Trek Antelope 830 (USA made) better than a Giant ATX980?
#1
90s Trek Antelope 830 (USA made) better than a 90s Giant ATX980?
My oldest is considering buying his younger brother's USA Trek 830 (at $80 which I consider a good price). He's also considering buying a Giant ATX 980 for $100. I'm telling him, that the USA Trek is probably a better bike for the money. Am I wrong?
He just wants a smooth riding not overly heavy mountain bike that fits him. He does well on the 830 in the fit dept. He is 6' 1" and age 17.
TREK:
Giant:
He just wants a smooth riding not overly heavy mountain bike that fits him. He does well on the 830 in the fit dept. He is 6' 1" and age 17.
TREK:
Giant:
Likes For 777funk:
#2
Senior Member
Those bikes are so old it just doesn't matter.
Likes For cxwrench:
#3
Why? What's wrong with old bikes? Not everyone cares about disk brakes, better suspension, or special shifting mechanisms.., at least I don't. Am I missing something else?
I'm plenty happy with non indexing thumb shifters and manually finding gears as long as stops are properly set.
EDIT: to add... No Carbon Fiber in the price range I'm shopping (used market at that). And to me... shaving 2-3 lbs by adding money in the Aluminum or steel frame category isn't worth it. 2-3 lbs could be overeating for a week.
I'm plenty happy with non indexing thumb shifters and manually finding gears as long as stops are properly set.
EDIT: to add... No Carbon Fiber in the price range I'm shopping (used market at that). And to me... shaving 2-3 lbs by adding money in the Aluminum or steel frame category isn't worth it. 2-3 lbs could be overeating for a week.
Last edited by 777funk; 09-25-21 at 09:37 AM.
Likes For 777funk:
#4
So is it accurate to say they're equal in (old) quality?
#5
Full Member
Join Date: Dec 2020
Posts: 302
Bikes: Bianchi Nyala, Bianchi Volpe, Bianchi Campione D'Italia, Trek 640, Luxus folding bike, Schwinn Speedster, Bianchi Torino, KHS Aero Sport, probably something else around here somewhere
Liked 223 Times
in
114 Posts
Personally I’d want the Trek. I imagine the giant suspension is worn out, and the trek is surely much lighter
Likes For denaffen:
#6
Senior Member
I would be reluctant to buy a 25 year old full suspension mountain bike. Suspensions require maintenance and you would have no idea how well it was taken care of or how it was used. However, at $100 you wouldn't lose much if it turned out to be a dud unless you tried to correct potentially expensive problems
Likes For alcjphil:
#7
We weighed the Trek and it's about 34 lbs.
Last edited by 777funk; 09-25-21 at 11:04 AM.
Likes For 777funk:
#8
Sunshine
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Des Moines, IA
Posts: 17,037
Bikes: '18 class built steel roadbike, '19 Fairlight Secan, '88 Schwinn Premis , Black Mountain Cycles Monstercross V4, '89 Novara Trionfo
Liked 8,064 Times
in
4,472 Posts
Why? What's wrong with old bikes? Not everyone cares about disk brakes, better suspension, or special shifting mechanisms.., at least I don't. Am I missing something else?
I'm plenty happy with non indexing thumb shifters and manually finding gears as long as stops are properly set.
EDIT: to add... No Carbon Fiber in the price range I'm shopping (used market at that). And to me... shaving 2-3 lbs by adding money in the Aluminum or steel frame category isn't worth it. 2-3 lbs could be overeating for a week.
I'm plenty happy with non indexing thumb shifters and manually finding gears as long as stops are properly set.
EDIT: to add... No Carbon Fiber in the price range I'm shopping (used market at that). And to me... shaving 2-3 lbs by adding money in the Aluminum or steel frame category isn't worth it. 2-3 lbs could be overeating for a week.
The Trek is really entry level the price sounds fine, and it's it's one I would select without actually seeing either since it doesn't have suspension to worry about.
#9
Full Member
That ATX is a far better bike, if the suspension is in good shape. The trek is probably running 200gs components, while the ATX is running LX or better. Plus you could get more than $100 for that Judy on Ebay.
Likes For krakhaus:
#10
It really doesn't matter what I think of course. But my take on it is that the Trek may be a more solid bike. It's also made in USA. Just my opinion. He's wanting to buy the Giant.
Likes For 777funk:
#11
My son bought the Giant and it's a nice bike. It had lots of shift issues that weren't mentioned by the seller and he didn't thoroughly test. But... it's an old bike. We'll fix it.
I think it's on par with my second boy's Trek from what I can tell. It has knobby tires that probably would annoy me a little on pavement. But... good traction and I would suspect it'd be a nice stable (and safe) bike for the bike trail and road.
It's 4 lbs lighter than the Trek (hard tail). Pretty good for a bike with shocks.
I think it's on par with my second boy's Trek from what I can tell. It has knobby tires that probably would annoy me a little on pavement. But... good traction and I would suspect it'd be a nice stable (and safe) bike for the bike trail and road.
It's 4 lbs lighter than the Trek (hard tail). Pretty good for a bike with shocks.
#12
Senior Member
Either seems like an excellent choice, and he should purchase the one that fits best. I had an 830 that was a great bike and am a big fan of Trek, but Giant is excellent too. Don't listen to any naysayers about old, well maintained bikes. My wife and I have ridden them at times for years and loved the experiences. In fact, she is riding her "old" (25 years) Trek MTB hardtail now since her SC Superlight was stolen last week, and rides it as well as the SC and had a fine time on it this weekend.
#13
Shawn of the Dead
Old bikes are awesome !! At 80 bux you should buy that old Trek for yourself !!
#14
Senior Member
I would check the Trek again for a 'Made In' sticker - I am 99.9% sure that bike was made in Taiwan (margin of error +/- 0.1%). The USA made Trek steel mountain bikies of that era were the 900 series and had lugged steel frames. Earlier 800 series were also made in USA but I believe they would have been lugged construction, not TIG welded.
Likes For ClydeClydeson:
#15
Zip tie Karen
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Fair Oaks Ranch, TX
Posts: 7,004
Bikes: '13 Motobecane Fantom29 HT, '16 Motobecane Turino Pro Disc, '18 Velobuild VB-R-022, '21 Tsunami SNM-100
Liked 1,543 Times
in
807 Posts
As I read the thread, my thoughts were that the Giant is the better bike. I'd prefer to have v-brakes over the cantilevers on the Trek. Indexed versus friction on the Trek, (grip shifts can easily be swapped for trigger shifters, thus eliminating the separate brake levers too). Plus, the Giant looks longer in the top tube and gives easier reach adjustment via the threadless stem. Overall, it's a no brainer.
Likes For Phil_gretz:
#16
#17
Senior Member
As I read the thread, my thoughts were that the Giant is the better bike. I'd prefer to have v-brakes over the cantilevers on the Trek. Indexed versus friction on the Trek, (grip shifts can easily be swapped for trigger shifters, thus eliminating the separate brake levers too). Plus, the Giant looks longer in the top tube and gives easier reach adjustment via the threadless stem. Overall, it's a no brainer.
Please explain how there is "better adjustment" with threadless stems?. With a quill stem, it can telescope up and down (an actual adjustment)
#18
Zip tie Karen
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Fair Oaks Ranch, TX
Posts: 7,004
Bikes: '13 Motobecane Fantom29 HT, '16 Motobecane Turino Pro Disc, '18 Velobuild VB-R-022, '21 Tsunami SNM-100
Liked 1,543 Times
in
807 Posts
- ease, not better
- reach, not up and down
Ease, since threadless stem changing doesn't involve removing handlebar-mounted controls. That's the biggest limitation to changing quill stems.
#19
I agree with cxwrench
With older bikes, especially old entry level bikes, the modal and components level don't really matter. Far more important is the condition the bikes are in. Are all the components in working order? Do the shocks still work, or stuck? Do the index shifters still shift as index? ...
Last edited by atnyc; 09-30-21 at 07:54 PM.
Likes For atnyc:
#20
Yes. You're missing the condition of the bikes.
I agree with cxwrench
With older bikes, especially old entry level bikes, the modal and components level don't really matter. Far more important is the condition the bikes are in. Are all the components in working order? Do the shocks still work, or stuck? Do the index shifters still shift as index? ...
I agree with cxwrench
With older bikes, especially old entry level bikes, the modal and components level don't really matter. Far more important is the condition the bikes are in. Are all the components in working order? Do the shocks still work, or stuck? Do the index shifters still shift as index? ...
I have only one or two that are so entry level that they weren't worth fixing the rest have been a good investment of $20 on something needing some help (many are vintage Euro 10 speeds along with a few mountain bikes).