speed.
#138
Advanced Slacker
Join Date: Feb 2017
Posts: 6,252
Bikes: Soma Fog Cutter, Surly Wednesday, Canfielld Tilt
Liked 2,571 Times
in
1,451 Posts
The mountain bike groups that I rode with before had no problem with allowing newbies to come along and ride with them over some "extremely technical and challenging trails". If somebody didn't feel confident they just got of the bike and walked over some sections. We were never in the rush to get anywhere. we were out there to have fun and didn't care about any speed.
So while it does take longer to “get good” at mountain biking, you don’t have to be as good to feel welcome.
Last edited by Kapusta; 09-15-19 at 01:04 PM.
#139
Senior Member
This is part of what I love about mtb culture. Most groups I’ve come accross are very encouraging to people less experienced. Waiting at the top of climbs and at the bottom of descents is just part of the deal, in my experience.
So while it does take longer to “get good” at mountain biking, you don’t have to be as good to feel welcome.
So while it does take longer to “get good” at mountain biking, you don’t have to be as good to feel welcome.
agree completely with at my 66 yrs of age. I would never be able to learn to play tennis , rugby, football or play basketball at my age and get to enjoy or be any good particularly with some early arthritis in one knee and not the best lower back.. But I started riding at age 60 and ride 50-75miles a week now and totally enjoy doing it by myself or with the company of good friends in my cycle group. There are riders in our club in their 70’s and early 80’s. He was indirectly making a very valuable statement for the aging population....if you are feeling and living the expected and unavoidable physical decline of aging...........you can take up cycling as a way to stay fit into your “later” years. Excellent advice.
Likes For Rstyle:
#140
Newbie
Like golf. But if you took up golf at 50, while golf allows you to play with much better golfers (and compete with them pretty equally on an agreed to handicapping system), You'd still be horrible at 56. Especially if you weren't a ball sport athlete growing up. Hand/eye coordination deteriorates, and you can't really get that back, like getting stronger. Of course practice/riding time and many other variables would matter. But back to the point, playing golf alone on a beautiful course can be very enjoyable and rewarding.
#141
that cycling doesn't require an inordinate amount of skill development in order to be pretty good at it.
I played tennis much of my life. I'm in my 50s now. If I had started tennis in my 50s, it would be a long time before good tennis players would enjoy being on the court with me. But with cycling, if you're healthy and willing to put in the time, you can soon be riding with cyclists who've done it for years and are pretty avid about it. And I'm not talking about being super competitive. I just mean being good enough so that you can enter a wide range of group rides.
Tennis, golf and cycling are sports of a lifetime, but cycling is much friendlier to late beginners.
That's all. Just another reason to like cycling.
I played tennis much of my life. I'm in my 50s now. If I had started tennis in my 50s, it would be a long time before good tennis players would enjoy being on the court with me. But with cycling, if you're healthy and willing to put in the time, you can soon be riding with cyclists who've done it for years and are pretty avid about it. And I'm not talking about being super competitive. I just mean being good enough so that you can enter a wide range of group rides.
Tennis, golf and cycling are sports of a lifetime, but cycling is much friendlier to late beginners.
That's all. Just another reason to like cycling.
Likes For myisland:
#142
Yep...anyone can ride a bicycle on an empty street... but riding with cars, potholes, glass debris, street lights, a group ride, a flat tire, a derailleur not working, etc. etc. require skills, there is no doubt. Perhaps we can learn those skills with out a trainer, unlike in tennis or golf, but we still need many skills...and if you go into competition...then things get more complicated.
#143
Trolling
that cycling doesn't require an inordinate amount of skill development in order to be pretty good at it.
I played tennis much of my life. I'm in my 50s now. If I had started tennis in my 50s, it would be a long time before good tennis players would enjoy being on the court with me. But with cycling, if you're healthy and willing to put in the time, you can soon be riding with cyclists who've done it for years and are pretty avid about it. And I'm not talking about being super competitive. I just mean being good enough so that you can enter a wide range of group rides.
Tennis, golf and cycling are sports of a lifetime, but cycling is much friendlier to late beginners.
That's all. Just another reason to like cycling.
I played tennis much of my life. I'm in my 50s now. If I had started tennis in my 50s, it would be a long time before good tennis players would enjoy being on the court with me. But with cycling, if you're healthy and willing to put in the time, you can soon be riding with cyclists who've done it for years and are pretty avid about it. And I'm not talking about being super competitive. I just mean being good enough so that you can enter a wide range of group rides.
Tennis, golf and cycling are sports of a lifetime, but cycling is much friendlier to late beginners.
That's all. Just another reason to like cycling.
#144
Senior Member
#145
Senior Member
#146
Banned.
'If I had started tennis in my 50s, it would be a long time before good tennis players would enjoy being on the court with me.'
I might not enjoy riding with you depending on your skills, lol. The operative word here in your semi-quote is 'good'! Some people learn faster than others. Some don't learn much at all no matter how hard they try. Some riders are 'good' in their circle of bike riding friends but terrible when riding with others who have higher a skill set. It's a relative thing. When I was younger and a lot faster we would go on training rides and sometimes we'd get silly, pulling each others jerseys, flicking their shift levers, hooking, leaning, head butting, striking, slinging and other 'tactical' play. You weren't supposed to do these things in races but sometimes you'd get away with it... until the end of a race! I was guilty of some of these things but not all!
I might not enjoy riding with you depending on your skills, lol. The operative word here in your semi-quote is 'good'! Some people learn faster than others. Some don't learn much at all no matter how hard they try. Some riders are 'good' in their circle of bike riding friends but terrible when riding with others who have higher a skill set. It's a relative thing. When I was younger and a lot faster we would go on training rides and sometimes we'd get silly, pulling each others jerseys, flicking their shift levers, hooking, leaning, head butting, striking, slinging and other 'tactical' play. You weren't supposed to do these things in races but sometimes you'd get away with it... until the end of a race! I was guilty of some of these things but not all!
#147
Back on-topic: I did a 60 mile mountain bike event over the weekend. Ended up riding a significant amount of the time with a newer rider who'd be riding only since the late spring. He was trouncing me on the single-track but I'd catch him on the descents and we ended up riding most of the climbs together and chatting. It was interesting hearing his background, he started riding MTB after seeing the NICA team on the local singletrack and had learned most of his skills riding with others. I've been seriously mountain biking since 2015 and have learned most of my skills from youtube and watching other riders - about equally. I think it was nice for the both of us, with vastly different levels of experience and skills to be able to ride together and talk, I took away some pointers and I think he did too. Made me think of this thread.
Last edited by Spoonrobot; 09-17-19 at 07:21 AM.
Likes For spelger:
#150
Some people...
Back on-topic: I did a 60 mile mountain bike event over the weekend. Ended up riding a significant amount of the time with a newer rider who'd be riding only since the late spring. He was trouncing me on the single-track but I'd catch him on the descents and we ended up riding most of the climbs together and chatting. It was interesting hearing his background, he started riding MTB after seeing the NICA team on the local singletrack and had learned most of his skills riding with others. I've been seriously mountain biking since 2015 and have learned most of my skills from youtube and watching other riders - about equally. I think it was nice for the both of us, with vastly different levels of experience and skills to be able to ride together and talk, I took away some pointers and I think he did too. Made me think of this thread.