View Poll Results: Clipless or Platform or Other
Clipless all the way!
50
54.95%
Nothin' but Regular Platform Pedals!
18
19.78%
Other/Both/Whatever
23
25.27%
Voters: 91. You may not vote on this poll
Clipless vs. Platform Pedals for Long Distance Riding
#26
Green lights for all
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Ohio, Germany, Florida, West Virginia, and then Georgia now
Posts: 103
Bikes: Fuji Team SL 20 spd, Nishiki, Mercian 12 spd. Alan 10 spd, Frejus, Bauer, Motobecane, Schwinn, JC Higgins 3 spd, Columbia coaster brake, Magna BMX
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Since developing neuropathy in my feet a few years ago after chemotherapy, I have a really hard time getting my feet comfortable. Using platform pedals for my commute and long FLAT distances work really well, but I get very nervous climbing without my SPDs. Fear of slipping off when I'm standing hard on the pedals…
I'm thinking of going for an extra large, extra wide clip less boot to see if that helps. I find the extra room in my sneakers helps the big dogs stay comfy.
I'm thinking of going for an extra large, extra wide clip less boot to see if that helps. I find the extra room in my sneakers helps the big dogs stay comfy.
#27
Since developing neuropathy in my feet a few years ago after chemotherapy, I have a really hard time getting my feet comfortable. Using platform pedals for my commute and long FLAT distances work really well, but I get very nervous climbing without my SPDs. Fear of slipping off when I'm standing hard on the pedals…
..People use this sort of pedal for singlespeed mountain biking.
Last edited by meanwhile; 09-02-14 at 06:42 AM.
#28
I use to prefer clipless pedals and wore them for years and years, however I developed a bad case of intermetatarsal bursitis and can no longer wear clipless shoes. They are too narrow for my feat and the tiny amount of compression drives my feet crazy. At first I thought that I would really struggle riding ultra distance without them however I have found very little difference. Perhaps if anything the muscles in my legs have developed slightly differently to counter for pedaling different, not so much round and round but round, up and down. I easily ride 200+ km in around 11 hrs.
I don't think that clipless pedals make as much difference to your riding compared to you perception of how you are riding.
Donnie
I don't think that clipless pedals make as much difference to your riding compared to you perception of how you are riding.
Donnie
I get worried when I hear people use clipless because without them they have a bad ankle orientation: to me this suggests a fit problem and I can't how locking the foot will remove it - instead it *may* transfer the problem to excessive strain on wear on a joint. But that's an amateur opinion and I'm prone to psychomsomatic ilnesses.
#29
Senior Member
spd 530s for the road bike and I'll be doing the double sided platform/ clip on my touring bike so I can use casual shoes around town and clip in for the longer stints
#30
Randomhead
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Happy Valley, Pennsylvania
Posts: 24,532
Liked 3,828 Times
in
2,608 Posts
in my case, I think it's the opposite, I develop issues if I ride with platforms too long because I'm sloppy about how I put my feet on the pedals and then pain slowly develops. I'm sure if I rode platforms all the time I would eventually become more cognizant of my foot position
#31
in my case, I think it's the opposite, I develop issues if I ride with platforms too long because I'm sloppy about how I put my feet on the pedals and then pain slowly develops. I'm sure if I rode platforms all the time I would eventually become more cognizant of my foot position
#32
Senior Member
I use clipless on my road bike (SPDs) and strapless clips on my hybrid. I used to have strapless clips on both, but find I get a tad more power with the clipless pedals, plus they solved my (mild) toe overlap issue.
#33
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 123
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
I rode 6/700 miles recently in normal trainers rather than my spd shoes in fairly close to brevet sort of times, (I have the same pedals as Machka has which has both options), and it was fine. I actually didn't have room in my minimal kit to fit a second pair of shoes or I would have had my spd's! As it happens, reading this forum today has made me realise I need to change my 14 year old mountain biking spds as I have problems with my feet when I wear them and think I need something better quality and stiffer!
#34
Banned.
I use clipless nearly all the time. I used to race, and some sort of foot retention system is pretty much essential when racing.
However, for ordinary purposes I think the advantages are pretty small. Out of the saddle sprinting, or hard climbing, definitely. Just riding, even for long distances, not so much. But if you're going to use platforms for randonneuring I'd definitely recommend biggish platforms and stiff-soled shoes.
However, for ordinary purposes I think the advantages are pretty small. Out of the saddle sprinting, or hard climbing, definitely. Just riding, even for long distances, not so much. But if you're going to use platforms for randonneuring I'd definitely recommend biggish platforms and stiff-soled shoes.
#36
Senior Member
I've considered trying clipless again, but I find lately I intentionally position my foot differently when climbing. I have a nasty habit of "ankling", resulting in pain in my left Achilles tendon, and when pedaling hard I tend to point my toes downward, which only makes this worse. I can mentally overcome this habit when cruising along at an easy or moderate pace, but when I'm going hard I can't seem to maintain the same pedal stroke. So on long climbs I'll place my foot so that the pedal is closer to the arch of my foot. And yet, there are times when I think I'd prefer to be clipped in (and might benefit from it).
Of note: This pain in my ankle makes it next to impossible for me to ride much over 40 miles, which means, unless I can figure out a solution, I can't do any rides of longer distances.
Of note: This pain in my ankle makes it next to impossible for me to ride much over 40 miles, which means, unless I can figure out a solution, I can't do any rides of longer distances.
#37
www.ocrebels.com
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Los Angeles area
Posts: 6,186
Bikes: Several bikes, Road, Mountain, Commute, etc.
Likes: 0
Liked 5 Times
in
2 Posts
I have normal SPD's on my commute bike but I put those Shimano reflector/platform thingies on one side of each pedal so it's kind of like a Machka set up. I have a lot of stop & go on my commute (and usually in the dark) so those work for that application. Shoes are most often 6-6-1 sandals, with Answer full-shoes on the rare cold days.
For long distance rides, any kind of recreational ride (except moutain biking) I use Shimano SPD-SL's. Very comfortable, easy in and out; absolutely no problems or issues with SPD-SL's. I mostly use either Lake or Sidi road shoes with these.
On my mountain bike I have normal SPD's, with either side available for clipping in. I use these with 6-6-1 mountain bike shoes which also quite walk/hike-able.
For my grocery-getter / Post Office / Bank errand bike (1957 Hercules 3-Speed) I use platform pedals and whatever shoes I happen to have on.
The key (for me) is to pick the right pedal/shoe combination for the specific application (ride type). Of course, your pedals (and shoes) may vary!
Rick / OCRR
For long distance rides, any kind of recreational ride (except moutain biking) I use Shimano SPD-SL's. Very comfortable, easy in and out; absolutely no problems or issues with SPD-SL's. I mostly use either Lake or Sidi road shoes with these.
On my mountain bike I have normal SPD's, with either side available for clipping in. I use these with 6-6-1 mountain bike shoes which also quite walk/hike-able.
For my grocery-getter / Post Office / Bank errand bike (1957 Hercules 3-Speed) I use platform pedals and whatever shoes I happen to have on.
The key (for me) is to pick the right pedal/shoe combination for the specific application (ride type). Of course, your pedals (and shoes) may vary!
Rick / OCRR
#38
just another gosling
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Everett, WA
Posts: 19,638
Bikes: CoMo Speedster 2003, Trek 5200, CAAD 9, Fred 2004
Liked 2,004 Times
in
1,423 Posts
I've considered trying clipless again, but I find lately I intentionally position my foot differently when climbing. I have a nasty habit of "ankling", resulting in pain in my left Achilles tendon, and when pedaling hard I tend to point my toes downward, which only makes this worse. I can mentally overcome this habit when cruising along at an easy or moderate pace, but when I'm going hard I can't seem to maintain the same pedal stroke. So on long climbs I'll place my foot so that the pedal is closer to the arch of my foot. And yet, there are times when I think I'd prefer to be clipped in (and might benefit from it).
Of note: This pain in my ankle makes it next to impossible for me to ride much over 40 miles, which means, unless I can figure out a solution, I can't do any rides of longer distances.
Of note: This pain in my ankle makes it next to impossible for me to ride much over 40 miles, which means, unless I can figure out a solution, I can't do any rides of longer distances.
#39
Senior Member
Solution is very simple really: concentrate on every aspect of every pedal stroke during the whole ride. That's how it's done. "Heels down, pedal round." Don't ankle. Ignore your foot angle and simply pedal with your heel cups. Your ankles will take care of themselves.
#40
just another gosling
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Everett, WA
Posts: 19,638
Bikes: CoMo Speedster 2003, Trek 5200, CAAD 9, Fred 2004
Liked 2,004 Times
in
1,423 Posts
I try to concentrate on my pedal stroke and I even do fairly well...until I hit a bad hill. When I have to put forth more effort, I forget to concentrate on my pedal stroke and automatically start ankling. I know I need to concentrate on my pedal stroke all the time, but I don't know how to actually do that. And I can pedal using other parts of my feet, but that gets old pretty quickly and when I have to really pedal hard, it seems I don't have as much strength unless I'm pedaling closer to the ball of my foot. Well, I plan to do a long-ish ride later this week; I'll just try to concentrate harder.
#41
Senior Member
Ah, that's right - I was forgetting that you are having an aversion to clipless. What I suggested only works with clipless. One needs to be able to disregard the fact of shoe/pedal attachment and ride as though the bike were a simple extension of your skeleton. Hadn't really thought about it, but am very thankful that so far my body parts have been permanently attached to one another. How awkward if that were not the case. Hoping I don't sound rude or at least not too rude - but that's how it works. The footbone's connected to the pedalbone, the pedalbone's connected to the crankbone . . .praised be Shimano.
#42
Bicycle Repair Man !!!
I spend most of my time riding clipless... nerve damage in my back and neuropathy in my left leg causes my left foot to drift so being clipped in keeps things in place and aligned while clipping in on the right allows me to spin efficiently with the good leg (which does more work).
I also use clips and straps on some bicycles and a few have toothier half step pedals which do a better job of keeping my feet positioned but I do not ride those bikes long distances.
Over the past two weekends I rode 222 km and 125 km and in both cases was wearing my Keen Springwater II shoes and running M324 pedals... my feet were in a state of bliss the whole time.
I also use clips and straps on some bicycles and a few have toothier half step pedals which do a better job of keeping my feet positioned but I do not ride those bikes long distances.
Over the past two weekends I rode 222 km and 125 km and in both cases was wearing my Keen Springwater II shoes and running M324 pedals... my feet were in a state of bliss the whole time.
#43
Bicycle Repair Man !!!
I've considered trying clipless again, but I find lately I intentionally position my foot differently when climbing. I have a nasty habit of "ankling", resulting in pain in my left Achilles tendon, and when pedaling hard I tend to point my toes downward, which only makes this worse. I can mentally overcome this habit when cruising along at an easy or moderate pace, but when I'm going hard I can't seem to maintain the same pedal stroke. So on long climbs I'll place my foot so that the pedal is closer to the arch of my foot. And yet, there are times when I think I'd prefer to be clipped in (and might benefit from it).
Of note: This pain in my ankle makes it next to impossible for me to ride much over 40 miles, which means, unless I can figure out a solution, I can't do any rides of longer distances.
Of note: This pain in my ankle makes it next to impossible for me to ride much over 40 miles, which means, unless I can figure out a solution, I can't do any rides of longer distances.
Two: Try and increase your cadence and spin a lower gear, faster.
Three: If you do try clipless again try setting the cleats farther back, this helps with power on climbs by engaging the major leg muscles instead of the minor (lower) muscles.
#44
Senior Member
#45
Senior Member
One: I think I have mentioned that you set your saddle really high which contributes to a toes down position.
Two: Try and increase your cadence and spin a lower gear, faster.
Three: If you do try clipless again try setting the cleats farther back, this helps with power on climbs by engaging the major leg muscles instead of the minor (lower) muscles.
Two: Try and increase your cadence and spin a lower gear, faster.
Three: If you do try clipless again try setting the cleats farther back, this helps with power on climbs by engaging the major leg muscles instead of the minor (lower) muscles.
I generally spin more than mash because my knees aren't so great, but I'll try to pay more attention to my cadence. And there are some especially steep hills here where I'm in my easiest gear and simply have to either mash the pedals or just get off and walk. That's with a 26t chainring and 32t rear cog!
#46
Senior Member
I also have a Windsor Tourist that I ride on the Katy Trail in Missouri. I use Egg Beater pedals with recessed cleats on mountain bike shoes.
I've done a number of 12- and 24-hour races back in the day. Twice I had to stop at about 160 miles due to knee pain. Once it was because big dummy here was just mashing the pedals at a low RPM and the other time because my seat post had slipped about an inch lower.
I'd hate to think what would have happened to my knees on such long rides if I wasn't wearing clipless pedals. They keep my feet pretty well locked into an ideal position. Also they allow me to pedal faster than on platform pedals or even when using toe clips. Plus my feet probably would be sliding all over the place on platform pedals..
I've done a number of 12- and 24-hour races back in the day. Twice I had to stop at about 160 miles due to knee pain. Once it was because big dummy here was just mashing the pedals at a low RPM and the other time because my seat post had slipped about an inch lower.
I'd hate to think what would have happened to my knees on such long rides if I wasn't wearing clipless pedals. They keep my feet pretty well locked into an ideal position. Also they allow me to pedal faster than on platform pedals or even when using toe clips. Plus my feet probably would be sliding all over the place on platform pedals..
#47
In Real Life
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Down under down under
Posts: 52,152
Bikes: Lots
Liked 599 Times
in
331 Posts
That's good. Just focus on not pointing your toes down and see how that goes. It's kind of like scraping mud off the bottom of your shoe.
__________________
Rowan
My fave photo threads on BF
Century A Month Facebook Group
Machka's Website
Photo Gallery
Rowan
My fave photo threads on BF
Century A Month Facebook Group
Machka's Website
Photo Gallery
#48
just another gosling
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Everett, WA
Posts: 19,638
Bikes: CoMo Speedster 2003, Trek 5200, CAAD 9, Fred 2004
Liked 2,004 Times
in
1,423 Posts
You did mention my seat height, and I lowered it as a result, but I still find myself pointing my toes downward. And if I lower it any more I'm afraid it will start hurting my knees. As it is right now, I can pedal with my heels and my knees are still slightly bent.
I generally spin more than mash because my knees aren't so great, but I'll try to pay more attention to my cadence. And there are some especially steep hills here where I'm in my easiest gear and simply have to either mash the pedals or just get off and walk. That's with a 26t chainring and 32t rear cog!
I generally spin more than mash because my knees aren't so great, but I'll try to pay more attention to my cadence. And there are some especially steep hills here where I'm in my easiest gear and simply have to either mash the pedals or just get off and walk. That's with a 26t chainring and 32t rear cog!
Prepping for a century with some steep climbs, Stoker and I were out yesterday on our tandem, climbing 1900'/hr at 50 cadence. The trick is to pedal smoothly, no upper body motion, arms relaxed.
Never walk! I'm against it philosophically.
#49
Senior Member
And that's the thing with clipless: you don't mash. You simply rotate your feet smoothly, though slowly, and up you go. I'm not particularly strong, but I can climb 10% seated in a 42 X 17 gear. That translates to a cadence of about 35 for me.
Prepping for a century with some steep climbs, Stoker and I were out yesterday on our tandem, climbing 1900'/hr at 50 cadence. The trick is to pedal smoothly, no upper body motion, arms relaxed.
Never walk! I'm against it philosophically.
Prepping for a century with some steep climbs, Stoker and I were out yesterday on our tandem, climbing 1900'/hr at 50 cadence. The trick is to pedal smoothly, no upper body motion, arms relaxed.
Never walk! I'm against it philosophically.
#50
just another gosling
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Everett, WA
Posts: 19,638
Bikes: CoMo Speedster 2003, Trek 5200, CAAD 9, Fred 2004
Liked 2,004 Times
in
1,423 Posts
I've wondered if using clipless pedals would help me to pedal more smoothly. And I definitely need to work on keeping my upper body relaxed and minimizing my movement there. On particularly bad climbs, I find myself really pulling on the bars, which I have to remind myself to avoid. I also feel that having cycling-specific shoes would probably help me a bit, too. I've tried some clipless pedals in the past, but they were ancient Look pedals that had seen better days, and I was using them to ride around town instead of long rides out of the city. So needless to say, they didn't work well for me. But I think modern clipless pedals would work well with the sort of riding I do now.