Clipless or not for touring?
#101
The bike culture assumes there is always some type of foot retention device. There are clips which are toe clips or straps and later came a cleat style that did not use clips or straps. There is no third option of neither
Maybe the third option is simply just implied as clipless AND cleatless.
Last edited by u235; 01-17-19 at 04:16 PM.
#102
ablasen
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: West Hartford, CT
Posts: 2
Bikes: Rivendell Atlantis, Soma ES
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Both have their advantages
I have toured recently with platform pedals and with SPD (hybrid pedals). I love the freedom of platforms and being able to wear whatever shoes you want to ride. "Normal" shoes are also better for the time off the bike. They are also better if you have to start and stop a lot (as in urban riding, if you want to ride from camp to dinner, etc.. But if the route is very challenging and/or you have an aggressive schedule, I would opt for clipping in and carrying a pair of Tevas for off the bike.
For platforms, the pedal should be very grippy, and it is better to have grippy shoes. I really like the Velo Orange Grand Cru Sabot pedals. For shorter local rides I have even ridden in Birkenstocks or Tevas.
For platforms, the pedal should be very grippy, and it is better to have grippy shoes. I really like the Velo Orange Grand Cru Sabot pedals. For shorter local rides I have even ridden in Birkenstocks or Tevas.
#103
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2016
Location: 961' 42.28° N, 83.78° W (A2)
Posts: 2,344
Bikes: Mongoose Selous, Trek DS
Liked 319 Times
in
189 Posts
To add what others have already said. If you want to make sense of it without getting Freud involved....
The bike culture assumes there is always some type of foot retention device. There are clips which are toe clips or straps and later came a cleat style that did not use clips or straps. There is no third option of neither
Maybe the third option is simply just implied as clipless AND cleatless.
The bike culture assumes there is always some type of foot retention device. There are clips which are toe clips or straps and later came a cleat style that did not use clips or straps. There is no third option of neither
Maybe the third option is simply just implied as clipless AND cleatless.
#104
Word.
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Rural New England
Posts: 232
Bikes: Surly Disc Trucker, Orbea Oiz XCountry Bike, Specialized Roubaix, Borealis Echo Fat Bike for Winter, many others out in the barn.
Liked 99 Times
in
51 Posts
Also, the contact area between the shoe and pedal varies from model to model. If you look at Crank Brother's Egg Beater pedals, there is nothing on them to contact the shoes beyond the retaining clips. Or the ubiquitous Shimano 520 style have about 0.5 square inch of contact which fits neatly within the recessed area around the cleat, not making contact with the walking surface.
Seems you could find a better shoe/pedal combination that the ones that you describe having trouble with.
#105
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Madison, WI
Posts: 11,568
Bikes: 1961 Ideor, 1966 Perfekt 3 Speed AB Hub, 1994 Bridgestone MB-6, 2006 Airnimal Joey, 2009 Thorn Sherpa, 2013 Thorn Nomad MkII, 2015 VO Pass Hunter, 2017 Lynskey Backroad, 2017 Raleigh Gran Prix, 1980s Bianchi Mixte on a trainer. Others are now gone.
Liked 1,589 Times
in
1,230 Posts
This simply isn't true (Unless you simply meant all the shoes you've tried yourself). On my mountain biking shoe, the metal cleat is clearly the lowest point, and makes contact with the floor. So when I walk around I sound like I'm wearing tap shoes.The cleats on my touring SPD shoes, OTOH, are tucked up in the sole enough that they do not touch the floor when I walk around, they make no sound.
Also, the contact area between the shoe and pedal varies from model to model. If you look at Crank Brother's Egg Beater pedals, there is nothing on them to contact the shoes beyond the retaining clips. Or the ubiquitous Shimano 520 style have about 0.5 square inch of contact which fits neatly within the recessed area around the cleat, not making contact with the walking surface.
....
Also, the contact area between the shoe and pedal varies from model to model. If you look at Crank Brother's Egg Beater pedals, there is nothing on them to contact the shoes beyond the retaining clips. Or the ubiquitous Shimano 520 style have about 0.5 square inch of contact which fits neatly within the recessed area around the cleat, not making contact with the walking surface.
....
I was unaware that Crank Bros made a SPD pedal, when did they start?
Shimano makes at least two different pedals with a number 520.
When I walk on pavement, I can hear my cleats contacting the pavement because shoe soles flex under weight.
#106
For The Fun of It
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Louisissippi Coast
Posts: 5,910
Bikes: Lynskey GR300, Lynskey Backroad, Litespeed T6, Lynskey MT29, Burley Duet
Liked 1,746 Times
in
864 Posts
I have never seen a shoe where the SPD cleats stick out from the sole the way that you describe. What kind of mountain bike shoe do you have? Are you sure it is not from the sole being worn down?
I was unaware that Crank Bros made a SPD pedal, when did they start?
Shimano makes at least two different pedals with a number 520.
When I walk on pavement, I can hear my cleats contacting the pavement because shoe soles flex under weight.
I was unaware that Crank Bros made a SPD pedal, when did they start?
Shimano makes at least two different pedals with a number 520.
When I walk on pavement, I can hear my cleats contacting the pavement because shoe soles flex under weight.
Crank Bros does not make an SPD. Their design is proprietary. The only pedal in their lineup that doesn't have shoe surface to pedal surface interface is the Eggbeater. I was thinking about your previous post on my ride today. I have some new MTB shoes and Crank Bros Candy pedals. I have only used them a half dozen times. It's finally getting easier to click in. The tread of the shoe needs to compress a good bit against the surface area of the pedal for positive engagement. I guess things are wearing in a bit now.
#107
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Madison, WI
Posts: 11,568
Bikes: 1961 Ideor, 1966 Perfekt 3 Speed AB Hub, 1994 Bridgestone MB-6, 2006 Airnimal Joey, 2009 Thorn Sherpa, 2013 Thorn Nomad MkII, 2015 VO Pass Hunter, 2017 Lynskey Backroad, 2017 Raleigh Gran Prix, 1980s Bianchi Mixte on a trainer. Others are now gone.
Liked 1,589 Times
in
1,230 Posts
Crank Bros does not make an SPD. Their design is proprietary. The only pedal in their lineup that doesn't have shoe surface to pedal surface interface is the Eggbeater. I was thinking about your previous post on my ride today. I have some new MTB shoes and Crank Bros Candy pedals. I have only used them a half dozen times. It's finally getting easier to click in. The tread of the shoe needs to compress a good bit against the surface area of the pedal for positive engagement. I guess things are wearing in a bit now.
Some of my pedals push harder against the shoe sole than other pedals. When I regularly use A530, M324 and Ritchey V4 Mountain pedals with various shoes including Pearl Izumi mountain, Keen Commuter 3, Keen Commuter 4, Keen Arroyo Pedal and Serfas mountain shoes, I have just about every possible combination of very sticky float to shoes that feel really loose in the pedal.
#108
Senior Member
Toe half-clips as they hold my foot in a fixed place and there's no trouble getting my foot out/off. Since my tourer is 90's the aesthetic is a bonus.
#110
Senior Member
If you use flat pedals and shoes, does anyone use a strap across the top of the foot like the bike messengers use?
#111
Nowadays many use clipless pedals. There is a short learning period where you may fall over a couple times because you've forgotten to unclip before stopping. I recommend Speedplay Frogs if they fit in your budget.
Alternatives I've tried include std toe clips, Powergrips and "half clips", which are basically the toe piece without the strap.
SPEEDPLAY : HIGH PERFORMANCE PEDALS
Power Grips
https://www.amazon.com/Power-Grips-S.../dp/B001FYGGLC
https://www.amazon.com/Zefal-Cristop.../dp/B002NGS9ZW
#112
Senior Member
Velcro straps are one of the more dangerous options, even more so than decent toe clips.
Nowadays many use clipless pedals. There is a short learning period where you may fall over a couple times because you've forgotten to unclip before stopping. I recommend Speedplay Frogs if they fit in your budget.
Alternatives I've tried include std toe clips, Powergrips and "half clips", which are basically the toe piece without the strap.
Nowadays many use clipless pedals. There is a short learning period where you may fall over a couple times because you've forgotten to unclip before stopping. I recommend Speedplay Frogs if they fit in your budget.
Alternatives I've tried include std toe clips, Powergrips and "half clips", which are basically the toe piece without the strap.
I'm a bit surprised about your suggestion for Speedplay, I thought that they were meant for road bikes/shoes, oh, wait, I've just looked online, the Frogs are the MTB versions of the road ones I've seen more often, got it.
#113
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2018
Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Posts: 603
Bikes: 1950 Sun Wasp, 1953 Armstrong Consort, 1975 Raleigh Competition, 1981 Nishiki International, 1988 Schwinn Voyageur, Mystery MTB
Liked 522 Times
in
207 Posts
I've got shimano saint platform pedals on my touring / commuter bike. I'm planning to use keen arroyo or newport sandals for my warm weather tours. Anybody else use those? My feet get hot, and they are wide. I like the comfort and utility of a closed toe sandal. I'm the kind of guy who stops for a nature sight or a quick dip in the lake, for lunch etc. A stiff-soled sandal is a good thing, at least for me.
#114
I do use and have (name of brand escapes me at this time) MTB shoes with Crank Bros cleats to go with my Eggbeaters (been clipless for several years) but I got to thinking that I might be more comfortable with flat shoes and pedals.
I'm a bit surprised about your suggestion for Speedplay, I thought that they were meant for road bikes/shoes, oh, wait, I've just looked online, the Frogs are the MTB versions of the road ones I've seen more often, got it.
I'm a bit surprised about your suggestion for Speedplay, I thought that they were meant for road bikes/shoes, oh, wait, I've just looked online, the Frogs are the MTB versions of the road ones I've seen more often, got it.
I have some Eggbeaters too, I quit using them after I got Frogs. I've revisited street shoes + flat pedals a few times over the years, I immediately swap the pedals out (again) after trying them. For me, Frogs are simply the best.
Last edited by seeker333; 05-22-19 at 02:55 PM.
#115
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Madison, WI
Posts: 11,568
Bikes: 1961 Ideor, 1966 Perfekt 3 Speed AB Hub, 1994 Bridgestone MB-6, 2006 Airnimal Joey, 2009 Thorn Sherpa, 2013 Thorn Nomad MkII, 2015 VO Pass Hunter, 2017 Lynskey Backroad, 2017 Raleigh Gran Prix, 1980s Bianchi Mixte on a trainer. Others are now gone.
Liked 1,589 Times
in
1,230 Posts
I've got shimano saint platform pedals on my touring / commuter bike. I'm planning to use keen arroyo or newport sandals for my warm weather tours. Anybody else use those? My feet get hot, and they are wide. I like the comfort and utility of a closed toe sandal. I'm the kind of guy who stops for a nature sight or a quick dip in the lake, for lunch etc. A stiff-soled sandal is a good thing, at least for me.
https://www.keenfootwear.com/p/M-COMMUTER-4.html
It has a very thick insole. The foot bed under that thick insole at the location of the cleat hardware has a very uneven surface. I suspect most people do not notice it but I do. I put a thin sheet of steel from a coffee can base over that uneven surface and taped it in place to make a smoother foot bed.
These were my first keen cycling sandals, but they are discontinued, no longer made.
https://www.rei.com/product/812176/k...ike-shoes-mens
I have heard that if you mount your cleats further back that it can fix hot foot problems. I have always mounted my cleats a bit further back and have never had a hot foot problem.
#116
Senior Member
Yep, Frogs are MTB pedals but they're also great for all-around road use. The cleat has a low height so you can walk in your bike shoes more naturally than some road shoe/cleat combinations. Frogs let you walk without damaging a wood floor. Their most useful feature is the no-spring-recentering design that lets you twist your foot laterally on the pedal like it's on ice, or as Speedplay puts it "knee-friendly, non-centering free float."
I have some Eggbeaters too, I quit using them after I got Frogs. I've revisited street shoes + flat pedals a few times over the years, I immediately swap the pedals out (again) after trying them. For me, Frogs are simply the best.
I have some Eggbeaters too, I quit using them after I got Frogs. I've revisited street shoes + flat pedals a few times over the years, I immediately swap the pedals out (again) after trying them. For me, Frogs are simply the best.
#117
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2018
Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Posts: 603
Bikes: 1950 Sun Wasp, 1953 Armstrong Consort, 1975 Raleigh Competition, 1981 Nishiki International, 1988 Schwinn Voyageur, Mystery MTB
Liked 522 Times
in
207 Posts
Are you aware of the Commuter 4 sandals? You can install cleats, or not, your call. Note the comment on the website about size, I followed their sizing advice and was happy that I did.
https://www.keenfootwear.com/p/M-COMMUTER-4.html
It has a very thick insole. The foot bed under that thick insole at the location of the cleat hardware has a very uneven surface. I suspect most people do not notice it but I do. I put a thin sheet of steel from a coffee can base over that uneven surface and taped it in place to make a smoother foot bed.
These were my first keen cycling sandals, but they are discontinued, no longer made.
https://www.rei.com/product/812176/k...ike-shoes-mens
I have heard that if you mount your cleats further back that it can fix hot foot problems. I have always mounted my cleats a bit further back and have never had a hot foot problem.
https://www.keenfootwear.com/p/M-COMMUTER-4.html
It has a very thick insole. The foot bed under that thick insole at the location of the cleat hardware has a very uneven surface. I suspect most people do not notice it but I do. I put a thin sheet of steel from a coffee can base over that uneven surface and taped it in place to make a smoother foot bed.
These were my first keen cycling sandals, but they are discontinued, no longer made.
https://www.rei.com/product/812176/k...ike-shoes-mens
I have heard that if you mount your cleats further back that it can fix hot foot problems. I have always mounted my cleats a bit further back and have never had a hot foot problem.
Thanks for the tips. The Keen Commuter sandals are no longer available in Canada, and they aren't available on US Amazon either. I wrote to Keen, and the fellow there told me that the Commuter sandal base is just about the same as the Newport or Newport H2, so I think I'm going with those. I don't need the SPD with my sticky pedals, so it should be a good solution. I thought of picking the new Arroyo 3 hiking sandal, but it is the same base as my Keen Targhee 3 boots, which are too narrow for cycling. Happy riding.
#118
I've got shimano saint platform pedals on my touring / commuter bike. I'm planning to use keen arroyo or newport sandals for my warm weather tours. Anybody else use those? My feet get hot, and they are wide. I like the comfort and utility of a closed toe sandal. I'm the kind of guy who stops for a nature sight or a quick dip in the lake, for lunch etc. A stiff-soled sandal is a good thing, at least for me.
#119
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2015
Location: QC Canada
Posts: 2,050
Bikes: Custom built LHT & Troll
Liked 167 Times
in
120 Posts
I've got shimano saint platform pedals on my touring / commuter bike. I'm planning to use keen arroyo or newport sandals for my warm weather tours. Anybody else use those? My feet get hot, and they are wide. I like the comfort and utility of a closed toe sandal. I'm the kind of guy who stops for a nature sight or a quick dip in the lake, for lunch etc. A stiff-soled sandal is a good thing, at least for me.
#120
The most comfortable pedals I've used by far are the Dmr Vaults.
- Big pedals for big feet (size 12)
- Slight concave (curves slight) design is very comfortable and I can feel generally if my foot is well positioned on the pedal.
I own a few other pairs of not-cheap flat pedals and I've stopped using them in favor of the dmr vaults. I'm more comfortable in these pedals and five ten shoes than I am walking around in my regular shoes, they make biking really really comfortable (for me at least).
https://www.dmrbikes.com/Catalogue/P...lt-2/Vault-NEW
I use Five Ten Freerider shoes in black
https://www.adidasoutdoor.com/five-t...men-bike-shoes
That's actually the same grip you get with Five Ten Shoes plus Flat Pedals...the grip is that good forward, down, and back (not up obviously).
- Big pedals for big feet (size 12)
- Slight concave (curves slight) design is very comfortable and I can feel generally if my foot is well positioned on the pedal.
I own a few other pairs of not-cheap flat pedals and I've stopped using them in favor of the dmr vaults. I'm more comfortable in these pedals and five ten shoes than I am walking around in my regular shoes, they make biking really really comfortable (for me at least).
https://www.dmrbikes.com/Catalogue/P...lt-2/Vault-NEW
I use Five Ten Freerider shoes in black
https://www.adidasoutdoor.com/five-t...men-bike-shoes
That's actually the same grip you get with Five Ten Shoes plus Flat Pedals...the grip is that good forward, down, and back (not up obviously).
I use these pedals with a pair of Crocs. Not the basic ones, but the Swiftwater clog. They are topped with leather, look good, have a stiffer sole than most, are comfortable, and they dry quickly after a rain.
#121
Banned
I got my well broken in Birkenstocks resoled with a denser rubber mid sole and a Vibram Outsole ..
At the Shoe Fix-Shop..
It stiffened up the sole more than the less dense original resole material ..
At the Shoe Fix-Shop..
It stiffened up the sole more than the less dense original resole material ..
#122
Senior Member
They're the worst of everything...
- worse to get your foot out in an emergency than flats or clipless
- getting back in at a stop is pain because the strap rotates down to the ground and you have to flip it back up
- clipless doesn't even get you an efficiency or speed benefit in lab tests so straps are even less likely to
I wouldn't recommend straps to anyone I know, it's flats (with five ten shoes if you want top grip) or clipless. Both are good systems, straps have drawbacks without having advantages.
Likes For PaulRivers:
#123
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2018
Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Posts: 603
Bikes: 1950 Sun Wasp, 1953 Armstrong Consort, 1975 Raleigh Competition, 1981 Nishiki International, 1988 Schwinn Voyageur, Mystery MTB
Liked 522 Times
in
207 Posts
I have the DMR V12 Magnesium pedals, though at the moment they need rebuild, there is a bit of play in one, so I need to get the rebuild kit for them. I swapped them out the other day and have the Welgos on it. I had them in the garage.
I use these pedals with a pair of Crocs. Not the basic ones, but the Swiftwater clog. They are topped with leather, look good, have a stiffer sole than most, are comfortable, and they dry quickly after a rain.
I use these pedals with a pair of Crocs. Not the basic ones, but the Swiftwater clog. They are topped with leather, look good, have a stiffer sole than most, are comfortable, and they dry quickly after a rain.
Likes For Ged117:
#124
Senior Member
I don't think that's accurate that bike messengers use straps nowadays.
They're the worst of everything...
- worse to get your foot out in an emergency than flats or clipless
- getting back in at a stop is pain because the strap rotates down to the ground and you have to flip it back up
- clipless doesn't even get you an efficiency or speed benefit in lab tests so straps are even less likely to
I wouldn't recommend straps to anyone I know, it's flats (with five ten shoes if you want top grip) or clipless. Both are good systems, straps have drawbacks without having advantages.
They're the worst of everything...
- worse to get your foot out in an emergency than flats or clipless
- getting back in at a stop is pain because the strap rotates down to the ground and you have to flip it back up
- clipless doesn't even get you an efficiency or speed benefit in lab tests so straps are even less likely to
I wouldn't recommend straps to anyone I know, it's flats (with five ten shoes if you want top grip) or clipless. Both are good systems, straps have drawbacks without having advantages.
I'm learning that these straps aren't as good as I had thought. I just thought that they'd be a way of wearing flat shoes but having some means of increasing pedal stroke efficiency.
Likes For jrickards:
#125
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Middle of the desert
Posts: 542
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
I use clipless mtb style because I feel way safer and more comfortable with them. Bumps, wet weather, etc. make it too easy to come off and lose the whole rig, especially when you're tired.
That's just me though.
That's just me though.