I have a creak that takes 10 miles of riding to start
#1
Full Member
Thread Starter
I have a creak that takes 10 miles of riding to start
Just taking a shot that someone might have thought of something I haven't yet. This creak is driving me nuts.
I bought a used Trek 920 back in May for a good price. The creaks showed up right away, but only after riding 10 to 15 miles. It starts off rather quiet, then gets worse (to a point) as I ride. I haven't gone more than 35 miles on this bike because I'm worried something might be going bad. I can start off the next day and it will be dead quiet again until I have ridden another 10 to 15 miles.
It creaks with the pedaling cadence.
It does not creak while coasting.
It starts with going uphill on the lowest gears (I have a 42/28 crank with a 11-36 10 speed cassette), then will creak in both chainrings as it gets worse and will not need any significant torque to do so after it gets going, but will still be worse going uphill slowly in low gear with more torque.
Anyone know of any kind of creak that only shows up after riding at least 10 miles? Totally and completely without fail. It *always* gets worse as I ride more. Yesterday I took a 25 mile ride. Sure enough, it started creaking almost so that you didn't notice at the 12 mile point. In the last 7 miles, it was creaking much louder half the time I was pedaling, going up any hill at all, no matter how easy. I'm stumped.
I bought a used Trek 920 back in May for a good price. The creaks showed up right away, but only after riding 10 to 15 miles. It starts off rather quiet, then gets worse (to a point) as I ride. I haven't gone more than 35 miles on this bike because I'm worried something might be going bad. I can start off the next day and it will be dead quiet again until I have ridden another 10 to 15 miles.
It creaks with the pedaling cadence.
It does not creak while coasting.
It starts with going uphill on the lowest gears (I have a 42/28 crank with a 11-36 10 speed cassette), then will creak in both chainrings as it gets worse and will not need any significant torque to do so after it gets going, but will still be worse going uphill slowly in low gear with more torque.
Anyone know of any kind of creak that only shows up after riding at least 10 miles? Totally and completely without fail. It *always* gets worse as I ride more. Yesterday I took a 25 mile ride. Sure enough, it started creaking almost so that you didn't notice at the 12 mile point. In the last 7 miles, it was creaking much louder half the time I was pedaling, going up any hill at all, no matter how easy. I'm stumped.
#2
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: SW Ohio
Posts: 3,743
Bikes: Puch Marco Polo, Saint Tropez, Masi Gran Criterium
Liked 471 Times
in
336 Posts
My first guess is corrosion or a loose fitting seatpost. Have you ridden in the rain lately? When is the last time you pulled the seatpost to check that there is no moisture or corrosion and then re-greased it?
#3
Senior Member
I would guess seatpost or saddle rails. Does it creak when standing or only when seated?
#4
Habitual User
Join Date: Jan 2020
Location: Altadena, CA
Posts: 8,625
Bikes: 2023 Niner RLT 9 RDO, 2022 Trek Supercaliber, 2018 Storck Fascenario.3 Platinum, 2003 Time VX Special Pro, 2001 Colnago VIP, 1999 Trek 9900 singlespeed, 1977 Nishiki ONP
Liked 8,951 Times
in
4,198 Posts
68.7% of bike creaks are seat post related.
89.4% of statistics posted online are made up by the poster.
89.4% of statistics posted online are made up by the poster.
__________________
Platypus gravelus.
Platypus gravelus.
Likes For Eric F:
#5
Senior Member
For creaking that starts after a little riding look at the rider contact points that could absorb moisture from sweating.
Does the creaking stop if you pedal out of the saddle? If it does check the seat post, saddle clamp, and where the saddle rails attach to the cover. I have a Sella Italia saddle that starts creaking after about 5 miles, and it goes away after about 30 miles. Shots of silicone spray where the saddle rails attach to the cover will stop it for a while.
If it still creaks out of the saddle check your shoes. Once you get some moisture in the shoe they can start creaking.
Does the creaking go away if you take your hands off the bars? If it does check if your brake hoods are clean, the brake attachments to the bars are clean and tight.
Does the creaking stop if you pedal out of the saddle? If it does check the seat post, saddle clamp, and where the saddle rails attach to the cover. I have a Sella Italia saddle that starts creaking after about 5 miles, and it goes away after about 30 miles. Shots of silicone spray where the saddle rails attach to the cover will stop it for a while.
If it still creaks out of the saddle check your shoes. Once you get some moisture in the shoe they can start creaking.
Does the creaking go away if you take your hands off the bars? If it does check if your brake hoods are clean, the brake attachments to the bars are clean and tight.
#6
LR÷P=HR
Join Date: Sep 2019
Location: SF Bay Area
Posts: 2,298
Bikes: 1981 Holdsworth Special, 1993 C-dale MT3000 & 1996 F700CAD3, 2018 & 2019 Cervelo R3’s & 2022 R5, JustGo Runt, Ridley Oval, Kickr Bike 8-)
Liked 1,316 Times
in
755 Posts
You mention it ties to pedal cadence... which leg is on the downstroke?
Does it creak with one leg pedaling (other leg unclipped)?
Barry
Does it creak with one leg pedaling (other leg unclipped)?
Barry
#7
I'm good to go!
Join Date: Jul 2017
Location: Mississippi
Posts: 16,147
Bikes: Tarmac Disc Comp Di2 - 2020
Liked 5,404 Times
in
3,729 Posts
I once had a saddle that would start squeaking after riding a while. Turned out to be my bike shorts rubbing on the saddle covering after I got them sweaty.
Try putting some wax, paraffin or some type of conditioner like armorAll on your saddle nose.
Try putting some wax, paraffin or some type of conditioner like armorAll on your saddle nose.
#8
Full Member
Thread Starter
I will put the saddle and seat post from my Surly trucker on my 920 and see if that does anything, just to cover that base.
For creaking that starts after a little riding look at the rider contact points that could absorb moisture from sweating.
Does the creaking stop if you pedal out of the saddle? If it does check the seat post, saddle clamp, and where the saddle rails attach to the cover. I have a Sella Italia saddle that starts creaking after about 5 miles, and it goes away after about 30 miles. Shots of silicone spray where the saddle rails attach to the cover will stop it for a while.
If it still creaks out of the saddle check your shoes. Once you get some moisture in the shoe they can start creaking.
Does the creaking go away if you take your hands off the bars? If it does check if your brake hoods are clean, the brake attachments to the bars are clean and tight.
Does the creaking stop if you pedal out of the saddle? If it does check the seat post, saddle clamp, and where the saddle rails attach to the cover. I have a Sella Italia saddle that starts creaking after about 5 miles, and it goes away after about 30 miles. Shots of silicone spray where the saddle rails attach to the cover will stop it for a while.
If it still creaks out of the saddle check your shoes. Once you get some moisture in the shoe they can start creaking.
Does the creaking go away if you take your hands off the bars? If it does check if your brake hoods are clean, the brake attachments to the bars are clean and tight.
As I said above, platform pedals. I have tried to determine which downstroke is associated with the creak, but I haven't been able to do that.
#9
Senior Member
Easy to check: seat post - remove and regrease or if carbon fiber, re-apply assembly paste. Saddle rails - remove saddle, put a little grease where the rails contact the saddle clamps. Pedals - sometimes a creak can come from the shoe and pedal. See if you can figure that out. Make sure the cleat bolts are greased and tightened.
#10
Senior Member
Platform pedals. I can't take my hands off the bars climbing a steep hill. I'll try standing up as soon as it creaks, but if it's the seat I'll pretty much know when I do the switch. I really don't think it has anything to do with the seat, but I bet plenty of people have said that before and then...
#11
Full Member
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: San Francisco
Posts: 280
Bikes: 2000 Santana Sovereign SE; 2005 Co-Motion Speedster; Kona Kilauea with various dorky commuter accoutrements; Mercier Kilo TT fixie; Burley Fladbed trailer for groceries, bags of cement and the like.
Likes: 0
Liked 90 Times
in
46 Posts
I had a creak with this pattern on tour--when loaded, under some torque, after about 10 miles, quietly at first. I did all the above. Plus a lot more, about everything except for checking the bottom bracket, because it seemed unlikely. And I'd examined it recently.
It was a bottom-bracket bearing.
It was a bottom-bracket bearing.
#13
I'm good to go!
Join Date: Jul 2017
Location: Mississippi
Posts: 16,147
Bikes: Tarmac Disc Comp Di2 - 2020
Liked 5,404 Times
in
3,729 Posts
Have you checked the chain ring bolts?
#14
Full Member
Thread Starter
I had a creak with this pattern on tour--when loaded, under some torque, after about 10 miles, quietly at first. I did all the above. Plus a lot more, about everything except for checking the bottom bracket, because it seemed unlikely. And I'd examined it recently.
It was a bottom-bracket bearing.
It was a bottom-bracket bearing.
I'll switch saddle and post.
No, I haven't. Will do.
#15
don't try this at home.
My nice Bianchi had a creaking rear quick release.
That took me a long time to find! I was so sure it was a creaking bottom bracket! I finally was standing next to the bike and put foot pressure on the pedal, enough to flex the frame. Oh--sounds like it's coming from the back...
I unscrewed the clamp from the skewer, cleaned it with a paper towel, then greased the skewer threads and put a light film of grease on the cam surface. Fixed! I have to redo this maybe once a year.
My older bike had the two-bolt FSA splined crank. The splines needed grease or they would "click" or "creak" at random.
That took me a long time to find! I was so sure it was a creaking bottom bracket! I finally was standing next to the bike and put foot pressure on the pedal, enough to flex the frame. Oh--sounds like it's coming from the back...
I unscrewed the clamp from the skewer, cleaned it with a paper towel, then greased the skewer threads and put a light film of grease on the cam surface. Fixed! I have to redo this maybe once a year.
My older bike had the two-bolt FSA splined crank. The splines needed grease or they would "click" or "creak" at random.
#16
Full Member
Thread Starter
I went all out yesterday with the bike. Crank removed. BB checked - it was fine. Took the chainrings off and cleaned them really good, but the bolts were fine. I ended up spending a lot of time cleaning the chain. It only has a few hundred miles on it, and I figured as long as I'm dipping it in mineral spirits, I might as well strip it good and wax it. I've been putting that off for weeks even though I bought all the stuff I need to do it. Anyway, after taking everything off and stripping it of grease (yes, rear derailleur too), I waxed my chain and put everything back together.
Side note: If you are thinking of trying out waxing, DO NOT try to clean your existing chain. Just buy a new one and strip it. OMG, just not worth the trouble and time it takes. I'm glad I'm trying it, though. I live on a gravel road and going each way out of my driveway is one mile to pavement. I also ride as many gravel roads as I possibly can. My chain gets way more gunked up than when I used to ride only pavement. So we'll see.
This was it! I knew it as soon as I took them to clean. Because I read this post, I worked the lever back and forth in my hand and heard that sound. It was much quieter of course, since it wasn't attached to the frame to really *ring* that creak out, but I could tell it was that pitch. So I did the same. Took everything apart, cleaned it and lightly coated all moving parts with grease. I went for a 35 mile, silent ride today.
I didn't switch the seats out because I tested that before I ripped into the bike. Stood up on a hill while it was creaking and there was no change at all. I had messed with the saddle and post an awful lot before anyway, because that is such a common cause.
Thanks to everyone for the helpful suggestions. Even though I did a lot of work that had nothing to do with the problem, I'm glad I did it. It's a new bike to me and I haven't done any real maintenance yet, so it was good to learn all the stuff that's different from what I'm familiar. Plus, I never feel right about a bike until I go in and check all that stuff anyway, so there's that. So, whoo hoo! Drive train checked, creak is gone, chain is waxed and not gunky. It's a good day.
Side note: If you are thinking of trying out waxing, DO NOT try to clean your existing chain. Just buy a new one and strip it. OMG, just not worth the trouble and time it takes. I'm glad I'm trying it, though. I live on a gravel road and going each way out of my driveway is one mile to pavement. I also ride as many gravel roads as I possibly can. My chain gets way more gunked up than when I used to ride only pavement. So we'll see.
My nice Bianchi had a creaking rear quick release.
That took me a long time to find! I was so sure it was a creaking bottom bracket! I finally was standing next to the bike and put foot pressure on the pedal, enough to flex the frame. Oh--sounds like it's coming from the back...
I unscrewed the clamp from the skewer, cleaned it with a paper towel, then greased the skewer threads and put a light film of grease on the cam surface. Fixed! I have to redo this maybe once a year.
That took me a long time to find! I was so sure it was a creaking bottom bracket! I finally was standing next to the bike and put foot pressure on the pedal, enough to flex the frame. Oh--sounds like it's coming from the back...
I unscrewed the clamp from the skewer, cleaned it with a paper towel, then greased the skewer threads and put a light film of grease on the cam surface. Fixed! I have to redo this maybe once a year.
I didn't switch the seats out because I tested that before I ripped into the bike. Stood up on a hill while it was creaking and there was no change at all. I had messed with the saddle and post an awful lot before anyway, because that is such a common cause.
Thanks to everyone for the helpful suggestions. Even though I did a lot of work that had nothing to do with the problem, I'm glad I did it. It's a new bike to me and I haven't done any real maintenance yet, so it was good to learn all the stuff that's different from what I'm familiar. Plus, I never feel right about a bike until I go in and check all that stuff anyway, so there's that. So, whoo hoo! Drive train checked, creak is gone, chain is waxed and not gunky. It's a good day.