Jughed

I see the Edge 530 on sale for $199, $270 with the full sensor pack.

I don't know about you, but for me - baby steps in a hobby always lead me to get more into the hobby. But the baby steps end up costing money, and I end up with the more expensive option in the end.

$199 isn't a very big leap in the cycling world.

And that unit allows you to add on just about anything you may decide to get into in the future. Long rides/centuries - the GPS is built in and you can download ride maps. Want to get on Strava - it will do it. Want to add a power meter, it will read it. It will communicate a crash to your phone and send emergency texts. It will receive texts from your phone. Want to start training - it can help with that.

Pretty big bang for the buck.

Bully4

I run mine all the time. It is very nice to keep track of just about everything. The motivation factor is worth it for me. I'm still riding this year to get to 5000 miles. When I get back home I just click on the save button. It loads all the info into the main system. Useless info- maybe for an old guy like me. But I didn't hit the couch for the winter yet.

If mine breaks, I will definitely order another. However, I've been running mine for 2 years without a glitch. The radar is also a very valuable safety feature as well.

PeteHski

Garmin Edge 130 is their entry level GPS. That would easily cover your display needs and basic GPS nav. But it doesn't have mapping like the more expensive units.

noimagination

Just get a new bike computer. If you're already using your iPhone to track your ride, I don't see the utility of spending hundreds of dollars to get gps computer. You can get a new non-gps bike computer for under $100.

BobsPoprad

Garmin 245 watch... usually don't look at it much during rides. But along with app and smartphone, get all he info I need. Phone stys tucked away in pocket or bag.

seypat

This. Lots of choices out there.

Fredo76

The Cateye Velo 7 speedometer is the basic wired model. The Velo 9 adds calories and CO2 - not needed IMO. The Urban Wireless model eliminates the wire without going bigger and bulkier, but you have to wake it from sleep mode, or it won't record your ride. The wired models wake automatically, but do not zero-out without holding the button. Either are more accurate than a phone GPS, provided you set the size of the wheel accurately in the setup routine.

pepperbelly

I will be doing that later this morning.

Iride01 

Save and spend the money to get a Garmin or Wahoo. I still have most all my Garmin's for cycling, auto, marine and other sports activities. Well over a dozen now. and they all still work. Some from 2005. The only Garmin I have that quit was a early chart plotter that was underwater on a sailboat that sunk during Hurricane Katrina in 2005 that was underwater for two week. However after refloating the boat and drying out the chart plotter, it worked for four more years. My original Edge 500 I bought circa 2010 still works, though I've since replaced it with a newer Garmin in 2020.

Phone apps might work for you. But I'd think that longer trips you might find them just draining your battery. And maybe a issue if in areas of bad cell service and using maps.

Steel Charlie

Yeah, I have those on everything - the 7 that is. I've used them since Cateye were the newest greatest thing. The 7 has everything in it that I have any interest in and they're dirt cheap so if it gets lost no BFD.

Of course I'm just out for a ride. I'm old fat and stupid and my bikes are old and simple. Works for me. YMMV

PeteHski

This makes sense if you don't need/want GPS tracking/navigation.

pepperbelly

Are the computers that track speed and distance using gps less accurate than one using a wheel sensor?

Eric F 

IMO, there's not enough difference to matter to most people. Does it matter to you if your computer says 13.2 or 13.3 miles at the end of your ride? For my Wahoo, I can choose to manually input a wheel size (when I'm on a bike that has a wheel sensor), or I can have speed/distance calculated by GPS. I assume Garmin has the same option.

PeteHski

GPS distance is very accurate, but real-time speed lags quite significantly. If you want a more accurate speed display while riding you can pair them with a wireless speed sensor, but I don't bother. I rarely look at my speed whilst riding.

Iride01 

I just recently took my old speed sensor off my bike. I noticed that my speed readout while riding the bike without the speed sensor seemed to lag sometimes. As far as affecting the resulting data for later review, it didn't seem to be an issue. My distances measured for the same route were pretty much the same with and without.

My old speed sensor was a 10 plus year old GSC-10. It was big and somewhat ugly sitting on the stay. So I decided to get rid of it. When I became annoyed enough with the speed readout not seeming to be accurate, I got the newer Garmin Speed Sensor 2 that fits on the wheel hub and is less noticeable.

Eric F 

Sometimes I wonder about how accurate it really is. There have been multiple times when riding with friends where we all end up with different distances and elevation gains, even though we started and finished our rides at pretty close times and locations, and are all using GPS-sourced distance calculations. The differences aren't gigantic, but more than would happen in our variations in start and stop times/locations.

spelger

you don't really think that thin layer of lycra will help it do you?

13ollocks

The big upside for dedicated computers/head units is battery life. I used to run Strava on my phone (with the phone in my jersey pocket - handlebar-mounted phone is just too dorky) but I found that it hammered the battery. Running it to provide real-time info would be even worse. Yes, a phone can do the job, but even a basic head unit does a better job, IMO.

SpedFast

Sounds like a simple $10. dollar sensor and computer is all he needs or wants. I have a drawer full of them since switching up. They work just fine for speed and distance.

terrymorse 

You may not "lose" GPS during a ride, but its accuracy fluctuates greatly. If you've ever looked at a raw plot of GPS points from a ride, it looks like it was drawn by an alcoholic in withdrawal.

A speed sensor on the wheel can help alleviate the GPS drop outs. Your head unit may not know where you are for a while, but by using the speed sensor, it at least knows how far you have gone. A ride buddy of mine doesn't have a speed sensor, and when we're climbing in the redwoods, his GPS signal is bad, and his climbing rate (VAM) reading goes crazy.

Steve B.

They can be by a small amount. The GPS tracking on a dedicate cycling type unit records bread crumb like points. If you are riding an extremally twisted course, such as mt. bike single track and are in a deeply wooded area, the mileage measurement can be off a bit. Riding in heavily wooded area's can cause the GPS signal to get scattered a bit which can throw off accuracy. Many riders add a speed sensor on a wheel hub, which sends a signal to the GPS unit and which overrides the GPS signal. The sensor provides much better accuracy.

Eric F 

It's about the location. I'm not under the belief that being in my jersey pocket is the same as some sort of protective case, but it's much less exposed and prone to damage than being on my handlebars, especially since a good portion of my riding is in the dirt (MTB or gravel bike)

jackb

It's not what the cycle computer does or what the smart phone does that is the true attraction. That lies in the simple using of an electronic device and the fascination of translating experience into numbers. Think back to the days before we had all this stuff. Cycling was just as much fun. I suppose there is no harm in using these devices, but they are really unnecessary. I have a simple computer on my road bikes but nothing on my mountain bike. The only difference between riding one and the other is that on my road bike I know how fast I am going and how far I went. If I am cycling to a destination on my road bike, I know how far I have to go. I pretty much know the same things on my mountain but not with precision. As Marshall Mc Cluan pointed out with regards to T.V., "the medium is the message." But no harm done if you like this sort of thing.

pepperbelly

I may not have said but this is a road bike.
I just like being able to check speed and distance quickly, especially when I am doing laps through town fir exercise.
I will find another simple computer.

Oldguyonoldbike

If all you are interested in is real time speed and distance, there are some cheap GPS "computers" available. I have one of these, which is very simple, doesn't have a lot of functions, but works fine. Right now it's only $25 on Amazon.
https://www.amazon.com/CYCPLUS-Compu...34&sr=8-3&th=1