Trek 520 Dynamo Wheel problems
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Trek 520 Dynamo Wheel problems
I upgraded my 2010 Trek 520 touring Bike to use Brifters instead of bar end shifters and separate brake levers. The Micro new 9 speed shifters work very nicely. The integrated brake lever had limited cable pull so I added Travel Agent™ brake cable pulley adapter to increase the cable pull. The brakes and shifters worked very well.
The second part of the upgrade was a new 36 spoke wheel with a Dynamo hub to replace the existing front wheel. The new wheel with dynamo works fine until I apply the brakes firmly which causes violent shuddering which can be seen at the fork.
I order to troubleshoot the problem I swapped the new Dynamo Wheel with the Original Trek front wheel and the brakes work beautifully with no adjustments.
I would like to use the Dynamo hub wheel, could the problem be inadequate spoke tension? Any other ideas?
The second part of the upgrade was a new 36 spoke wheel with a Dynamo hub to replace the existing front wheel. The new wheel with dynamo works fine until I apply the brakes firmly which causes violent shuddering which can be seen at the fork.
I order to troubleshoot the problem I swapped the new Dynamo Wheel with the Original Trek front wheel and the brakes work beautifully with no adjustments.
I would like to use the Dynamo hub wheel, could the problem be inadequate spoke tension? Any other ideas?
#2
Overdoing projects
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Rotterdam, former republic of the Netherlands
Posts: 2,443
Bikes: Batavus Randonneur GL, Gazelle Orange Excellent, Gazelle Super Licht, Gazelle Grand Tourist, Gazelle Lausanne, Gazelle Tandem, Koga-Miyata SilverAce, Koga-Miyata WorldTraveller
Liked 1,319 Times
in
711 Posts
For the spoke tension to be an issue the wheel would have to feel floppy in your hand, I suspect the rim is narrower than the original wheel and the brakes need to be readjusted for the new wheel. Have you measured the rim width yet?
Likes For JaccoW:
#3
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Both rims measure 23.9 mm. I have also tried to adjust the brakes with the Dynamo wheel and can't stop the shuddering. The original wheel never has a problem with adjustment.
#4
Really Old Senior Member
I'd suspect the angle of the brake track between rims is different enough that the pads aren't hitting it "square", compared to the old rim.
I'd also suspect it'll get better as soon as the pads "wear in" to match.
I'd also suspect it'll get better as soon as the pads "wear in" to match.
Likes For Bill Kapaun:
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Rochester, NY
Posts: 18,341
Bikes: Stewart S&S coupled sport tourer, Stewart Sunday light, Stewart Commuting, Stewart Touring, Co Motion Tandem, Stewart 3-Spd, Stewart Track, Fuji Finest, Mongoose Tomac ATB, GT Bravado ATB, JCP Folder, Stewart 650B ATB
Liked 4,188 Times
in
2,471 Posts
Well one could swap the rims to the other hubs and try test fitting again...
I have had a low spoke tension front wheel cause shudder when braking before. Low enough tension to allow the rim to shift WRT the hub but not so low tension that it flapped about otherwise. What does the spoke pluck tone say? Andy
I have had a low spoke tension front wheel cause shudder when braking before. Low enough tension to allow the rim to shift WRT the hub but not so low tension that it flapped about otherwise. What does the spoke pluck tone say? Andy
__________________
AndrewRStewart
AndrewRStewart
Likes For Andrew R Stewart:
#7
Senior Member
Are you sure you're not feeling the notchiness of the dynamo hub. Take the wheel off and spin the axle and you'll see it doesn't spin smoothly. It is inherent to the design. When the light is on it is even harder.
Likes For zacster:
#8
Senior Member
Thread Starter
I have tried to resolve this by sanding the rim, changing brake pads, allowing the pads to bed in for several hundred miles. none of these has helped. The only improvement I have is putting the original non dynamo wheel back on the bike. I suspect it has something to do with the spoke tension or play in the dynamo hub.
#9
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Ann Arbor, MI
Posts: 16,960
Bikes: 1980 Masi, 1984 Mondonico, 1984 Trek 610, 1980 Woodrup Giro, 2005 Mondonico Futura Leggera ELOS, 1967 PX10E, 1971 Peugeot UO-8
Liked 681 Times
in
520 Posts
It's recommended that brake shoes be toed in when installed, to reduce the likelihood for chatter and squeal. I like to put a dime behind the back end of a brake shoe, and hold the brake lever or clamp it with a toe strap to hold the shoe in the desired position as you cinch the brake shoe clamp bolt. It may take a few tries, and you might need an assistant to give an extra hand. A Third Hand-like tool is also good for holding the brake caliper closed, but you will also need to hold the shoe in place as you tighten its clamp bolt. I don't know exactly how the physics work here, but it's worth a try.
Once the calipers and their shoes are positioned properly, I would next look at the cables as you squeeze the levers. Compression, squishiness, and excess play have to be eliminated. You should dress the ends of the housings (with a file) to be flat and perpendicular to the cable axis at every end of every segment of housing, and use ferrules that fit the housing snugly. The caliper pivots should be clean and adjusted for free motion without play. Any vibration should be conducted directly into the frame based on good conduction into the brake center bolts.
Once the calipers and their shoes are positioned properly, I would next look at the cables as you squeeze the levers. Compression, squishiness, and excess play have to be eliminated. You should dress the ends of the housings (with a file) to be flat and perpendicular to the cable axis at every end of every segment of housing, and use ferrules that fit the housing snugly. The caliper pivots should be clean and adjusted for free motion without play. Any vibration should be conducted directly into the frame based on good conduction into the brake center bolts.
#10
Half way there
Join Date: Sep 2015
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 2,963
Bikes: Many, and the list changes frequently
Liked 890 Times
in
533 Posts
You don't mention any specifics, e.g. make/model of rim and hub. I'm not sure that it makes any difference, but I'm curious. Most dyno hubs use cartridge bearings so play in the hub should not be a factor. You also did not mention whether the wheel was built by you or by a competent mechanic or if you just ordered it as a complete wheel. If the latter, you should do two quick checks. First, spin the wheel to gauge how true it is. If you have a bit of lateral wobble, that could initiate the resonance that you describe a violent. If the wheel seems true, then compare the spoke tension with your good wheel. You can do this by feel: grab two pairs of adjacent spokes and squeeze. A significant difference between the wheels would likely be the issue. You can also gauge tension by plucking the spokes. If the good wheel says "ping" and the new wheel says "plunk" it needs tensioning. Tightening each spoke by a quarter turn should not affect truing much and may solve your problem.
The other thing that may be happening is that the rim joint is not smooth so that the brake pad catches causing a pulsation. Probably not the violent shuddering you describe though. Have you tried braking gently at low speed to see if the shuddering occurs when the joint passes?
The other thing that may be happening is that the rim joint is not smooth so that the brake pad catches causing a pulsation. Probably not the violent shuddering you describe though. Have you tried braking gently at low speed to see if the shuddering occurs when the joint passes?
#11
Senior Member
Thread Starter
You don't mention any specifics, e.g. make/model of rim and hub. I'm not sure that it makes any difference, but I'm curious. Most dyno hubs use cartridge bearings so play in the hub should not be a factor. You also did not mention whether the wheel was built by you or by a competent mechanic or if you just ordered it as a complete wheel. If the latter, you should do two quick checks. First, spin the wheel to gauge how true it is. If you have a bit of lateral wobble, that could initiate the resonance that you describe a violent. If the wheel seems true, then compare the spoke tension with your good wheel. You can do this by feel: grab two pairs of adjacent spokes and squeeze. A significant difference between the wheels would likely be the issue. You can also gauge tension by plucking the spokes. If the good wheel says "ping" and the new wheel says "plunk" it needs tensioning. Tightening each spoke by a quarter turn should not affect truing much and may solve your problem.
The other thing that may be happening is that the rim joint is not smooth so that the brake pad catches causing a pulsation. Probably not the violent shuddering you describe though. Have you tried braking gently at low speed to see if the shuddering occurs when the joint passes?
The other thing that may be happening is that the rim joint is not smooth so that the brake pad catches causing a pulsation. Probably not the violent shuddering you describe though. Have you tried braking gently at low speed to see if the shuddering occurs when the joint passes?
IDC Stout - Intelligent Design Cycles - Dynamo Wheels and Wheelsets | Intelligentdesigncycles
#12
Senior Member
Having read the copy on that wheel I'd say they are doing their wheelbuilding right, as any competent wheel builder would. Tension, stress relief, accounting for the differences between front, drive side and non-drive side etc... I vaguely recall looking at them myself when I was putting a dynamo wheel on my bike, but ended up building my own. 5 years later I've never had to true them so I must've done it right.
The one thing I did note, and I knew this would be the case, is that these wheels are heavy. Dynamo wheels generally are. Maybe it is the rotational weight that is causing the brakes to amplify the normal stuttering of the hubs, and maybe you need stiffer brakes. The spec on the 520 shows Avid SD-5 V-brakes. I don't know anything about these but fwiw I have XT M770 V-brakes on my dynamo equipped bike. Make sure what you have is properly tightened to the studs on the frame.
The one thing I did note, and I knew this would be the case, is that these wheels are heavy. Dynamo wheels generally are. Maybe it is the rotational weight that is causing the brakes to amplify the normal stuttering of the hubs, and maybe you need stiffer brakes. The spec on the 520 shows Avid SD-5 V-brakes. I don't know anything about these but fwiw I have XT M770 V-brakes on my dynamo equipped bike. Make sure what you have is properly tightened to the studs on the frame.
#13
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Golden, CO and Tucson, AZ
Posts: 2,902
Bikes: 2012 Specialized Elite Disc, 1983 Trek 520
Liked 834 Times
in
465 Posts
Perhaps you've built a perfectly tuned system for a certain harmonic frequency. Contributors could be the magnetic pulse in the hub, the shorter spokes with different tension, different rim material and geometry, a slight play in the headset, the phase of the moon, and the way you part your hair. The things you can change are spoke tension and headset adjustment.
Does it change with more or less electrical load on the hub?
Does it change with more or less electrical load on the hub?
#15
Half way there
Join Date: Sep 2015
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 2,963
Bikes: Many, and the list changes frequently
Liked 890 Times
in
533 Posts
The Dynamo wheel is an Intelligent Design Cycles Stout model wheel, with Sanyo NH-H27 hub dynamo see website:
IDC Stout - Intelligent Design Cycles - Dynamo Wheels and Wheelsets | Intelligentdesigncycles
IDC Stout - Intelligent Design Cycles - Dynamo Wheels and Wheelsets | Intelligentdesigncycles
#16
Insane Bicycle Mechanic
Another variable: what kind of brake shoes are on the brakes?
I've had brakes grab very suddenly when I've laced new rims on a couple bikes. This has happened most often with Kool-Stop Salmon pads, once to the extent that the bike was unrideable. When I switched to Kool-Stop dual compound pads the grabbing went away. After a few hundred miles on the new rims I installed the Salmon pads again and the grabbing was gone.
IMO: brand new rims with machined surfaces have microscopic surface roughness that grab brake pads with a vengeance. Once that roughness is worn down the brakes will be more manageable.
I've had brakes grab very suddenly when I've laced new rims on a couple bikes. This has happened most often with Kool-Stop Salmon pads, once to the extent that the bike was unrideable. When I switched to Kool-Stop dual compound pads the grabbing went away. After a few hundred miles on the new rims I installed the Salmon pads again and the grabbing was gone.
IMO: brand new rims with machined surfaces have microscopic surface roughness that grab brake pads with a vengeance. Once that roughness is worn down the brakes will be more manageable.
__________________
Jeff Wills
Comcast nuked my web page. It will return soon..
Jeff Wills
Comcast nuked my web page. It will return soon..