How do I dispose of a carbon bike frame?
#26
Full Member
That depends entirely on the repair. If it is done to make the frame "look like new", yes, I wouldn't trust it either. But if the repair was done like the bonding of cured parts like in sailboat construction, with full respect for secondary bonds, I'd have no second thoughts about riding it. I did a CF wrap around the chainstays & BB of a steel frame with both chainstays about to break. When I finished, that was the strongest part of the whole frame. But, I made no attempt to hide the repair. Instead, I did clean work with careful masking and simply painted the repair black like it was always that way. Now, whether I'd want to own and ride a CF frame with such an obvious repair, well I just don't know. I'll stick to steel and ti where simple tube replacement is possible and brazing/TIG torches can do a lot.
Boats have very important structural pieces bonded inside the hull. Bulkheads for one. Those bonds are entirely secondary. Yet those boats go to sea and come back.
Boats have very important structural pieces bonded inside the hull. Bulkheads for one. Those bonds are entirely secondary. Yet those boats go to sea and come back.
When laying up successive layers of epoxy, it's best to do it all in one shot, to make use of the chemical bonds between layers. If done in multiple stages, letting the previous layer fully cure before adding the next, it's not bonding via chemical bond, and in that case it relies on a rough surface so that the new epoxy can "grip" the previous layer via mechanical bond, and such layers are more prone to delamination. Using rough sandpaper (or more easily, peel ply) can provide a fairly decent bond, but not as strong as chemical. Things can be embedded in between two layers (such as metal mounting plates), etc., before the epoxy cures, so you can still get the chemical bonding between layers of laminate, but the insert is mainly trapped / held in place by the laminate rather than bonded itself.
I think compared to boats, bicycles are much more critical and experience far higher loads. Boat hulls do slap down on the waves with sudden impact forces, but there's a lot of hull to provide strength, vs. a chainstay or seat stay on a bike which are very small.
As an aside... When I started doing fabrication with carbon fiber, the thing that surprised me most was seeing how flexible it is. A 1-layer sample of flat carbon fiber laminate (3K 2x2 twill, 5.7 oz/yd) is super flexible, like a piece of paper that can be curled up but springs back into shape. 2 layers is like a notebook divider, 3 layers is like a ketchup bottle, 4 layers is like a credit card, 5-6 layers more like a popsicle stick. People think it's stiff and brittle, but it's not...at least when thin and flat. Of course, when used in thicker thicknesses, and made into more rigid shapes such as bike frames, it does lose its flexibility somewhat, and we want it to. It gets its rigid strength from the shapes that are used. Sandwich materials are used (more in car parts...not so much in bike frames) where you can have honeycomb or foam in between layers of laminate and it multiplies the rigidity many fold.
I made 2 CF dashboards for my Miata... The first dashboard I made had 3 layers, and no sandwich material. It weighed 12 oz and could be pushed in by hand (like when waxing it), but returned to shape. The next one I made using 4 layers, with a honeycomb sandwich material in the middle. That version weighs 4 lbs and is very very rigid.
Also made a CF door for the Miata - 7 layers with foam core sandwich material, and weighs 7 lbs including a wooden brace where the hinge mounts to. (I wrapped the wooden brace with fiberglass and used a secondary (mechanical) bond to prevent the brace from delaminating. When clearcoating the door, I had it hanging from my garage door track, and it accidentally fell on its edge from a height of maybe 2-3 ft onto the concrete. The door made a loud "ping" sound when it hit, then BOUNCED back up in the air maybe 6 inches before I caught it! That barely left a scuff mark on the edge of the door. No damage was done.
Likes For jayp410:
#27
Junior Member
IMO as always. Not trying to claim any ethical high ground, just curious about the temperature of people responding to this thread. Google and Wiki reveal carbon fiber's toxicity and that so far very little has been or is going to be recycled or re-purposed. The environmental costs of steel and aluminum are well established along with the fact that they can be nearly endlessly recycled at a much lower cost financially and environmentally without repeating the damage of their original creation. All that damaged steel, aluminum and carbon shouldn't be tossed and should be recycled. I can only claim that my intentions are that when too old and infirm to ride my no chrome bikes, they will still most likely be in a condition where they can provide someone with many more years of dependable service.
Likes For Medium Size Dog:
#28
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2014
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 13,333
Bikes: (2) ti TiCycles, 2007 w/ triple and 2011 fixed, 1979 Peter Mooney, ~1983 Trek 420 now fixed and ~1973 Raleigh Carlton Competition gravel grinder
Liked 4,336 Times
in
2,790 Posts
OK, so you wrapped the whole BB and chainstay joint to create a shell. Were the chainstays still connected enough to provide the tensile strength? If the chainstays were actually broken/severed, I'd be very suspicious of riding that bike, with all of the tensile strength coming from a secondary bond between the carbon and steel. However if the steel was still connected and you just stiffened up the joint to prevent further flexing / metal fatigue, I could see how that would still be strong from a tensile strength standpoint via the steel.
When laying up successive layers of epoxy, it's best to do it all in one shot, to make use of the chemical bonds between layers. If done in multiple stages, letting the previous layer fully cure before adding the next, it's not bonding via chemical bond, and in that case it relies on a rough surface so that the new epoxy can "grip" the previous layer via mechanical bond, and such layers are more prone to delamination. Using rough sandpaper (or more easily, peel ply) can provide a fairly decent bond, but not as strong as chemical. Things can be embedded in between two layers (such as metal mounting plates), etc., before the epoxy cures, so you can still get the chemical bonding between layers of laminate, but the insert is mainly trapped / held in place by the laminate rather than bonded itself.
I think compared to boats, bicycles are much more critical and experience far higher loads. Boat hulls do slap down on the waves with sudden impact forces, but there's a lot of hull to provide strength, vs. a chainstay or seat stay on a bike which are very small.
As an aside... When I started doing fabrication with carbon fiber, the thing that surprised me most was seeing how flexible it is. A 1-layer sample of flat carbon fiber laminate (3K 2x2 twill, 5.7 oz/yd) is super flexible, like a piece of paper that can be curled up but springs back into shape. 2 layers is like a notebook divider, 3 layers is like a ketchup bottle, 4 layers is like a credit card, 5-6 layers more like a popsicle stick. People think it's stiff and brittle, but it's not...at least when thin and flat. Of course, when used in thicker thicknesses, and made into more rigid shapes such as bike frames, it does lose its flexibility somewhat, and we want it to. It gets its rigid strength from the shapes that are used. Sandwich materials are used (more in car parts...not so much in bike frames) where you can have honeycomb or foam in between layers of laminate and it multiplies the rigidity many fold.
I made 2 CF dashboards for my Miata... The first dashboard I made had 3 layers, and no sandwich material. It weighed 12 oz and could be pushed in by hand (like when waxing it), but returned to shape. The next one I made using 4 layers, with a honeycomb sandwich material in the middle. That version weighs 4 lbs and is very very rigid.
Also made a CF door for the Miata - 7 layers with foam core sandwich material, and weighs 7 lbs including a wooden brace where the hinge mounts to. (I wrapped the wooden brace with fiberglass and used a secondary (mechanical) bond to prevent the brace from delaminating. When clearcoating the door, I had it hanging from my garage door track, and it accidentally fell on its edge from a height of maybe 2-3 ft onto the concrete. The door made a loud "ping" sound when it hit, then BOUNCED back up in the air maybe 6 inches before I caught it! That barely left a scuff mark on the edge of the door. No damage was done.
When laying up successive layers of epoxy, it's best to do it all in one shot, to make use of the chemical bonds between layers. If done in multiple stages, letting the previous layer fully cure before adding the next, it's not bonding via chemical bond, and in that case it relies on a rough surface so that the new epoxy can "grip" the previous layer via mechanical bond, and such layers are more prone to delamination. Using rough sandpaper (or more easily, peel ply) can provide a fairly decent bond, but not as strong as chemical. Things can be embedded in between two layers (such as metal mounting plates), etc., before the epoxy cures, so you can still get the chemical bonding between layers of laminate, but the insert is mainly trapped / held in place by the laminate rather than bonded itself.
I think compared to boats, bicycles are much more critical and experience far higher loads. Boat hulls do slap down on the waves with sudden impact forces, but there's a lot of hull to provide strength, vs. a chainstay or seat stay on a bike which are very small.
As an aside... When I started doing fabrication with carbon fiber, the thing that surprised me most was seeing how flexible it is. A 1-layer sample of flat carbon fiber laminate (3K 2x2 twill, 5.7 oz/yd) is super flexible, like a piece of paper that can be curled up but springs back into shape. 2 layers is like a notebook divider, 3 layers is like a ketchup bottle, 4 layers is like a credit card, 5-6 layers more like a popsicle stick. People think it's stiff and brittle, but it's not...at least when thin and flat. Of course, when used in thicker thicknesses, and made into more rigid shapes such as bike frames, it does lose its flexibility somewhat, and we want it to. It gets its rigid strength from the shapes that are used. Sandwich materials are used (more in car parts...not so much in bike frames) where you can have honeycomb or foam in between layers of laminate and it multiplies the rigidity many fold.
I made 2 CF dashboards for my Miata... The first dashboard I made had 3 layers, and no sandwich material. It weighed 12 oz and could be pushed in by hand (like when waxing it), but returned to shape. The next one I made using 4 layers, with a honeycomb sandwich material in the middle. That version weighs 4 lbs and is very very rigid.
Also made a CF door for the Miata - 7 layers with foam core sandwich material, and weighs 7 lbs including a wooden brace where the hinge mounts to. (I wrapped the wooden brace with fiberglass and used a secondary (mechanical) bond to prevent the brace from delaminating. When clearcoating the door, I had it hanging from my garage door track, and it accidentally fell on its edge from a height of maybe 2-3 ft onto the concrete. The door made a loud "ping" sound when it hit, then BOUNCED back up in the air maybe 6 inches before I caught it! That barely left a scuff mark on the edge of the door. No damage was done.
The unidirectional had been given to me years before. I have no idea what it was, other than it was a weight appropriate for a primary hull laminate. End result - plenty of material, no voids, all done as a one-shot layup, plenty of bonding already beyond the crack and nothing loose that could start to delam. The original steel is now just there for the ride. (Oh, there's a solid mechanical bond to the BB with its bulbous shape. Also to the bridge which got a full wrap and the chainstay is tapered. It'd have to enlarge the epoxy/CF to pull out. That remaining chainstay steel is completely redundant.)
Likes For 79pmooney:
#29
I have only owned 2 bikes in my adult life, both of which I still ride regularly. One is aluminum from '98, the other steel from the 70's. Do any owners of carbon fiber bikes and products that support the carbon fiber industry have any ethical concerns? Bikes and parts utilizing toxic chemicals, gases, dusts produced and petroleum products. They're extremely limited in recycling and re-purposing possibilities and non-biodegradable. Has anyone chosen not to buy CF for any of these reasons? Or damn the torpedoes? Has this already been argued and justified in other posts?
Note: This is assuming carbon is even less ethical than steel on a whole product lifecycle basis, which may or may not be true.
Last edited by PeteHski; 08-02-21 at 03:54 AM.
Likes For PeteHski:
#30
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: The banks of the River Charles
Posts: 2,051
Bikes: 2022 Salsa Beargrease, 2020 Seven Evergreen, 2019 Honey Allroads Ti, 2018 Seven Redsky XX, 2017 Trek Boon 7, 2014 Trek 520, 2006 Gary Fisher Montare
Liked 937 Times
in
497 Posts
Cut off the joints until your left with a pile of tubes, top tube, chain stay, seatstay, down tube, etc. Use them in your garden to hold up your plants.
Last edited by Ghazmh; 08-02-21 at 08:39 AM.
Likes For Milton Keynes:
Likes For Milton Keynes:
#33
I don't know what Cannondale's warranty is but I can't, in good conscience, try to make a warranty claim on this. There was nothing wrong with the frame The chain/gears got entangled and my body weight ripped off the whole thing. Even if this were a frame issue I can't see how I could show it. Anyway, I've already moved on to a new bike, I just want to close the chapter here.
#34
With a mighty wind
When I was a teenager, most of the parts me and my friends broke got repurposed at least temporarily, yep, we smoked weed out of it.
Handlebar
A Canondale Killer V
Rock Shox pump
probably something else too but I uh, forgot.
I don’t think you can do that with a carbon frame.
Handlebar
A Canondale Killer V
Rock Shox pump
probably something else too but I uh, forgot.
I don’t think you can do that with a carbon frame.
#35
With a mighty wind
I don't know what Cannondale's warranty is but I can't, in good conscience, try to make a warranty claim on this. There was nothing wrong with the frame The chain/gears got entangled and my body weight ripped off the whole thing. Even if this were a frame issue I can't see how I could show it. Anyway, I've already moved on to a new bike, I just want to close the chapter here.
#36
Actually, if you think about it, it's more aero than a soda can. But really, steel and aluminum can be built quite light, and short of running them into an SUV, are more durable than plastic.
That said, feel free to ignore me, and ride your own ride. Have fun with whatever you get next!
That said, feel free to ignore me, and ride your own ride. Have fun with whatever you get next!
Never had a bike made out of plastic though; My parents never bought me a "Big Wheels" A tragic gap in my childhood.
Likes For JoeO:
#37
Full Member
IMO as always. Not trying to claim any ethical high ground, just curious about the temperature of people responding to this thread. Google and Wiki reveal carbon fiber's toxicity and that so far very little has been or is going to be recycled or re-purposed. The environmental costs of steel and aluminum are well established along with the fact that they can be nearly endlessly recycled at a much lower cost financially and environmentally without repeating the damage of their original creation. All that damaged steel, aluminum and carbon shouldn't be tossed and should be recycled. I can only claim that my intentions are that when too old and infirm to ride my no chrome bikes, they will still most likely be in a condition where they can provide someone with many more years of dependable service.
Consider the environmental impact of having a kid. All the clothes, appliances, electronics, vehicles, housing, and food they will consume, and the fuel and waste products associated. Also consider the possibility that they will have kids, making a potentially exponentially larger impact in the future.
I chose to not have kids, largely due to the above reasons. When I die, my negative impact on the environment ends. Also, I've been working from home the past 17 years.
So if anyone wants to have a conversation with me about the impacts of having a CF bike or working with carbon fabrication, you'd better have no kids when starting that conversation.
Likes For jayp410:
Likes For JoeO:
#39
I like bike
Join Date: Feb 2021
Location: Merry Land USA
Posts: 669
Bikes: Roubaix Comp 2020
Liked 286 Times
in
193 Posts
CF is being recycled, see for example This review. It discusses the state of the art for CF recycling. CF is getting used more in 3D printing filaments and recycled CF can work very well there.
The main problem today as I see it is CF production has grown very fast and the recycling channels have not caught up yet.
Re: fix or not, the modern repair places are offering lifetime warranties. A lot has been learned about CF in the last few years. I personally would be fine riding on a bike fixed by one of these shops.
The main problem today as I see it is CF production has grown very fast and the recycling channels have not caught up yet.
Re: fix or not, the modern repair places are offering lifetime warranties. A lot has been learned about CF in the last few years. I personally would be fine riding on a bike fixed by one of these shops.
Likes For scottfsmith:
#40
Randomhead
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Happy Valley, Pennsylvania
Posts: 24,881
Liked 4,048 Times
in
2,755 Posts
One of the few constructive posts in this thread was copy pasta from a spammer who knows nothing about carbon recycling. The industry was making noise about carbon recycling a few years ago, but I really don't think they followed through. It's likely to be more prevalent in the future.
#41
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2016
Location: SE Wisconsin
Posts: 1,859
Bikes: Lemond '01 Maillot Jaune, Lemond '02 Victoire, Lemond '03 Poprad, Lemond '03 Wayzata DB conv(Poprad), '79 AcerMex Windsor Carrera Professional(pur new), '88 GT Tequesta(pur new), '01 Bianchi Grizzly, 1993 Trek 970 DB conv, Trek 8900 DB conv
Likes: 0
Liked 816 Times
in
474 Posts
CF is being recycled, see for example This review. It discusses the state of the art for CF recycling.
Recycling a carbon fiber composite (carbon fiber "polluted" by, and enveloped in, a cured epoxy matrix) is a whole different kettle of fish. The article goes on to say: "While the technology to recycle carbon fiber composites has existed for several years and is capable of yielding a product with mechanical properties very near that of virgin material, the composites recycling industry is relatively young and is still in the early stages of developing markets for the materials it produces from recyclate."
Which continues to be the current state of the decades-old industry of recycling the plastics we already collect for..ah..recycling. One major problem with composites (mixed materials) is that they lack compatibility with other virgin or mixed materials. If the plastics aren't compatible(miscible) then their recycle utility quickly disappears. There could be a massive industry in plastics compatibilizers..if someone could come up with really good plastics compatibilizers(btdt). I read an article years ago about the P&G Marketing folks for TIDE clothes soap bottles were waving an environmental flag..had the statement on the label I think..about the bottle being made of "35% post-consumer waste"..or some such. The problem with that was by virtue of including the 35% post consumer waste they removed the bottle from the downstream pure polyethylene recycle industry and it went to a landfill..oops.
#42
#43
Senior Member
I don't know what Cannondale's warranty is but I can't, in good conscience, try to make a warranty claim on this. There was nothing wrong with the frame The chain/gears got entangled and my body weight ripped off the whole thing. Even if this were a frame issue I can't see how I could show it. Anyway, I've already moved on to a new bike, I just want to close the chapter here.
It is my belief that a replaceable derailleur hanger should be designed to fail in a manner that minimizes damage to the underlying frame. Not all damage can be prevented, but one shouldn't expect every derailleur into the spokes to take out a $1000+ frame.
So, yes, it may be a warranty issue. Or, at least it should be one.
#44
Mad bike riding scientist
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 27,700
Bikes: Some silver ones, a red one, a black and orange one, and a few titanium ones
Liked 4,537 Times
in
2,522 Posts
The fiber itself is calcined at extreme temperatures…up to 800°C (1470°F). That’s about 150°C higher than the melting point of aluminum. That makes the fiber very resistant to burning or degradation of any kind due to temperature. In other words, it’s hard to burn as is the resin. But that makes the material fairly stable to other kinds of degradation as well.
Mother Nature makes a similar type of material in every terrestrial plant on the planet. It’s called lignin and plants use it to hold together cellulose fibers to allow the plant to stand upright. It makes up about 20% of all plant biomass. There is no organism on the planet that utilizes lignin as a primary food source. There are some organisms that can use a small amount of lignin…along with cellulose…for energy but they are few. Mother Nature’s solution is to bury it deep and forget about it. We clever monkeys figured out that we could do other stuff with it and dug it up. We call it “coal”.
By the way, refining the materials for that aluminum can or boat anchor, requires vast amounts of nasty chemicals…far more than making carbon fiber.
__________________
Stuart Black
Plan Epsilon Around Lake Michigan in the era of Covid
Old School…When It Wasn’t Ancient bikepacking
Gold Fever Three days of dirt in Colorado
Pokin' around the Poconos A cold ride around Lake Erie
Dinosaurs in Colorado A mountain bike guide to the Purgatory Canyon dinosaur trackway
Solo Without Pie. The search for pie in the Midwest.
Picking the Scablands. Washington and Oregon, 2005. Pie and spiders on the Columbia River!
Stuart Black
Plan Epsilon Around Lake Michigan in the era of Covid
Old School…When It Wasn’t Ancient bikepacking
Gold Fever Three days of dirt in Colorado
Pokin' around the Poconos A cold ride around Lake Erie
Dinosaurs in Colorado A mountain bike guide to the Purgatory Canyon dinosaur trackway
Solo Without Pie. The search for pie in the Midwest.
Picking the Scablands. Washington and Oregon, 2005. Pie and spiders on the Columbia River!
#45
I'm good to go!
Join Date: Jul 2017
Location: Mississippi
Posts: 16,168
Bikes: Tarmac Disc Comp Di2 - 2020
Liked 5,407 Times
in
3,731 Posts
If it's the drops that are toast and the CF repair place said it wasn't worth fixing, then toss it. CF should be perfectly safe in where ever they take your local trash. But you can check with your trash pickup service to be sure.
I'd have no problem cutting it up with a hand saw or reciprocating saw to make it fit in a can or trash bag.
Remember that fork is good still. Put it on the shelf or offer it for sale.
I'd have no problem cutting it up with a hand saw or reciprocating saw to make it fit in a can or trash bag.
Remember that fork is good still. Put it on the shelf or offer it for sale.
#46
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: Martinsburg WV Area
Posts: 1,716
Bikes: State 4130 Custom, Giant Trance 29
Liked 189 Times
in
127 Posts
I had read this article on comparing aluminum to carbon fiber and well it's really a toss up on which is better for environment:
https://www.pinkbike.com/news/alumin...ls-debate.html
In other words for all whom are interested, choose your poison or if really interested in having or supporting environmentally friendly transportation...walk!
Likes For travbikeman:
#47
Mad bike riding scientist
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Denver, CO
Posts: 27,700
Bikes: Some silver ones, a red one, a black and orange one, and a few titanium ones
Liked 4,537 Times
in
2,522 Posts
Thought your comment was interesting and decided to do a quick google search on this. I do find it interesting how much more destructive mining and processing aluminum is as compared to Carbon Fiber. But it is in some ways environmentally friendly due to it's recycle capabilities, but to get it out of ground and such is just wow!
I had read this article on comparing aluminum to carbon fiber and well it's really a toss up on which is better for environment:
https://www.pinkbike.com/news/alumin...ls-debate.html
In other words for all whom are interested, choose your poison or if really interested in having or supporting environmentally friendly transportation...walk!
I had read this article on comparing aluminum to carbon fiber and well it's really a toss up on which is better for environment:
https://www.pinkbike.com/news/alumin...ls-debate.html
In other words for all whom are interested, choose your poison or if really interested in having or supporting environmentally friendly transportation...walk!
__________________
Stuart Black
Plan Epsilon Around Lake Michigan in the era of Covid
Old School…When It Wasn’t Ancient bikepacking
Gold Fever Three days of dirt in Colorado
Pokin' around the Poconos A cold ride around Lake Erie
Dinosaurs in Colorado A mountain bike guide to the Purgatory Canyon dinosaur trackway
Solo Without Pie. The search for pie in the Midwest.
Picking the Scablands. Washington and Oregon, 2005. Pie and spiders on the Columbia River!
Stuart Black
Plan Epsilon Around Lake Michigan in the era of Covid
Old School…When It Wasn’t Ancient bikepacking
Gold Fever Three days of dirt in Colorado
Pokin' around the Poconos A cold ride around Lake Erie
Dinosaurs in Colorado A mountain bike guide to the Purgatory Canyon dinosaur trackway
Solo Without Pie. The search for pie in the Midwest.
Picking the Scablands. Washington and Oregon, 2005. Pie and spiders on the Columbia River!
Likes For cyccommute:
#49
Banned
Likes For shelbyfv:
#50
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2012
Location: Orange County, California
Posts: 1,977
Bikes: Yes
Liked 1,681 Times
in
1,146 Posts
I'd just take a sledge hammer and smash it a few times at the center of the tubes to break it up so no one else tries to use it, then toss it into the rubbish bin. Always tough to loose a frame, but it happens (both of my losses were aluminum).
Pack up your sorrows
Trash man comes tomorrow
Leave it at the curb and it'll just go away
- Jackson Browne -
Pack up your sorrows
Trash man comes tomorrow
Leave it at the curb and it'll just go away
- Jackson Browne -